Book 4 Chapter: Review, Analysis, Theories, and More!

On April 13th, the Inheritance Cycle’s American publisher released Brisingr in paperback, and accompanying the story would be our first glimpse at Book 4: the book’s fourth chapter, “King Cat”. This is big news for us Inheritance fans because it means that progress is being made on Book 4. No longer do we have to wait in agony for Book 4 news!

In this editorial, we’re going to explore what we learned in this chapter (though very vaguely as to not spoil it for those who have yet to read the chapter), what questions this chapter has raised, and most importantly, what the release of this chapter could potentially mean for Book 4. Our goal is to spark creative discussion, theorizing, and understanding of the chapter and what it means for Book 4 and our favorite characters. Keep reading!

What have we learned from this chapter?
  • Book 4 will begin with a battle!
  • Angela is still very, very mysterious. Perhaps even more so!
  • Angela has even more enemies. Shocker! (See below)
  • We have encountered a new king
  • Werecats continue to be absurdly mysterious and unpredictable
What questions has this chapter raised?
  • Who or what the heck is Angela?!
  • Why do the werecats hate Angela?
  • Which battle did the Varden just fight in?
  • Who is Lord Bradburn?
  • What kind of difference will the werecats make as allies?
  • Can the werecats truly be trusted?
  • What took the werecats so long?
  • How many werecats are there under their king’s command?
  • What are the “Lonely Places”? What are the “Night Reaches”? And why does Grimrr “Walk Alone”?
What was notably missing?
  • A certain green egg.
What ideas should we definitely explore?
  • The importance of Angela is now almost undeniable. The herbalist has made all kinds of crazy claims, has demonstrated powers of significance, is a formidable opponent in physical combat, appears ageless, has many interesting friends and enemies, and knows far too much. Who is she? What is she? How old is she? What role is she going to play in the final battles?
  • What exactly are the werecats capable of? We’ve seen Solembum fight on the battlefield and prophesize important events in certain individuals’ futures. Are all werecats prophets? Do some werecats have separate abilities we have not yet seen? How large are their numbers? Christopher teased the importance of werecats in Book 4 in previous interviews – is this all he was referring to, or will there be more?
  • What battle happened before this chapter? Were the Varden able to capture another Empire city, or did they fall under siege by Galbatorix’s army? Is Lord Bradburn an ally or enemy, perhaps leader of the town they just captured?
  • Four chapters in, has anything happened with the final egg? There was not even a single hint or mention of it, so it’s safe to assume that at this point in the book, the egg is not with the Varden or their allies…
What does the release of this chapter mean for Book 4’s title, cover, and release date?

Let’s start with the obvious: Book 4 is clearly further along now than it was back when the deluxe edition of Brisingr was released in November. Christopher was confident enough in the solidity of the plot that this chapter could be released without the worry of having to change plot going forward.

As for the more uncertain aspects: this means that Book 4 is getting closer, but it in no way means that Book 4 is right around the corner. Do not expect a summer 2010 release for this book. Going off of past timelines with the Cycle, we are willing to guess that a title and cover are creeping up on us. Whether or not a release date will be bundled with a cover and title announcement is not clear. When these announcements will be made is also unclear.

So what now?

We sit and wait. And we have a blast dissecting this new chapter for any hidden meanings, developing new theories based off of what we’ve learned, debating these theories with our friends, and possibly debunking other theories we had that were proven false. One thing is for certain: Book 4 is coming and it looks like it’s going to be sweet.

Shur’tugal is going to be running a series of editorials centered around the community’s favorite and most mysterious theories. We’ll explore and conquer subjects such as “who the heck is Angela?!”, the new “werecat dilemma”, the “Green Rider”, and more. Keep an eye out on the website in the coming months for these editorials!

If you are interested in contributing to Shurtugal.com by writing your own theories and editorials, please check out this page for more information. Great articles will be posted on the front page of Shurtugal.com for tens of thousands of Inheritance Cycle fans to read and enjoy, and those who have their editorials and theories posted on the website will be rewarded (with signed drawings, pictures, personalized books, and more!)!

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Now I am popular here for all the wrong reasons 🙁

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Now I am popular here for all the wrong reasons 🙁

  • Were176cRider

    @Tulkas: Dude, just please stay out of this!

  • Were176cRider

    @Tulkas: Dude, just please stay out of this!

  • Tulkas

    @aryaprincess: Well, At he bottom of the page here I see something saying, “Latest Book four theories”
    Were176cRider- But we want to know!

  • Tulkas

    @aryaprincess: Well, At he bottom of the page here I see something saying, “Latest Book four theories”Were176cRider- But we want to know!

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Will you just stop posting things about me? Can’t a guy not have his friend blab everything about him on the internet, especially things concerning his girlfriend?

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Will you just stop posting things about me? Can’t a guy not have his friend blab everything about him on the internet, especially things concerning his girlfriend?

  • aryaprincess

    hey, how do I get to the book four theories????

  • aryaprincess

    hey, how do I get to the book four theories????

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): So, did you text your girlfriend or not? If it’s personal than don’t tell.

    Shout out to peoples: I love a ya’ll, but ya never know on the internet, ya know? 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): So, did you text your girlfriend or not? If it’s personal than don’t tell.Shout out to peoples: I love a ya’ll, but ya never know on the internet, ya know? 🙂

  • Were176cRider

    @dragonpower: Thanks 🙂

  • Were176cRider

    @dragonpower: Thanks 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): This isn’t a popularity contest! Oh and thank you for the comment. 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): This isn’t a popularity contest! Oh and thank you for the comment. 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas: Dude, you’re on every page. You’re in good shape.

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas: Dude, you’re on every page. You’re in good shape.

  • dragonpower

    @Were176cRider (Guest): its ok. I forgive u.

  • dragonpower

    @Were176cRider (Guest): its ok. I forgive u.

  • Tulkas

    I wish that I was popular on here…

  • Tulkas

    I wish that I was popular on here…

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): You really have some interesting theories. But the one I like the best is the whole connected to family one.

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): You really have some interesting theories. But the one I like the best is the whole connected to family one.

  • Dragonrider360

    @Deidara (Guest): You know posting theories and asking questions.

  • Dragonrider360

    @Deidara (Guest): You know posting theories and asking questions.

  • iloveeragon

    @Deidara (Guest) ya what would that be?

  • iloveeragon

    @Deidara (Guest) ya what would that be?

  • Deidara

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): and what would that be?

  • Deidara

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): and what would that be?

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): Did what I normally do, dude.

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): Did what I normally do, dude.

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): But seriously, how did you become so popular here?

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): But seriously, how did you become so popular here?

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): Yes I must! HAGS!

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest): Yes I must! HAGS!

  • Were176cRider

    @dragonpower: Sorry, I didn’t mean you. I meant to comment on DragonRider360 being so popular. I just saw that name and just commented on it, not noticing whose comment it was. Srry, please forgive 🙁

  • Were176cRider

    @dragonpower: Sorry, I didn’t mean you. I meant to comment on DragonRider360 being so popular. I just saw that name and just commented on it, not noticing whose comment it was. Srry, please forgive 🙁

  • Were176cRider

    @dragonpower: Dang, when did you become so popular on this site? It hurts!!!! 🙂

  • Were176cRider

    @dragonpower: Dang, when did you become so popular on this site? It hurts!!!! 🙂

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Must you reveal everything about me on this site? P.S good theories BTW

  • Were176cRider

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Must you reveal everything about me on this site? P.S good theories BTW

  • iloveeragon

    i mean took it. my bad 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    i mean took it. my bad 🙂

  • dragonpower

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): It makes sense thou because eragons family plus saphira means everything to him

  • dragonpower

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): It makes sense thou because eragons family plus saphira means everything to him

  • iloveeragon

    @Dragonrider360: i just typed what eragon character are you quiz and selected a site and took.

  • iloveeragon

    @Dragonrider360: i just typed what eragon character are you quiz and selected a site and took.

  • Dragonrider360

    @iloveeragon (Guest): I wanna take it! Where’d you find it? 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @iloveeragon (Guest): I wanna take it! Where’d you find it? 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @dragonpower: Acually I didn’t think about that. But that’s exactly what I mean. 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @dragonpower: Acually I didn’t think about that. But that’s exactly what I mean. 🙂

  • MSJ

    I want to point another very small (but IMPORTANT detail IMO). I forget exactly what chapter it was in Brisingr, but during the one battle Roran was involved in, his leg was cut badlyl by an ox that ran from fear of the chaos. It even mentioned how the wards seemed to not do anything to prevent this injury.

    So I wonder if Eragon will use his head in the “Brains” chapter and somehow control a random animal and use it to inflict damage?

    I honestly think the little detail in Brisingr is very overlooked. Thoughts??

  • MSJ

    I want to point another very small (but IMPORTANT detail IMO). I forget exactly what chapter it was in Brisingr, but during the one battle Roran was involved in, his leg was cut badlyl by an ox that ran from fear of the chaos. It even mentioned how the wards seemed to not do anything to prevent this injury.So I wonder if Eragon will use his head in the “Brains” chapter and somehow control a random animal and use it to inflict damage?I honestly think the little detail in Brisingr is very overlooked. Thoughts??

  • dragonpower

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): ohhh so your saying he’ll be taken captive or get wounded somehow and eragon doesnt know where he is. Because roran is the only thing connecting him to garrow, he will feel regret because he didnt save him.

  • dragonpower

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): ohhh so your saying he’ll be taken captive or get wounded somehow and eragon doesnt know where he is. Because roran is the only thing connecting him to garrow, he will feel regret because he didnt save him.

  • iloveeragon

    OMG!!! i just took the eragon quiz to see what character im most like and i got Arya! 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    OMG!!! i just took the eragon quiz to see what character im most like and i got Arya! 🙂

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): I see…

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): I see…

  • Dragonrider360

    Thanks for the comments guys! 🙂

    PS: Yo, Were176cRider, you should tell your girlfriend about this site. She likes Eragon, too. Oh, and happy summer!

  • Dragonrider360

    Thanks for the comments guys! :)PS: Yo, Were176cRider, you should tell your girlfriend about this site. She likes Eragon, too. Oh, and happy summer!

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas: Yeah, I know. I just can’t spell Uru’bean.

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas: Yeah, I know. I just can’t spell Uru’bean.

  • Dragonrider360

    @dragonpower: I can’t explain it, but I don’t think Roran is going to die. Wonded, perhaps, but not die.

  • Dragonrider360

    @dragonpower: I can’t explain it, but I don’t think Roran is going to die. Wonded, perhaps, but not die.

  • dragonpower

    @The.one: i know but he is a human with wards. If those wards fail, and hes fighting someone stronger then him (galby) then he might die.

  • dragonpower

    @The.one: i know but he is a human with wards. If those wards fail, and hes fighting someone stronger then him (galby) then he might die.

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: That would be really stupid because, Roran has a stronger spirit than Eragon and he is able to do things that Eragon can’t.

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: That would be really stupid because, Roran has a stronger spirit than Eragon and he is able to do things that Eragon can’t.

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): You are most welcome. And the name of the capital city is Uru’baen. The name was changed.

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): You are most welcome. And the name of the capital city is Uru’baen. The name was changed.

  • dragonpower

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): what if roran dies. Eragon and katrina would feel bad cuz they lost him

  • dragonpower

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): what if roran dies. Eragon and katrina would feel bad cuz they lost him

  • Dragonrider360

    @Vermilius: That’s a good theory. But what if all is not lost but Eragon thinks all is lost (that’s confusing)?

  • Dragonrider360

    @Vermilius: That’s a good theory. But what if all is not lost but Eragon thinks all is lost (that’s confusing)?

  • Vermilius

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): I have a theory about how Eragon finds the VoS, the arden try to attack the capital city and someone close to eragon ends up killed by Galby after that Saphira runs away with him to protect him, and because of the death of that someone close to him he thinks that all his lost and starts to try to find the VoS but can’t find it and at the last second when he thinks there is nothing he can do and that all is lost he finds it, I know it’s a bit confused but I think it’s possible

  • Vermilius

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): I have a theory about how Eragon finds the VoS, the arden try to attack the capital city and someone close to eragon ends up killed by Galby after that Saphira runs away with him to protect him, and because of the death of that someone close to him he thinks that all his lost and starts to try to find the VoS but can’t find it and at the last second when he thinks there is nothing he can do and that all is lost he finds it, I know it’s a bit confused but I think it’s possible

  • Plav

    Is the new Lord perhaps the leader of the werecats

  • Plav

    Is the new Lord perhaps the leader of the werecats

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): Yeah I really hope it’s not to short. But judging apon the time it has taken I dont think it’s going to be short.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): Yeah I really hope it’s not to short. But judging apon the time it has taken I dont think it’s going to be short.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya i also hope its just as long as brisingr,because i love long books.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya i also hope its just as long as brisingr,because i love long books.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): Yeah it was. 🙂 I actually kinda like that name to. “Oh crap CP doesnt have a name for me yet” is gonna be a good book hopefully.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): Yeah it was. 🙂 I actually kinda like that name to. “Oh crap CP doesnt have a name for me yet” is gonna be a good book hopefully.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one:oh, haha that was the name of the book.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one:oh, haha that was the name of the book.

  • The.one

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): They should have done better with it tho.

  • Dragonrider360

    @the.thorn99 (Guest):

    Hmmm……Well, this has nothing to do with the realeased chapter but maybe when the Varden try to attack Illrea(I can’t spell the capital city’s name) they’ll have to retreat and that’s when Eragon will have to go to the Rock of Kuthian because all seems lost.

    Just a thought. 🙂

  • The.one

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): They should have done better with it tho.

  • Dragonrider360

    @the.thorn99 (Guest):
    Hmmm……Well, this has nothing to do with the realeased chapter but maybe when the Varden try to attack Illrea(I can’t spell the capital city’s name) they’ll have to retreat and that’s when Eragon will have to go to the Rock of Kuthian because all seems lost.

    Just a thought. 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest):

    Well, they had it set up to be a good movie.

  • Dragonrider360

    @Were176cRider (Guest):
    Well, they had it set up to be a good movie.

  • the.thorn99

    Hey, just wondering, i bought the paperback, and on one of the last lines, after Nasuda and King halfpaw got the alliance, it stood; “At her words, all of the humans in the hall broke out cheering and began to clap, including Angela. Even the elves appeared pleased.”

    Who was these elves, was it blodgärhm(bad spelling) and the 12 other elves, or was Islandzadi there, and they had won the battle of Gil’ead??

    Just wondering if they would try to attack Uru’baen, but did’nt manage to take galby, just run away, and then, “when all seems to be lost, you should go to the rock of Kuthain(spelling is bad), and the VoS will open…

    Any ideas or theories about this, i’d like to hear them!!

  • the.thorn99

    Hey, just wondering, i bought the paperback, and on one of the last lines, after Nasuda and King halfpaw got the alliance, it stood; “At her words, all of the humans in the hall broke out cheering and began to clap, including Angela. Even the elves appeared pleased.”
    Who was these elves, was it blodgärhm(bad spelling) and the 12 other elves, or was Islandzadi there, and they had won the battle of Gil’ead??
    Just wondering if they would try to attack Uru’baen, but did’nt manage to take galby, just run away, and then, “when all seems to be lost, you should go to the rock of Kuthain(spelling is bad), and the VoS will open…

    Any ideas or theories about this, i’d like to hear them!!

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas: Opps! Yeah, I was going to say thanks! 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas: Opps! Yeah, I was going to say thanks! 🙂

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Were you going to say something?

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Were you going to say something?

  • The.one

    @CursedSight33: Yeah I read the Bronze Bow. I thought it was good. But have you read the Rangers Apprentice books? They are actually pretty good.

  • The.one

    @CursedSight33: Yeah I read the Bronze Bow. I thought it was good. But have you read the Rangers Apprentice books? They are actually pretty good.

  • CursedSight33

    fantasyfan…. if you want a good book to read…. for i was also just stuck in your dilemma …. read the bronze bow, Seeker, Jango, Noman, or any of those by William Nicolas. I think that is his name at least. i always mess it up : ) hope i helped.

  • CursedSight33

    fantasyfan…. if you want a good book to read…. for i was also just stuck in your dilemma …. read the bronze bow, Seeker, Jango, Noman, or any of those by William Nicolas. I think that is his name at least. i always mess it up : ) hope i helped.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): haha. I already gave you a name for the boook.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): haha. I already gave you a name for the boook.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: i cant wait for a cover and name.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: i cant wait for a cover and name.

  • The.one

    @lamens (Guest): The name of the forth book is “Oh crap CP doesnt have a name for me yet”.

  • The.one

    @lamens (Guest): The name of the forth book is “Oh crap CP doesnt have a name for me yet”.

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas:

  • Dragonrider360

    @Tulkas:

  • Deidara

    @fantasyfan: Which one the woodchiper remark or the finishing the series one?

  • Deidara

    @fantasyfan: Which one the woodchiper remark or the finishing the series one?

  • lamens

    wats the name of the fourth book????

  • lamens

    wats the name of the fourth book????

  • DragonLady

    @fantasyfan:hey, i like totally feel your pain. but at least chapter 4 of the book is out and that means progress.

  • DragonLady

    @fantasyfan:hey, i like totally feel your pain. but at least chapter 4 of the book is out and that means progress.

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Yes, you would be able to, after a contest of strength.

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Yes, you would be able to, after a contest of strength.

  • Were176cRider

    @The.one: I grudgingly have to agree that the Eragon movie was a total waste of a $100 million budget. Everything seemed cheesed to the max, like Saphira rapidly growing up. The best part was, well, the scenery during the horseback scenes.

  • Were176cRider

    @The.one: I grudgingly have to agree that the Eragon movie was a total waste of a $100 million budget. Everything seemed cheesed to the max, like Saphira rapidly growing up. The best part was, well, the scenery during the horseback scenes.

  • Dragonrider360

    I have a question: If you were tying to attack someone with wards that protect them against magic, but you were stronger than that person, would you be able to use magic against them?

    This question has troubled me.

  • Dragonrider360

    I have a question: If you were tying to attack someone with wards that protect them against magic, but you were stronger than that person, would you be able to use magic against them?This question has troubled me.

  • The.one

    Hey, can we post on the new thing now? cause its kinda annoying to keep going back and forth.

  • The.one

    Hey, can we post on the new thing now? cause its kinda annoying to keep going back and forth.

  • The.one

    @fantasyfan: I know, i thought the Eragon movie was crap. everything about it was wrong. Like how brom died and everything.

  • The.one

    @fantasyfan: I know, i thought the Eragon movie was crap. everything about it was wrong. Like how brom died and everything.

  • Tulkas

    @oromismaster (Guest): Ah, I see.

  • Tulkas

    @oromismaster (Guest): Ah, I see.

  • fantasyfan

    @Deidara (Guest): that second sentence should be a famous quote!!! they do that to all movies.i hate it when im really excited about some movie and it turns out its terrible:(

  • fantasyfan

    @Deidara (Guest): that second sentence should be a famous quote!!! they do that to all movies.i hate it when im really excited about some movie and it turns out its terrible:(

  • dragonpower

    @Deidara (Guest): i totally agree. They destroyed the whole meaning of the 1st book

  • dragonpower

    @Deidara (Guest): i totally agree. They destroyed the whole meaning of the 1st book

  • MESSIROXX

    U Can read the chapter king cat in the evening hoot.com

  • MESSIROXX

    U Can read the chapter king cat in the evening hoot.com

  • oromismaster

    @Tulkas:ohhh it wasnt i was just pressing the reply button because it is easier than going all the way to the bottom of the screen and posting,i was just lazy and the post meant almost at 1000 posts on this page.

  • oromismaster

    @Tulkas:ohhh it wasnt i was just pressing the reply button because it is easier than going all the way to the bottom of the screen and posting,i was just lazy and the post meant almost at 1000 posts on this page.

  • Tulkas

    oromismaster- Not that one, this one. “[email protected]:com-737-983almost1000” I cannot understand it, but it has my username in it, so I presumed that it was directed at me.

  • Tulkas

    oromismaster- Not that one, this one. “[email protected]:com-737-983almost1000” I cannot understand it, but it has my username in it, so I presumed that it was directed at me.

  • fantasyfan

    ugh!!! i wish the stupidly wonderful, slowly written book would come out. also im a little irritable cause i havent read a book for like 2 weeks(feels like a century). slow library.expensive books.ugh…

  • fantasyfan

    ugh!!! i wish the stupidly wonderful, slowly written book would come out. also im a little irritable cause i havent read a book for like 2 weeks(feels like a century). slow library.expensive books.ugh…

  • oromismaster

    @Tulkas:what? random string of gibberish?if your talking about my last post someone asked me if i read the chapter king cat,and i was just telling that person.

  • oromismaster

    @Tulkas:what? random string of gibberish?if your talking about my last post someone asked me if i read the chapter king cat,and i was just telling that person.

  • Tulkas

    oromismaster- What do you mean by that random string of gibberish?
    DEvin15-Nasuada’s still black.

  • Tulkas

    oromismaster- What do you mean by that random string of gibberish?DEvin15-Nasuada’s still black.

  • Eldest

    @iloveeragon (Guest):No because that was not said in the ancient language and not added to the pack of elves dragons and men. Plus Oirk is already king being a rider would jump him from like 5 character to 2!

    Were176cRider- I love posting from and iPad!

  • Eldest

    @iloveeragon (Guest):No because that was not said in the ancient language and not added to the pack of elves dragons and men. Plus Oirk is already king being a rider would jump him from like 5 character to 2!Were176cRider- I love posting from and iPad!

  • Were176cRider

    @Skwear\’D (Guest):Dude, watch the language, people here prefer polite comments.

    p.s. I love being able to post from a smartphone!!!!!

  • Were176cRider

    @Skwear’D (Guest):Dude, watch the language, people here prefer polite comments. p.s. I love being able to post from a smartphone!!!!!

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): ya i read the forth chapter. and were finally over 1000!!

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): ya i read the forth chapter. and were finally over 1000!!

  • DEvin15

    YEAH i was the 1000 comment :)))

    i hope they make a movie too! eragon stunk but hopefully theyll make the second betta

  • DEvin15

    YEAH i was the 1000 comment :)))
    i hope they make a movie too! eragon stunk but hopefully theyll make the second betta

  • Deidara

    Sorry off plot. Yea past 1k

  • Deidara

    Sorry off plot. Yea past 1k

  • Deidara

    @iiloveeeeragon (Guest):No because the first movie stank. It was like they fed it through a wood chiper had a baby reasemble it and then they called it a movie. A film makers should wait for a series to end before they make a movie because if they dont one of the movies makes another extremely of plot.

  • Deidara

    @iiloveeeeragon (Guest):No because the first movie stank. It was like they fed it through a wood chiper had a baby reasemble it and then they called it a movie. A film makers should wait for a series to end before they make a movie because if they dont one of the movies makes another extremely of plot.

  • DEvin15

    @Galbystinks22 (Guest): you can just google eragon chapter four and it will show up its free so you dont have to buy the book

  • DEvin15

    @Galbystinks22 (Guest): you can just google eragon chapter four and it will show up its free so you dont have to buy the book

  • DEvin15

    i still stick to my theories

    ormorismaster did u read chapter 4 yet?

    and 4 more till 1000!!! now lol

  • DEvin15

    i still stick to my theories
    ormorismaster did u read chapter 4 yet?
    and 4 more till 1000!!! now lol

  • sirsimon

    @KinGCody (Guest):YEah but in a prohicy it says eragon will marry someone of royal blood; who else could it be?

  • sirsimon

    @KinGCody (Guest):YEah but in a prohicy it says eragon will marry someone of royal blood; who else could it be?

  • Uk360Pro

    @ang98320:ey all i no its 4 in the moringing heree but i couldnt waitalmost 1k and there is something new on the site!

    eragon and nausada will getg togjer and arya will ebe the next rider

    see ya mates

  • Uk360Pro

    @ang98320:ey all i no its 4 in the moringing heree but i couldnt waitalmost 1k and there is something new on the site!
    eragon and nausada will getg togjer and arya will ebe the next rider
    see ya mates

  • KinGCody

    @sirsimon- i dont tjhink theyy will get together because eragon likes araya too much

  • KinGCody

    @sirsimon- i dont tjhink theyy will get together because eragon likes araya too much

  • iloveeragon

    @Eldest (Guest):im not saying its true but do you think that since eragon joined hrothgars clan that the dwarves can now be dragon riders?

    i say this because in eldest on page 638 it says \”im glad you accepted my offer to become Durgrimst Ingeitum. it is a honor to have you as mine kin\” is what hrothgar says. eragon says \”and you mine\”

  • iloveeragon

    @Eldest (Guest):im not saying its true but do you think that since eragon joined hrothgars clan that the dwarves can now be dragon riders?

    i say this because in eldest on page 638 it says “im glad you accepted my offer to become Durgrimst Ingeitum. it is a honor to have you as mine kin” is what hrothgar says. eragon says “and you mine”

  • sirsimon

    I think Nasuada and Eragon will not get together, because it would be of royal blood.

    Though Nasuada is the daughter of the leader of the Varden, she isn\’t a princess descended from a royal line.

    We must remember that the varden is a kingdom, but a rebel faction created only shortly after Galbatorix\’s reign, about 80 years before the first book.

    Generally, Nasauda would have to have been born from a thousand year old line of queens and kings.

    Therefore in conclusion, it would be Arya, because Nasuada is the daughter of a rebellious ruler, whom declared himself leader by choosing, not blood.

    Arya has descended from a line dating back thousands of years, probably to the time of the dragon riders creation.

    So unless I am mistaken, or something strange happens, Eragon and Nasauda will not have a relationship.

    A more possible theory is Galbatorix capturing Nasauda as a ransom victim, or to discover a varden secret. This would anger Murtagh and this would make him take action against the king, therefore changing his true name.

    A final thing to the Nasauda/Eragon relationship is that she probably won\’t be a rider, nor will Elva. Elva was destined to be a normal child, but Eragon changed her fate, and this wasn\’t intended by time. Elva in reality is just a child, even a baby that has been given a curse, therefore she isn\’t worthy of becoming the next rider. Nasuada, though a leader, she is the leader of a group that have no ties to nobility, royality, there are more an extremist group, like the quakers of england.

    Arya fits both, she is of royal heritage and her fate is to be the bride of the rider.

    that will be her title.

    thanks for listening intentively. hopefully my words will spark discussion.

  • sirsimon

    I think Nasuada and Eragon will not get together, because it would be of royal blood.

    Though Nasuada is the daughter of the leader of the Varden, she isn’t a princess descended from a royal line.

    We must remember that the varden is a kingdom, but a rebel faction created only shortly after Galbatorix’s reign, about 80 years before the first book.
    Generally, Nasauda would have to have been born from a thousand year old line of queens and kings.

    Therefore in conclusion, it would be Arya, because Nasuada is the daughter of a rebellious ruler, whom declared himself leader by choosing, not blood.
    Arya has descended from a line dating back thousands of years, probably to the time of the dragon riders creation.
    So unless I am mistaken, or something strange happens, Eragon and Nasauda will not have a relationship.
    A more possible theory is Galbatorix capturing Nasauda as a ransom victim, or to discover a varden secret. This would anger Murtagh and this would make him take action against the king, therefore changing his true name.
    A final thing to the Nasauda/Eragon relationship is that she probably won’t be a rider, nor will Elva. Elva was destined to be a normal child, but Eragon changed her fate, and this wasn’t intended by time. Elva in reality is just a child, even a baby that has been given a curse, therefore she isn’t worthy of becoming the next rider. Nasuada, though a leader, she is the leader of a group that have no ties to nobility, royality, there are more an extremist group, like the quakers of england.

    Arya fits both, she is of royal heritage and her fate is to be the bride of the rider.

    that will be her title.

    thanks for listening intentively. hopefully my words will spark discussion.

  • iiloveeeeragon

    do u guys think they will make a second movie?!!

  • iiloveeeeragon

    do u guys think they will make a second movie?!!

  • Galbystinks22

    im soooooo excited for book 4!!!! wheredo i findchapter 4?

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest):9 more lol

  • Galbystinks22

    im soooooo excited for book 4!!!! wheredo i findchapter 4?

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest):9 more lol

  • fantasyfan

    i just read the last five pages of comments. WHEW!!!
    although i must admit extremely interesting. all i can add is that murtagh might escape galby because galby forgets himself and tells murtagh he did something terrible to someone murtagh cared for changing murtaghs true name.and that if eragon ever dies it will be because his head blew up from making too many oaths:)

  • fantasyfan

    i just read the last five pages of comments. WHEW!!!although i must admit extremely interesting. all i can add is that murtagh might escape galby because galby forgets himself and tells murtagh he did something terrible to someone murtagh cared for changing murtaghs true name.and that if eragon ever dies it will be because his head blew up from making too many oaths:)

  • oromismaster

    @oromismaster (Guest):10 more

  • oromismaster

    @oromismaster (Guest):10 more

  • oromismaster

    that would be sweet if it came out this year.

  • oromismaster

    that would be sweet if it came out this year.

  • Theremier

    ahh so close to 1k comments

  • Theremier

    ahh so close to 1k comments

  • MSJ

    I wanna say that the book will be released by end of the year. Eragon and Eldest were 2 years apart. Brisingr came out 3 years after Eldest. As I see it, eldest came out 2 years after Eragon cause he had most of it in order cause of the original trilogy concept. But then wanted to extend it to a cycle once he got so far. So being that book 3 was split in two, I think 4 will come out within a years time. Hurry up CP. THE SOONER THE BETTER!

  • MSJ

    I wanna say that the book will be released by end of the year. Eragon and Eldest were 2 years apart. Brisingr came out 3 years after Eldest. As I see it, eldest came out 2 years after Eragon cause he had most of it in order cause of the original trilogy concept. But then wanted to extend it to a cycle once he got so far. So being that book 3 was split in two, I think 4 will come out within a years time. Hurry up CP. THE SOONER THE BETTER!

  • DEvin15

    @Tulkas: i think he was saying nausda is the same age as murtaugh so selena gave birth to her before eragon..thats probally what he means

    * i think thats not true

    but who ever said they think the VoS will give eragon more power then galby its wrong.. because then they will be no one to take down eragon if he goes evil or insanse understand?

    wow i would want the realease date of the book i need something to keepme waiting till it comes out like a countdown date.. thats why he relased chapter 4 to keep us interested and in suspense !

  • DEvin15

    @Tulkas: i think he was saying nausda is the same age as murtaugh so selena gave birth to her before eragon..thats probally what he means
    * i think thats not true
    but who ever said they think the VoS will give eragon more power then galby its wrong.. because then they will be no one to take down eragon if he goes evil or insanse understand?
    wow i would want the realease date of the book i need something to keepme waiting till it comes out like a countdown date.. thats why he relased chapter 4 to keep us interested and in suspense !

  • oromismaster

    [email protected]:com-737-983almost1000

  • oromismaster

    [email protected]:com-737-983almost1000

  • Tulkas

    Glaedrocks- CP has stated that he did not even remember the green eggshell fragment.
    oromismaster- Perhaps, in Teirm, what he touched was nothing more than a charged stick.
    Werecat- First of all, Nasuada’s black, and second, Selena died a few weeks after leaving Eragon.
    Skuwear/’D Why fanghur? Why not The tears of Anuhin?

  • Tulkas

    Glaedrocks- CP has stated that he did not even remember the green eggshell fragment.oromismaster- Perhaps, in Teirm, what he touched was nothing more than a charged stick.Werecat- First of all, Nasuada’s black, and second, Selena died a few weeks after leaving Eragon.Skuwear/’D Why fanghur? Why not The tears of Anuhin?

  • iloveeragon

    OMG!!!! i cant wait for the book to come out its driving me insane and we almost hava a thousand comments that is also insane. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    OMG!!!! i cant wait for the book to come out its driving me insane and we almost hava a thousand comments that is also insane. 🙂

  • ang98320

    @Luke (Guest): Hehe, I read it too. “Cheep Cheep” says Angela

  • ang98320

    @Luke (Guest):

    Hehe, I read it too. “Cheep Cheep” says Angela

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): also, no matter how old a dragon is, there all stilll wise thats why thorn convinced murtagh to listen and i know that thorn is not retarded

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): also, no matter how old a dragon is, there all stilll wise thats why thorn convinced murtagh to listen and i know that thorn is not retarded

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): THORNS A HATCHLING IN A OVERSIZED DRAGON’S BODY!!!!!! Galbatorix was controlling thorn and Murtagh during their fight with Oromis and Glaedr. and anyways thorn is a rat compared to the size of Glaedr and Glaedr said it himself, the little red dragon was to fast and to nimble.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): THORNS A HATCHLING IN A OVERSIZED DRAGON’S BODY!!!!!! Galbatorix was controlling thorn and Murtagh during their fight with Oromis and Glaedr. and anyways thorn is a rat compared to the size of Glaedr and Glaedr said it himself, the little red dragon was to fast and to nimble.

  • zanji

    @Glaedrocks (Guest):i dont think you guys r giving thorn enough credit he is not stupid obviously he killed glaedr and when eragon told murtagh he could be free thorn convinced him to listen

  • zanji

    @Glaedrocks (Guest):i dont think you guys r giving thorn enough credit he is not stupid obviously he killed glaedr and when eragon told murtagh he could be free thorn convinced him to listen

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: that is a good theory

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: that is a good theory

  • The.one

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): yes i know i didnt say it was them.

  • The.one

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): yes i know i didnt say it was them.

  • Eldest

    @unsatisfied (Guest):I agree

  • Eldest

    @unsatisfied (Guest):I agree

  • unsatisfied

    @Glaedrocks (Guest):Release date!!!!!!

  • unsatisfied

    @Glaedrocks (Guest):Release date!!!!!!

  • dragonpower

    @oromismaster (Guest): release date would be better

  • unsatisfied

    Why does it take modern authors so long to complete certain works. Most great authors before this century would put out 2-3 books a year or at least have that many ready to publish if it wasn’t a timely completion of a book. I think it is very hard to write something as great as The Inheritance Cycle but I think it is more of a marketing ploy to make money the way they are being published!!!!! And that sucks

  • dragonpower

    @oromismaster (Guest): release date would be better

  • unsatisfied

    Why does it take modern authors so long to complete certain works. Most great authors before this century would put out 2-3 books a year or at least have that many ready to publish if it wasn’t a timely completion of a book. I think it is very hard to write something as great as The Inheritance Cycle but I think it is more of a marketing ploy to make money the way they are being published!!!!! And that sucks

  • Theremier

    how about if the green dragon hatched for one of galby’s men and they almost destroy the varden so when all hope is lost and eragons power is insufficient he goes and finds the vos and becomes more powerful than before and strikes back with the remainder of the varden and the elves

  • Theremier

    how about if the green dragon hatched for one of galby’s men and they almost destroy the varden so when all hope is lost and eragons power is insufficient he goes and finds the vos and becomes more powerful than before and strikes back with the remainder of the varden and the elves

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): i would want a release date.

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): i would want a release date.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): the world may never know

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): the world may never know

  • Opinonated

    I’m thinking Roran AND Katrina… if that’s possible. So could a dragon have 2 riders???

  • Opinonated

    I’m thinking Roran AND Katrina… if that’s possible. So could a dragon have 2 riders???

  • Glaedrocks

    if you had to choose between knowing the release date of book 4 or seeing the cover of book 4, which one would you choose?

  • Glaedrocks

    if you had to choose between knowing the release date of book 4 or seeing the cover of book 4, which one would you choose?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): okay

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): okay

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): what? i always thought eragon and would end up together and ive always thought that arya would be the next rider. i just didnt think shes gotten her dragon yet.

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): what? i always thought eragon and would end up together and ive always thought that arya would be the next rider. i just didnt think shes gotten her dragon yet.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): i think so does everyone else

  • dragonpower

    @DEvin15 (Guest): yea well a fight with swords is a better fight then with magic

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): i think so does everyone else

  • dragonpower

    @DEvin15 (Guest): yea well a fight with swords is a better fight then with magic

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: the Fanghur clan wasnt the clan that tried to kill eragon

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: the Fanghur clan wasnt the clan that tried to kill eragon

  • DEvin15

    @dragonpower:thanks that what i think it will come down to . swords not magic

  • DEvin15

    @dragonpower:thanks that what i think it will come down to . swords not magic

  • The.one

    @Skwear’D (Guest): i hope the guys who tried to kill eragon get slaghtered.

  • The.one

    @Skwear’D (Guest): i hope the guys who tried to kill eragon get slaghtered.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]\’D (Guest): why?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]’D (Guest): why?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): i thought you disagreed with me

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): i thought you disagreed with me

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): ialso agree that arya and eragonwillend up together and that arya willbe next rider.

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): ialso agree that arya and eragonwillend up together and that arya willbe next rider.

  • Skwear’D

    @The.one:

    thats pretty fucked up dude. im hoping the whole durgrimst Fanghur gets killed off.

  • Skwear’D

    @The.one:
    thats pretty fucked up dude. im hoping the whole durgrimst Fanghur gets killed off.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest):i agree with that statement. finally someone who agrees with me

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest):i agree with that statement. finally someone who agrees with me

  • The.one

    Yeah, i agree. i actually hope that nasuada gets killed. she gets on my nerves a lot.

  • The.one

    Yeah, i agree. i actually hope that nasuada gets killed. she gets on my nerves a lot.

  • dragonpower

    @Xander (Guest): I dont think Nasuada will become the nest dragon rider for these reasons: shes the head of the varden (who will take her place), she hates magic, and she is native born (i think she secretly hates dragons, they have already shown that the riders have a lust for power). i dont know anyone else other then arya to become the next rider. does anyone have anymore people that could become the next rider?

  • dragonpower

    @Xander (Guest): I dont think Nasuada will become the nest dragon rider for these reasons: shes the head of the varden (who will take her place), she hates magic, and she is native born (i think she secretly hates dragons, they have already shown that the riders have a lust for power). i dont know anyone else other then arya to become the next rider. does anyone have anymore people that could become the next rider?

  • Eldest

    @Were176cRider (Guest):Ya really these books are not that messed up. I agree.

  • Eldest

    @Were176cRider (Guest):Ya really these books are not that messed up. I agree.

  • Were176cRider

    @Xander (Guest): Yes, that theory makes a lot more sense than Nasuada being the dragon rider. Also, Werecat- Selena being Nasuada’s mom is very unlikely. Didn’t she love Brom, when Murtagh was like two? So then, wouldn’t Brom be heartbroken to find out that she cheated on him? Just saying, if that was true, I think that Eragon would lose respect for his mother.

  • Were176cRider

    @Xander (Guest): Yes, that theory makes a lot more sense than Nasuada being the dragon rider. Also, Werecat- Selena being Nasuada’s mom is very unlikely. Didn’t she love Brom, when Murtagh was like two? So then, wouldn’t Brom be heartbroken to find out that she cheated on him? Just saying, if that was true, I think that Eragon would lose respect for his mother.

  • oromismaster

    @Werecat (Guest):but nasuada and murtagh were like the same age so how could selena have both of them at the same time.

  • oromismaster

    @Werecat (Guest):but nasuada and murtagh were like the same age so how could selena have both of them at the same time.

  • Hancelot

    The chapter is awesome! The green dragon from the green egg, who says it’s the last egg of galbatorix? maybe eragon and saph, menage to free thorn and murtagh or free shruikan, and the green dragon is a son/daughter of saphira. BTW I think there should be another farmboy for a rider. as for great people aren’t the same as potential dragon riders.

  • Hancelot

    The chapter is awesome! The green dragon from the green egg, who says it’s the last egg of galbatorix? maybe eragon and saph, menage to free thorn and murtagh or free shruikan, and the green dragon is a son/daughter of saphira. BTW I think there should be another farmboy for a rider. as for great people aren’t the same as potential dragon riders.

  • Xander

    @Werecat (Guest): I doubt Nasuada will be a Rider. If anyone of the people Eragon knows will become a Rider it is most likely that it will be Arya. Since they don’t fit together because Eragon is a rider and arya too old and ‘only’ an elf, it would make much more sense that Arya becomes and elf thus enabling her and Eragon to begin a romantic relationship.

  • Xander

    @Werecat (Guest): I doubt Nasuada will be a Rider. If anyone of the people Eragon knows will become a Rider it is most likely that it will be Arya. Since they don’t fit together because Eragon is a rider and arya too old and ‘only’ an elf, it would make much more sense that Arya becomes and elf thus enabling her and Eragon to begin a romantic relationship.

  • Deidara

    No Nasuada is probably going to die and Eragon takes over the varden. And maybe noone becomes king or queen maybe its a republic.

  • Deidara

    No Nasuada is probably going to die and Eragon takes over the varden. And maybe noone becomes king or queen maybe its a republic.

  • Deidara

    @Eldest (Guest): Angela is to insane.

  • Deidara

    @Eldest (Guest): Angela is to insane.

  • trooper

    I know dwarfs dont become riders but i think it would be really cool if one did haha. 🙂

  • trooper

    I know dwarfs dont become riders but i think it would be really cool if one did haha. 🙂

  • Azrael

    i totally think that the dragons from the vault will give eragon their knowledge, he’ll mature then they will get together

  • Azrael

    i totally think that the dragons from the vault will give eragon their knowledge, he’ll mature then they will get together

  • Werecat

    I think Nasauda is the next rider. Kinda far-fetched, but when you think of the fact that Eragon & Nasauda both did not know their mom, there is the possibily that Selena could have been Nasauda’s mum too. After all, we don’t know where Selena went after leaving Eragon in Carvahall, do we? But the thought of Selena having three husbands….

  • Werecat

    I think Nasauda is the next rider. Kinda far-fetched, but when you think of the fact that Eragon & Nasauda both did not know their mom, there is the possibily that Selena could have been Nasauda’s mum too. After all, we don’t know where Selena went after leaving Eragon in Carvahall, do we? But the thought of Selena having three husbands….

  • Eldest

    Sorry meant Nasuda becomes Queen if Roran dosent become king (that would be wierd).

    And Elva is crazy not Angela.

  • Eldest

    Sorry meant Nasuda becomes Queen if Roran dosent become king (that would be wierd).And Elva is crazy not Angela.

  • Eldest

    Na Arya’s probably gonna be the next rider. Nasuda is either gonna be killed protecting Eragon in the last battle or Queen.

    I know this is kinda late but I agree with that ormis guy. The green dragon egg will probably be stolen by Angela or a fleeing Murthagh. It would then have 5-6 months to mature, but Eragon and Saphira (and possibly Murthagh and Thorn) would really have to be on guard.

    Roran is defiantly gonna be king.

    Elva will kill someone important in the Varden mostlikely Angela (she’s insane).

    Whoever said that thing about the VOS being in the spine and killing all Galby’s soliders that’s a really good theory.

  • Eldest

    Na Arya’s probably gonna be the next rider. Nasuda is either gonna be killed protecting Eragon in the last battle or Queen.I know this is kinda late but I agree with that ormis guy. The green dragon egg will probably be stolen by Angela or a fleeing Murthagh. It would then have 5-6 months to mature, but Eragon and Saphira (and possibly Murthagh and Thorn) would really have to be on guard.Roran is defiantly gonna be king.Elva will kill someone important in the Varden mostlikely Angela (she’s insane).Whoever said that thing about the VOS being in the spine and killing all Galby’s soliders that’s a really good theory.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): Nasuada said she hates magic, Roran wants a simple life back in Carvahall and if arya is not the next dragon rider, then who is?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): Nasuada said she hates magic, Roran wants a simple life back in Carvahall and if arya is not the next dragon rider, then who is?

  • necratic

    Eh. I think it’d be too obvious if Arya were to become the next rider. It’s too cliche. Not saying it wouldn’t still be sweet, however I think it’s just a simple diversion. Perhaps someone with earthly ties…Like Nasuada. Roran is perfect to take over the role as head of the Varden.

    In quick: I believe Nasuada will be the new rider. Roran will take over the Varden, and Arya will be killed off as incentive for Eragon to do something drastic, luring him into Galbatorix’ clutches. Makes for an epic battle for reclamation of Eragon.

  • necratic

    Eh. I think it’d be too obvious if Arya were to become the next rider. It’s too cliche. Not saying it wouldn’t still be sweet, however I think it’s just a simple diversion. Perhaps someone with earthly ties…Like Nasuada. Roran is perfect to take over the role as head of the Varden.In quick: I believe Nasuada will be the new rider. Roran will take over the Varden, and Arya will be killed off as incentive for Eragon to do something drastic, luring him into Galbatorix’ clutches. Makes for an epic battle for reclamation of Eragon.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): i believe that the vault of souls is either in the spine and maybe eragon finds when the varden invade dras-leona but it could also be at Vroengard, anyone think of that being a possibility?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): i believe that the vault of souls is either in the spine and maybe eragon finds when the varden invade dras-leona but it could also be at Vroengard, anyone think of that being a possibility?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest):dont remember

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest):dont remember

  • oromismaster

    i talked about this earlier but no one replied.does anyone have any ideas wat eragon might have toched in angelas shop that shocked him?

  • oromismaster

    i talked about this earlier but no one replied.does anyone have any ideas wat eragon might have toched in angelas shop that shocked him?

  • lawtonaaj

    i actually think the vault of kuthian is the ancient dropping ground of hearts for dragons before dragon riders and

    a green dragon fits arya perfectly also she and eeragon got closer to each other on the field of battle when she became a shadeslayer. finally she is the closest surviving non-rider to eragon brom and murtag,the three related(legally?) dragon riders. otherwise angela. she could have learned the ancient word for immortality while she worked for tenga.

    angela is proab the character that dies otherwise it could be eragon, or arya. for angela or arya it could be a sacrifical death to distract galbotorix like when arya destroyed the morning rose.

  • lawtonaaj

    i actually think the vault of kuthian is the ancient dropping ground of hearts for dragons before dragon riders and
    a green dragon fits arya perfectly also she and eeragon got closer to each other on the field of battle when she became a shadeslayer. finally she is the closest surviving non-rider to eragon brom and murtag,the three related(legally?) dragon riders. otherwise angela. she could have learned the ancient word for immortality while she worked for tenga.
    angela is proab the character that dies otherwise it could be eragon, or arya. for angela or arya it could be a sacrifical death to distract galbotorix like when arya destroyed the morning rose.

  • dragonpower

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i think the think about broms sword is a good ides. I never thought of that

  • dragonpower

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i think the think about broms sword is a good ides. I never thought of that

  • DEvin15

    Heres a couple things we know:

    The two women in Brisingr are going to play an important role in book 4

    King Cat dislikes angela for some reason

    The VoS will most likley be a dwarf created place

    What we dont know=

    *who the next rider will be

    *we know there is a Green dragon but dont know if it is the egg Galby has or a different dragon

    MY Theory::::

    The Next rider will be Arya. why?

    because she already has a vast knowledge of the ancient language. she knows alot Already so Cp wont have to go through alot of training with her as he did With Eragon. Also Eragon loves her so it would be perfect for them to get together and same with the dragons

    *i conclude that the VoS is in the Spine Guarded by this An Unknown dragon ..Why?

    because Galby sent his army into the spine and lost more then half of his army there, there has to be something important there for him to send that many soliders.

    *Angela is a Human spellcaster! ormosis said so himself but i think she figured out how werecats can change forms or something important about them and thats why they hate her.

    * Why solembum and her travel together?

    might be because the werecats sent someone after angela to make sure she didnt share the secret and they just became really good friends over the years- as to why she non-ageing i have no clue

    lol bear with me i know it long sorry

    *Did anyone ever consider that while she was under tenga she found out AL true name or maybe even her true name and thats why shes a lil crazy because she found out her true name?

    *Galby will fight eragon using Broms rider sword!(idk how to spell it )

    why? because in an interview CP said that broms sword would show up during the next book…

    Thats all i got for now i feel like HexRider with the big theories lol Reply with any comments thanks!

  • DEvin15

    Heres a couple things we know:
    The two women in Brisingr are going to play an important role in book 4
    King Cat dislikes angela for some reason
    The VoS will most likley be a dwarf created place
    What we dont know=
    *who the next rider will be
    *we know there is a Green dragon but dont know if it is the egg Galby has or a different dragon

    MY Theory::::
    The Next rider will be Arya. why?
    because she already has a vast knowledge of the ancient language. she knows alot Already so Cp wont have to go through alot of training with her as he did With Eragon. Also Eragon loves her so it would be perfect for them to get together and same with the dragons
    *i conclude that the VoS is in the Spine Guarded by this An Unknown dragon ..Why?
    because Galby sent his army into the spine and lost more then half of his army there, there has to be something important there for him to send that many soliders.
    *Angela is a Human spellcaster! ormosis said so himself but i think she figured out how werecats can change forms or something important about them and thats why they hate her.
    * Why solembum and her travel together?
    might be because the werecats sent someone after angela to make sure she didnt share the secret and they just became really good friends over the years- as to why she non-ageing i have no clue
    lol bear with me i know it long sorry
    *Did anyone ever consider that while she was under tenga she found out AL true name or maybe even her true name and thats why shes a lil crazy because she found out her true name?
    *Galby will fight eragon using Broms rider sword!(idk how to spell it )
    why? because in an interview CP said that broms sword would show up during the next book…
    Thats all i got for now i feel like HexRider with the big theories lol Reply with any comments thanks!

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: ya that is a strong possibility

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: ya that is a strong possibility

  • dragonpower

    @oromismaster (Guest): I agree. it would take the army a long time to reach even dras leon. Plenty of time of the new rider to mature. I think Angela will steal the egg

  • dragonpower

    @oromismaster (Guest): I agree. it would take the army a long time to reach even dras leon. Plenty of time of the new rider to mature. I think Angela will steal the egg

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest):haha your right i didnt even notice.

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest):haha your right i didnt even notice.

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest): lol u replyed to urself fyi 🙂 its ok tho and idk i think there is another rider and dragon out there in hiding and they are protecting the VoS (Vault of Souls) thats prob the green dragon

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest): lol u replyed to urself fyi 🙂 its ok tho and idk i think there is another rider and dragon out there in hiding and they are protecting the VoS (Vault of Souls) thats prob the green dragon

  • oromismaster

    @oromismaster (Guest):wouldnt cp talk about that

  • oromismaster

    @oromismaster (Guest):wouldnt cp talk about that

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): exactly my point so the green dragon may have already hatched for Arya

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): exactly my point so the green dragon may have already hatched for Arya

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): i just said i dont know,but they probably will and since im not cp i wont know for sure.

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): i just said i dont know,but they probably will and since im not cp i wont know for sure.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): HOW WOULD THE NEXT RIDER GET THE EGG ANYWAYS?!

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): HOW WOULD THE NEXT RIDER GET THE EGG ANYWAYS?!

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest):no its not it took eragon and murtagh like a month to go from gilead to the beors and its like almost the same distance from feinster to urabaen because the have to go through belatona and dras leona and their army moves so slow. so it would probably take like 5-6 months, wich is just enough time for greenie to mature.

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest):no its not it took eragon and murtagh like a month to go from gilead to the beors and its like almost the same distance from feinster to urabaen because the have to go through belatona and dras leona and their army moves so slow. so it would probably take like 5-6 months, wich is just enough time for greenie to mature.

  • Glaedrocks

    oromismaster: THATS A LONG TIME WHEN THE VARDEN ARE THAT CLOSE TO GALBATORIX

  • Glaedrocks

    oromismaster: THATS A LONG TIME WHEN THE VARDEN ARE THAT CLOSE TO GALBATORIX

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: well i didn’t see them

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: well i didn’t see them

  • HeXrider

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): hehe nice, but i already stated exactly those theories you came up with:p don’t take offense 918 comments is a lot to sort trough, but we are growing repetitive in this topic

  • HeXrider

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): hehe nice, but i already stated exactly those theories you came up with:p don’t take offense 918 comments is a lot to sort trough, but we are growing repetitive in this topic

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): it would probably only take like 6 months which really isnt that long,saphira fought in the battle under farthen dur when she was six months old.and about getting the egg i dont really know,ive heard other theories about the two women eragon blessed.

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): it would probably only take like 6 months which really isnt that long,saphira fought in the battle under farthen dur when she was six months old.and about getting the egg i dont really know,ive heard other theories about the two women eragon blessed.

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: first of all we dont know if morzan killed broms dragon. it only says that the forsworn killed his dragon

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected]: first of all we dont know if morzan killed broms dragon. it only says that the forsworn killed his dragon

  • HeXrider

    @Were176cRider (Guest):

    Look i don’t mean brom killed his dragon, but the dragon’s HoH’s (after morzan killed his flesh and blood dragon)

    If your very best friend would be enslaved by your worst enemy, and you had the choice of killing your very best friend or giving him/her an eternal life in egony and pain, what would you do ?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): no imsaying that arya is the green dragon’s rider

  • HeXrider

    @Were176cRider (Guest): Look i don’t mean brom killed his dragon, but the dragon’s HoH’s (after morzan killed his flesh and blood dragon)If your very best friend would be enslaved by your worst enemy, and you had the choice of killing your very best friend or giving him/her an eternal life in egony and pain, what would you do ?

  • Glaedrocks

    [email protected] (Guest): no imsaying that arya is the green dragon’s rider

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): im just trying to come up with differant ways to look at things,and if the green dragon has already hatched then he’seither just chosen a rider or his rider was killed or maybe even he is a wild dragon, and does anyone know if its possible to become a dragon’s rider if the dragons already old?

  • oromismaster

    @Glaedrocks (Guest): im just trying to come up with differant ways to look at things,and if the green dragon has already hatched then he’seither just chosen a rider or his rider was killed or maybe even he is a wild dragon, and does anyone know if its possible to become a dragon’s rider if the dragons already old?

  • Glaedrocks

    And anyways if the last egg were to hatch for Arya, how would she get it, and when the egg hatches, it will take time before the dragon is prepared to go into battle. i doubt that she will speed up the growth because then it would be stupid like thorn in a enlarged body.

  • Glaedrocks

    And anyways if the last egg were to hatch for Arya, how would she get it, and when the egg hatches, it will take time before the dragon is prepared to go into battle. i doubt that she will speed up the growth because then it would be stupid like thorn in a enlarged body.

  • oromismaster

    this probably dosent mean anything,but does anyone know wat eragon touched in the first book in angelas shop that shocked him? im also a fan of the angela either being a old rider or a half elf.

  • oromismaster

    this probably dosent mean anything,but does anyone know wat eragon touched in the first book in angelas shop that shocked him? im also a fan of the angela either being a old rider or a half elf.

  • Glaedrocks

    ALL OF YOUR THERIES AREN’T THAT GOOD!!!!! Here are my thoughts….. i believe like most of you that Arya will be the next rider because green represents her in many ways. However, i believe that the egg has already hatched because in Eldest, in the chapter Broken Egg and Scattered Nest, Eragon stumbles upon a fragment of a green dragon egg. Also, in Brisingr, when Eragon and Murtagh are about to battle, Murtagh only states that the last dragon egg is male. He doesn’t say what color it is.

  • Glaedrocks

    ALL OF YOUR THERIES AREN’T THAT GOOD!!!!! Here are my thoughts….. i believe like most of you that Arya will be the next rider because green represents her in many ways. However, i believe that the egg has already hatched because in Eldest, in the chapter Broken Egg and Scattered Nest, Eragon stumbles upon a fragment of a green dragon egg. Also, in Brisingr, when Eragon and Murtagh are about to battle, Murtagh only states that the last dragon egg is male. He doesn’t say what color it is.

  • DEvin15

    @Tulkas: thanks i guess i missed that part.. so did anyone figure out what angela is or why king cat hates her:? i know we talked about it several times but no ones had some good theories that make sense

  • DEvin15

    @Tulkas: thanks i guess i missed that part.. so did anyone figure out what angela is or why king cat hates her:? i know we talked about it several times but no ones had some good theories that make sense

  • Deidara

    [email protected] (Guest):com-737-904}The dragon doesnt have to die for you to take the heart out Glaedr took his out before he died.

  • Deidara

    [email protected] (Guest):com-737-904}The dragon doesnt have to die for you to take the heart out Glaedr took his out before he died.

  • dragonpower

    @The.one: yea i think that murtagh will change and the his true names changes so hes not under galbys control

  • dragonpower

    @The.one: yea i think that murtagh will change and the his true names changes so hes not under galbys control

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): I hope so. hey mike or anyone at shurty, can you not close this comment page until we reach 1000? hahah! only 90 to go!

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): I hope so. hey mike or anyone at shurty, can you not close this comment page until we reach 1000? hahah! only 90 to go!

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya i hope he dosent too,and i dont think he will either because i dont think eragon even would be able to kill him. plus i think he will join the varden.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya i hope he dosent too,and i dont think he will either because i dont think eragon even would be able to kill him. plus i think he will join the varden.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): I really dont care if he avenges hrothgar. i really like murtagh. i think that hes tougher than eragon and it wasnt his choice to work for galby.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): I really dont care if he avenges hrothgar. i really like murtagh. i think that hes tougher than eragon and it wasnt his choice to work for galby.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya maybe,does anyone think eragon will kill murtagh and avenge hrothgar? because im not really sure.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya maybe,does anyone think eragon will kill murtagh and avenge hrothgar? because im not really sure.

  • The.one

    @HeXrider: It was Morzan that killed Broms dragon. @oromismaster/…um,i think that she probably asked him something, like somthing about eldunari, or somethin, im not quite sure.

  • The.one

    @HeXrider: It was Morzan that killed Broms dragon. @oromismaster/…um,i think that she probably asked him something, like somthing about eldunari, or somethin, im not quite sure.

  • Were176cRider

    @HeXrider: That is totally insane to say that Brom would kill his dragon. Losing your dragon would be like a part of you, your mind, and a limb, being lost.

  • Were176cRider

    @HeXrider: That is totally insane to say that Brom would kill his dragon. Losing your dragon would be like a part of you, your mind, and a limb, being lost.

  • Dragonrider360

    @dragonpower::) 🙁 😛

  • Dragonrider360

    @dragonpower::) 🙁 😛

  • Tulkas

    @DEvin15 (Guest): When Eragon heals Arya, he notices, and later when they talk in Farthen Dur they speak of it and Brom’s ring.

    He said in an interview that Aren wasn’t a HoH.

  • Tulkas

    @DEvin15 (Guest): When Eragon heals Arya, he notices, and later when they talk in Farthen Dur they speak of it and Brom’s ring.He said in an interview that Aren wasn’t a HoH.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one:no problem. but do u have any theories on wat arya might have said to glaedrs eldunari?

  • oromismaster

    @The.one:no problem. but do u have any theories on wat arya might have said to glaedrs eldunari?

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): yeah thanks for clearing that for him, i dont know where it is.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): yeah thanks for clearing that for him, i dont know where it is.

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i was reading some of your earlier posts and u were asking about the symbol on aryas back and on aren, it was the yawe symbol which is the elvish symbol for a bond of trust. and i think the next rider will be arya,which is probably no surprise because it seems like most people think she will.

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i was reading some of your earlier posts and u were asking about the symbol on aryas back and on aren, it was the yawe symbol which is the elvish symbol for a bond of trust. and i think the next rider will be arya,which is probably no surprise because it seems like most people think she will.

  • fantasyfan

    P.S. im not talking about you guys. totally different website

  • fantasyfan

    P.S. im not talking about you guys. totally different website

  • fantasyfan

    i dont understand people who question fiction saying it’s unrealistic!!! fiction was created to be unrealistic,DUH. Now, im all for scrutinizing and shredding theories, but ditching fantasy just for being unreal is wrong!!!

    i feel much better now…

  • fantasyfan

    i dont understand people who question fiction saying it’s unrealistic!!! fiction was created to be unrealistic,DUH. Now, im all for scrutinizing and shredding theories, but ditching fantasy just for being unreal is wrong!!!i feel much better now…

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest): yea i wonder what arya said ! it might have some importance.. but who do u think the next rider will be??

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest): yea i wonder what arya said ! it might have some importance.. but who do u think the next rider will be??

  • DEvin15

    @The.one: where does it state that there is a design on the ring? or even a design on arya?!? i dont reemeber this

  • DEvin15

    @The.one: where does it state that there is a design on the ring? or even a design on arya?!? i dont reemeber this

  • oromismaster

    @HeXrider: i can agree with that theory because their was alot of energy,and because it doesnt say that saphira1 eldunari is in it. and when eragon used aren he only like heeled his blisters and stuff so it probably didnt take away that much energy from aren.

  • oromismaster

    @HeXrider: i can agree with that theory because their was alot of energy,and because it doesnt say that saphira1 eldunari is in it. and when eragon used aren he only like heeled his blisters and stuff so it probably didnt take away that much energy from aren.

  • dragonpower

    {@

  • dragonpower

    {@

  • <3Saphira

    @Deidara (Guest): If the rock is from the Dwarves then there’s a chance that Eragon will have Orik help him find it

  • <3Saphira

    @Deidara (Guest): If the rock is from the Dwarves then there’s a chance that Eragon will have Orik help him find it

  • Were176cRider

    @ooromimaster (Guest): Not siphon all of the power of the dragon, just lik when the rider melds his/her power with their dragon’s. Not saying that the dragon died because of energy loss.

  • Were176cRider

    @ooromimaster (Guest): Not siphon all of the power of the dragon, just lik when the rider melds his/her power with their dragon’s. Not saying that the dragon died because of energy loss.

  • Eldest

    @HeXrider:That’s a good theory but there are some problems with it.

  • Eldest

    @HeXrider:That’s a good theory but there are some problems with it.

  • HeXrider

    hmmm another theory: what if brom still had his dragons eldunari, and draw upon that to fill Aren with energy?

    When eragon used the ring, he could not sense the ring being any more depleted.

    So over dozens of years Brom would fill the ring with his own, and his dragons power. Oromis also mentioned perfect gems could store an almost infinite amount of energy. I’m sure the elves could make a gem perfect.

    It makes sense too: what if his saphira’s HoH was eventually tracked down and captured by galby? then this saphira’s HoH’s would be no longer under brom’s control, so brom would rather kill his dragon then let it fall in the hands of galby. So Before that happens, he could store all the dragons energy in aren, for eragon to keep.

    So how much power will there be in Aren, and will Eragon deplete it at all?

  • HeXrider

    hmmm another theory: what if brom still had his dragons eldunari, and draw upon that to fill Aren with energy?When eragon used the ring, he could not sense the ring being any more depleted. So over dozens of years Brom would fill the ring with his own, and his dragons power. Oromis also mentioned perfect gems could store an almost infinite amount of energy. I’m sure the elves could make a gem perfect. It makes sense too: what if his saphira’s HoH was eventually tracked down and captured by galby? then this saphira’s HoH’s would be no longer under brom’s control, so brom would rather kill his dragon then let it fall in the hands of galby. So Before that happens, he could store all the dragons energy in aren, for eragon to keep.So how much power will there be in Aren, and will Eragon deplete it at all?

  • Eldest

    @The.one:Hahaha

  • Eldest

    @The.one:Hahaha

  • Deidara

    Does anyone know whats so Solemn about Solemnbums bum?

  • Deidara

    Does anyone know whats so Solemn about Solemnbums bum?

  • The.one

    @Eldest (Guest): yeah! 113 until 1000!!

  • The.one

    @Eldest (Guest): yeah! 113 until 1000!!

  • Eldest

    @The.one: 36 pages and counting……!

  • Eldest

    @The.one: 36 pages and counting……!

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): they used to get like one every week

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): they used to get like one every week

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: i dont know, dont they get a mew one like every month?

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: i dont know, dont they get a mew one like every month?

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): whe is there going to be a new post thingy?

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): whe is there going to be a new post thingy?

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya it also had the yawe symbol, so theirs no way arens a eldunari

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: ya it also had the yawe symbol, so theirs no way arens a eldunari

  • ooromimaster

    @Were176crider (Guest): wouldnt that kill the dragon tho?

  • ooromimaster

    @Were176crider (Guest): wouldnt that kill the dragon tho?

  • The.one

    And, are we forgeting the design on the ring? same as on aryas shoulder.

  • The.one

    And, are we forgeting the design on the ring? same as on aryas shoulder.

  • Were176crider

    @oromismaster (Guest): That is a good theory, but Eldunari are large objects. Perhaps, he siphoned the energy of the HOH into the ring, because the ring would be too small to be the HOH.

  • Were176crider

    @oromismaster (Guest): That is a good theory, but Eldunari are large objects. Perhaps, he siphoned the energy of the HOH into the ring, because the ring would be too small to be the HOH.

  • Eldest

    @oromismaster (Guest): Maybe Angela has an HOH!

  • Eldest

    @oromismaster (Guest): Maybe Angela has an HOH!

  • oromismaster

    @scififantasylover: i agree with u about Broms ring because eragon even touched it with his mind and all he felt was energy.

  • oromismaster

    @scififantasylover: i agree with u about Broms ring because eragon even touched it with his mind and all he felt was energy.

  • DEIDARA

    You know authors write books for a reason so maybe not all of Angelas predictions come true and it shows how you can escape fate. Or its the opposite and they all come true saying that you cant escape fate you can only delay it for a while.

  • DEIDARA

    You know authors write books for a reason so maybe not all of Angelas predictions come true and it shows how you can escape fate. Or its the opposite and they all come true saying that you cant escape fate you can only delay it for a while.

  • scififantasylover

    Just some thoughts:
    1. Reading past posts where you mention that Brom’s ring is his heart of hearts. Sorry, but I don’t think that’s possible. This is because the elves gave him the ring.
    2. Does Eragon have to speak his true name at the vault of souls?
    3. Does anyone have any ideas about what the fourth book may be called? I have heard Empire or Shruikan but I am not sure these are right.
    3.1 A release date would be good!

  • scififantasylover

    Just some thoughts:1. Reading past posts where you mention that Brom’s ring is his heart of hearts. Sorry, but I don’t think that’s possible. This is because the elves gave him the ring.2. Does Eragon have to speak his true name at the vault of souls?3. Does anyone have any ideas about what the fourth book may be called? I have heard Empire or Shruikan but I am not sure these are right.3.1 A release date would be good!

  • Tulkas

    @Deidara (Guest): The dragon without a name and Eragon’s dragon are two different beings. From what I understand, it was not until the dragon riders that dragons learned languages, hence the dragon without a name would not have a name as we know it.

  • Tulkas

    @Deidara (Guest): The dragon without a name and Eragon’s dragon are two different beings. From what I understand, it was not until the dragon riders that dragons learned languages, hence the dragon without a name would not have a name as we know it.

  • Aryafan

    @TimTim220 (Guest):
    but, you forget Eragon also said that zar’roc felt like an extension of his arm.

  • Aryafan

    @TimTim220 (Guest):but, you forget Eragon also said that zar’roc felt like an extension of his arm.

  • dragonpower

    @Deidara (Guest): that is a good thought. I makes sense too

  • dragonpower

    @Deidara (Guest): that is a good thought. I makes sense too

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i agree with u about the rock of kuthian being in the spine. and i remember in brisingr when glaedr eldunari flared,after arya said something,but i dont know wat it could have been,maybe energy, or her condolences? i dont really know tho

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i agree with u about the rock of kuthian being in the spine. and i remember in brisingr when glaedr eldunari flared,after arya said something,but i dont know wat it could have been,maybe energy, or her condolences? i dont really know tho

  • Deidara

    Hmm… The “weapon under the meona tree was with the elves so maybe the ROCK [i.e. dwarves] of kuthian is whith the dwarves and the Vault is with Urgals or humans. Wow solumnbum really gets around.

  • Deidara

    Hmm… The “weapon under the meona tree was with the elves so maybe the ROCK [i.e. dwarves] of kuthian is whith the dwarves and the Vault is with Urgals or humans. Wow solumnbum really gets around.

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest):i also said that angela could be a werecat and that she left them with solembum because she wanted to be different thats why king cat hates her maybe? but on the rock of kuthian sounds dwarvish to me so maybe its in the spine..I just thought that there has to be something in the spine because galby lost alot of men in there a d he wouldnt send so many for no reason right?

    but ok i just reread brisingr and on the last couple pages of the book it says”arya whispers something to galedars eldunardi in the ancient language and he responds to her” does anyone have any idea what she said to him and what he said back? i would like to know cause if no one knows ill ask it in the next Q&A thanks reply with thoughts please

  • DEvin15

    @oromismaster (Guest):i also said that angela could be a werecat and that she left them with solembum because she wanted to be different thats why king cat hates her maybe? but on the rock of kuthian sounds dwarvish to me so maybe its in the spine..I just thought that there has to be something in the spine because galby lost alot of men in there a d he wouldnt send so many for no reason right?
    but ok i just reread brisingr and on the last couple pages of the book it says”arya whispers something to galedars eldunardi in the ancient language and he responds to her” does anyone have any idea what she said to him and what he said back? i would like to know cause if no one knows ill ask it in the next Q&A thanks reply with thoughts please

  • oromismaster

    does anyone have any theories about the rock of kuthian?

  • oromismaster

    does anyone have any theories about the rock of kuthian?

  • dragonpower

    @HeXrider: thats a pretty good theory. Havent heard that one. would he learn to combat dark magic when he visits the VOS

  • dragonpower

    @HeXrider: thats a pretty good theory. Havent heard that one. would he learn to combat dark magic when he visits the VOS

  • HeXrider

    howdy back from a heavy weekend 😀

    in that case dark magic exists and i think dark magic would not be from the AL. Maybe Eragon learns a weakness in dark magic to oppose Galby?

    Maybe eragon won’t have to fight galby, just alter his spells to consume more energy, so that when galby get’s exausted he’ll use dark magic and eragon can use the weakness.

    Just another theory

  • HeXrider

    howdy back from a heavy weekend :Din that case dark magic exists and i think dark magic would not be from the AL. Maybe Eragon learns a weakness in dark magic to oppose Galby?Maybe eragon won’t have to fight galby, just alter his spells to consume more energy, so that when galby get’s exausted he’ll use dark magic and eragon can use the weakness.Just another theory

  • JCV2013

    @Deidara (Guest): I’m sorry, but there are a lot of people out there who say thier pets are human because they like to sit at the dinner table and eat people food.

    Honestly, it could go either way, but I think its silly not to allow for the possibility that there exist multiple interpretations of the word “human”. CP might have said human, as he considers Angela to be a true human. Whether or not she is truly human, WE DO NOT KNOW!

  • JCV2013

    @Deidara (Guest): I’m sorry, but there are a lot of people out there who say thier pets are human because they like to sit at the dinner table and eat people food.

    Honestly, it could go either way, but I think its silly not to allow for the possibility that there exist multiple interpretations of the word “human”. CP might have said human, as he considers Angela to be a true human. Whether or not she is truly human, WE DO NOT KNOW!

  • dragonpower

    @fantasyfan: that is a possibility. But it said that galby bent shruikan to serve him with dark magic

  • dragonpower

    @fantasyfan: that is a possibility. But it said that galby bent shruikan to serve him with dark magic

  • fantasyfan

    CP said that if someone interfered with the binding of a dragon and its chosen rider the dragon would try to kill that person.What if shruikan killed galby.

    also i like the idea of angela being a survived rider.

  • fantasyfan

    CP said that if someone interfered with the binding of a dragon and its chosen rider the dragon would try to kill that person.What if shruikan killed galby.also i like the idea of angela being a survived rider.

  • oromismaster

    @Deidara (Guest): she could just be human but im just trying to come upwith different ideas. cp could just be saying she looks human but she could be half elf because of her long life.

  • oromismaster

    @Deidara (Guest): she could just be human but im just trying to come upwith different ideas. cp could just be saying she looks human but she could be half elf because of her long life.

  • Deidara

    You know there was a word CP used to discribe Angela. What was it oh yeah its spelled H-U-M-A-N anyone know what it means?

  • Deidara

    You know there was a word CP used to discribe Angela. What was it oh yeah its spelled H-U-M-A-N anyone know what it means?

  • dragonpower

    @oromismaster (Guest): thats what i thought too

  • dragonpower

    @oromismaster (Guest): thats what i thought too

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: i think galby probably has thorns eldunari.

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: i think galby probably has thorns eldunari.

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: i think galby probably has thorns eldunari.

  • dragonpower

    in the 3rd book how does galby talk through murtagh before murtagh kills oromis. Just a thought

  • dragonpower

    in the 3rd book how does galby talk through murtagh before murtagh kills oromis. Just a thought

  • dragonpower

    in the 3rd book how does galby talk through murtagh before murtagh kills oromis. Just a thought

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): it would b kinda good to have it in galbys pount of veiw, but then he wouldnt be shrouded in mistery and we would no his character.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): it would b kinda good to have it in galbys pount of veiw, but then he wouldnt be shrouded in mistery and we would no his character.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): it would b kinda good to have it in galbys pount of veiw, but then he wouldnt be shrouded in mistery and we would no his character.

  • oromismaster

    i think it would be a good idea to have a cuple of chapters in murtagh/thorns point of view,and maybe even galby’s.

  • oromismaster

    i think it would be a good idea to have a cuple of chapters in murtagh/thorns point of view,and maybe even galby’s.

  • oromismaster

    i think it would be a good idea to have a cuple of chapters in murtagh/thorns point of view,and maybe even galby’s.

  • The.one

    @zasekr1: when u say POV..u mean..?

  • The.one

    @zasekr1: when u say POV..u mean..?

  • The.one

    Yeah he is I guess, man i just wanna read the book. as does everybody else. (Eragonstinks excluded. :P)

  • The.one

    Yeah he is I guess, man i just wanna read the book. as does everybody else. (Eragonstinks excluded. :P)

  • MSJ

    Thorn is in pretty much the same position Elva was in. Only Eragon didn’t realize what he was doing, where as Galby did. Thorn is just trying to make sense of things, he is thrown into a world he doesn’t understand nor does he get the chance to make his own decisions with things. That was, at the leat, the one thing Eragon gave back to Elva. Her ability to make her own decision and not be forced to do this over that.

  • MSJ

    Thorn is in pretty much the same position Elva was in. Only Eragon didn’t realize what he was doing, where as Galby did. Thorn is just trying to make sense of things, he is thrown into a world he doesn’t understand nor does he get the chance to make his own decisions with things. That was, at the leat, the one thing Eragon gave back to Elva. Her ability to make her own decision and not be forced to do this over that.

  • MSJ

    Thorn is in pretty much the same position Elva was in. Only Eragon didn’t realize what he was doing, where as Galby did. Thorn is just trying to make sense of things, he is thrown into a world he doesn’t understand nor does he get the chance to make his own decisions with things. That was, at the leat, the one thing Eragon gave back to Elva. Her ability to make her own decision and not be forced to do this over that.

  • The.one

    I wanna know what thorns personality is, cause it doesnt seem like he shows any emotion, ecept when they were fighting eragon and saphira and saphira said that thorn looked..idk sad?

  • The.one

    I wanna know what thorns personality is, cause it doesnt seem like he shows any emotion, ecept when they were fighting eragon and saphira and saphira said that thorn looked..idk sad?

  • The.one

    I wanna know what thorns personality is, cause it doesnt seem like he shows any emotion, ecept when they were fighting eragon and saphira and saphira said that thorn looked..idk sad?

  • Were176cRider

    @oromismaster (Guest): Yes, I also agree that Angela could be half-elf. Zaseker1-Yeah, that would be awesome if there were some chapters in the fourth book from Thorn’s point of view.

    p.s. Would it eventually be possible for a dwarf to join the oath between dragons and elves/humans?

  • Were176cRider

    @oromismaster (Guest): Yes, I also agree that Angela could be half-elf. Zaseker1-Yeah, that would be awesome if there were some chapters in the fourth book from Thorn’s point of view.

    p.s. Would it eventually be possible for a dwarf to join the oath between dragons and elves/humans?

  • oromismaster

    this is just a theory but could angela be a werecat?

  • oromismaster

    this is just a theory but could angela be a werecat?

  • oromismaster

    @scififantasylover:i knew they were other peoples theories, but it was still a lot of work to find them. i think angela is half elf,because that would explain why she has been to du weldenvarden and her age.

  • oromismaster

    @scififantasylover:i knew they were other peoples theories, but it was still a lot of work to find them. i think angela is half elf,because that would explain why she has been to du weldenvarden and her age.

  • scififantasylover

    Reading other posts, I just thought that angela could be a rider. I am pretty sure (feel free to check up on this) that Angela on one of her many rambling speeches mentioned something about a dragon could touch you anywhere, why the hand? … So she could be hiding her gedwey ignasia.

    BTW you probably think I’m one crazy fan to be up early in the morning to post comments. Well no, I’m not. I live in England which is about 6 hours in front of you guys.

  • scififantasylover

    Reading other posts, I just thought that angela could be a rider. I am pretty sure (feel free to check up on this) that Angela on one of her many rambling speeches mentioned something about a dragon could touch you anywhere, why the hand? … So she could be hiding her gedwey ignasia.BTW you probably think I’m one crazy fan to be up early in the morning to post comments. Well no, I’m not. I live in England which is about 6 hours in front of you guys.

  • scififantasylover

    OK, this is my own theory….
    The green dragon does not become important until the end (what happens in the future) and its Rider is Roran and Katrina’s child!

    I think that paolini has already finished the fourth book and the publishers are leaving us hanging. Anyway, I know for certain that things won’t be as they seem, cp will keep us hanging.

  • scififantasylover

    OK, this is my own theory…. The green dragon does not become important until the end (what happens in the future) and its Rider is Roran and Katrina’s child!I think that paolini has already finished the fourth book and the publishers are leaving us hanging. Anyway, I know for certain that things won’t be as they seem, cp will keep us hanging.

  • scififantasylover

    @oromismaster (Guest): and @Were176cRider (Guest) Actually these were all theories that people said earlier on in this post. I was just summarising them.

  • scififantasylover

    @oromismaster (Guest): and @Were176cRider (Guest) Actually these were all theories that people said earlier on in this post. I was just summarising them.

  • scififantasylover

    @oromismaster (Guest): and @Were176cRider (Guest) Actually these were all theories that people said earlier on in this post. I was just summarising them.

  • Deidara

    @dragonpower: Maybe gilderlan the [old] wise.

  • Deidara

    @dragonpower: Maybe gilderlan the [old] wise.

  • Deidara

    You know just because there is a green cover dragon doesn’t mean the dragon HAS to be green. Who knows maybe greenie was somones old dragon seen in a memory.

  • Deidara

    You know just because there is a green cover dragon doesn’t mean the dragon HAS to be green. Who knows maybe greenie was somones old dragon seen in a memory.

  • Deidara

    You know just because there is a green cover dragon doesn’t mean the dragon HAS to be green. Who knows maybe greenie was somones old dragon seen in a memory.

  • Ang98320

    @Ang98320 (Guest):

    SO EXCITED!!! REPLAY IF YOU ARE TOO!!

  • Ang98320

    @Ang98320 (Guest):

    SO EXCITED!!! REPLAY IF YOU ARE TOO!!

  • Ang98320

    @Ang98320 (Guest):

    SO EXCITED!!! REPLAY IF YOU ARE TOO!!

  • Ang98320

    I’m guessing that Arya is going to be the next rider. Angela is probably half elf or a rider who lost her dragon. That would explain the pysical feats and magic. The egg will not hatch for anyone on Galby’s side or that will make the book uneven. Angela probably fitched the egg and got caught by the werecat. If Angela was a rider, then she probably upseted the were-king . Hope Book 4 is released soon. CAIO!

  • Ang98320

    I’m guessing that Arya is going to be the next rider. Angela is probably half elf or a rider who lost her dragon. That would explain the pysical feats and magic. The egg will not hatch for anyone on Galby’s side or that will make the book uneven. Angela probably fitched the egg and got caught by the werecat. If Angela was a rider, then she probably upseted the were-king . Hope Book 4 is released soon. CAIO!

  • Ang98320

    I’m guessing that Arya is going to be the next rider. Angela is probably half elf or a rider who lost her dragon. That would explain the pysical feats and magic. The egg will not hatch for anyone on Galby’s side or that will make the book uneven. Angela probably fitched the egg and got caught by the werecat. If Angela was a rider, then she probably upseted the were-king . Hope Book 4 is released soon. CAIO!

  • Deidara

    @dragonpower:He already said he would have some voiced by murtagh

  • Deidara

    @dragonpower:He already said he would have some voiced by murtagh

  • Deidara

    @dragonpower:He already said he would have some voiced by murtagh

  • 7th

    @The.one: In the books it says that galby killed the dragons rider. and used dark magic to fight seal them together.

  • 7th

    @The.one: In the books it says that galby killed the dragons rider. and used dark magic to fight seal them together.

  • 7th

    @The.one: In the books it says that galby killed the dragons rider. and used dark magic to fight seal them together.

  • dragonpower

    @zasekr1: maybe cp makes some chapters that are into Murtagh’s mind. Like how he writes as saphira and Narsuada

  • dragonpower

    @zasekr1: maybe cp makes some chapters that are into Murtagh’s mind. Like how he writes as saphira and Narsuada

  • dragonpower

    @zasekr1: maybe cp makes some chapters that are into Murtagh’s mind. Like how he writes as saphira and Narsuada

  • zasekr1

    i dont know if anyone has already thought of this but since cp said in the latest Q’A’S thatwe would get a view into galby’s and murtaghs conflict so to speak everyone has assumed that it will hopefully be murtagh’s POV but what if it was thorn’s???? because he sauggested that it wouldnt be murtaghs POV directly. that would be pretty cool .. any comments?

  • zasekr1

    i dont know if anyone has already thought of this but since cp said in the latest Q’A’S thatwe would get a view into galby’s and murtaghs conflict so to speak everyone has assumed that it will hopefully be murtagh’s POV but what if it was thorn’s???? because he sauggested that it wouldnt be murtaghs POV directly. that would be pretty cool .. any comments?

  • zasekr1

    i dont know if anyone has already thought of this but since cp said in the latest Q’A’S thatwe would get a view into galby’s and murtaghs conflict so to speak everyone has assumed that it will hopefully be murtagh’s POV but what if it was thorn’s???? because he sauggested that it wouldnt be murtaghs POV directly. that would be pretty cool .. any comments?

  • dragonpower

    @Deidara (Guest): that is a possibility, but what character would he be. I think angela is either half elf or a rider that survived.

  • dragonpower

    @Deidara (Guest): that is a possibility, but what character would he be. I think angela is either half elf or a rider that survived.

  • dragonpower

    @Deidara (Guest): that is a possibility, but what character would he be. I think angela is either half elf or a rider that survived.

  • Deidara

    Maybe Eragon one survied a long time and became a member of the forsworn. Islansadi said quote “dragons name can not be uttered in this or any language” so maybe his name was banished like the rest of the forsworns dragons. Any thoughts?

  • Deidara

    Maybe Eragon one survied a long time and became a member of the forsworn. Islansadi said quote “dragons name can not be uttered in this or any language” so maybe his name was banished like the rest of the forsworns dragons. Any thoughts?

  • Deidara

    Maybe Eragon one survied a long time and became a member of the forsworn. Islansadi said quote “dragons name can not be uttered in this or any language” so maybe his name was banished like the rest of the forsworns dragons. Any thoughts?

  • MSJ

    @The.one: I’m not sure who tells Eragon of this, but somewhere it states the a dragon will wait until the person it choices to be its rider comes into contact with the egg. BUT there is an event we have not been told too many details about.

    What/who was behind the “Scattered nest/shattered egg” incident? When Saphira first hears of the Razac in Eragon, she takes Eragon hostage (kinda, lol) and just curses out “Egg breakers, murderers, etc”. What does she know? I don’t believe we ever really found out what that was all about.

  • MSJ

    @The.one: I’m not sure who tells Eragon of this, but somewhere it states the a dragon will wait until the person it choices to be its rider comes into contact with the egg. BUT there is an event we have not been told too many details about. What/who was behind the “Scattered nest/shattered egg” incident? When Saphira first hears of the Razac in Eragon, she takes Eragon hostage (kinda, lol) and just curses out “Egg breakers, murderers, etc”. What does she know? I don’t believe we ever really found out what that was all about.

  • MSJ

    @The.one: I’m not sure who tells Eragon of this, but somewhere it states the a dragon will wait until the person it choices to be its rider comes into contact with the egg. BUT there is an event we have not been told too many details about. What/who was behind the “Scattered nest/shattered egg” incident? When Saphira first hears of the Razac in Eragon, she takes Eragon hostage (kinda, lol) and just curses out “Egg breakers, murderers, etc”. What does she know? I don’t believe we ever really found out what that was all about.

  • dragonpower

    @The.one: i think so. Isn’t that how galby got his 2nd dragon

  • dragonpower

    @The.one: i think so. Isn’t that how galby got his 2nd dragon

  • dragonpower

    @The.one: i think so. Isn’t that how galby got his 2nd dragon

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: hm..it didnt seem to make his power that much stronger when he fought in feinster…I still want to know and no one has commented last time i posted this, but can an egg be opened with magic?

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: hm..it didnt seem to make his power that much stronger when he fought in feinster…I still want to know and no one has commented last time i posted this, but can an egg be opened with magic?

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: hm..it didnt seem to make his power that much stronger when he fought in feinster…I still want to know and no one has commented last time i posted this, but can an egg be opened with magic?

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: thats a good theory and the only one i hav heard

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: thats a good theory and the only one i hav heard

  • oromismaster

    @dragonpower: thats a good theory and the only one i hav heard

  • dragonpower

    another thing to think about. What do you think the meona tree wants from eragon. Also the pain in his stomach, I think that the tree supplied some of the magic to make him half-elf. She wants that magic back after he kills galby

  • dragonpower

    another thing to think about. What do you think the meona tree wants from eragon. Also the pain in his stomach, I think that the tree supplied some of the magic to make him half-elf. She wants that magic back after he kills galby

  • dragonpower

    another thing to think about. What do you think the meona tree wants from eragon. Also the pain in his stomach, I think that the tree supplied some of the magic to make him half-elf. She wants that magic back after he kills galby

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: um…omgosh, i have no idea!

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: um…omgosh, i have no idea!

  • The.one

    @dragonpower: um…omgosh, i have no idea!

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: it was arya in elest who told eragon about the man who killed his son.but i agree with u about the dwaef rider because he isn\’t a dwarf in blood

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: it was arya in elest who told eragon about the man who killed his son.but i agree with u about the dwaef rider because he isn’t a dwarf in blood

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: it was arya in elest who told eragon about the man who killed his son.but i agree with u about the dwaef rider because he isn’t a dwarf in blood

  • dragonpower

    I agree with a lot of people with many of these theories. I agree that arya is going to be the next rider and that roran is going to be the next king. Just a question. What about sloan. Does anyone have any comment on him?

  • dragonpower

    I agree with a lot of people with many of these theories. I agree that arya is going to be the next rider and that roran is going to be the next king. Just a question. What about sloan. Does anyone have any comment on him?

  • dragonpower

    I agree with a lot of people with many of these theories. I agree that arya is going to be the next rider and that roran is going to be the next king. Just a question. What about sloan. Does anyone have any comment on him?

  • The.one

    @scififantasylover: well, there is a falt, there was no spell put on eragon. in fact, he might not leave at all, because, if i remember correctly, eragon asked someone,( im thinking it was……oromis,) something to do with fourtune telling. and the person said that a man was told that he would kill his son in battle, and in order to save his son he killed himself, and his son didnt die. And i dont think that the dwarves can be dagon riders cause even though eragon is part of that clan, he is not of there blood, and the dwarves were not part of the spell, so his part of being in there clan has nothing to do with them being dragon riders. just a thought, please comment.

  • The.one

    @scififantasylover: well, there is a falt, there was no spell put on eragon. in fact, he might not leave at all, because, if i remember correctly, eragon asked someone,( im thinking it was……oromis,) something to do with fourtune telling. and the person said that a man was told that he would kill his son in battle, and in order to save his son he killed himself, and his son didnt die. And i dont think that the dwarves can be dagon riders cause even though eragon is part of that clan, he is not of there blood, and the dwarves were not part of the spell, so his part of being in there clan has nothing to do with them being dragon riders. just a thought, please comment.

  • The.one

    @scififantasylover: well, there is a falt, there was no spell put on eragon. in fact, he might not leave at all, because, if i remember correctly, eragon asked someone,( im thinking it was……oromis,) something to do with fourtune telling. and the person said that a man was told that he would kill his son in battle, and in order to save his son he killed himself, and his son didnt die. And i dont think that the dwarves can be dagon riders cause even though eragon is part of that clan, he is not of there blood, and the dwarves were not part of the spell, so his part of being in there clan has nothing to do with them being dragon riders. just a thought, please comment.

  • Were176cRider

    @scififantasylover: Wow, all those theories are possible and concise. You are now my favorite poster on this site. 🙂

  • Were176cRider

    @scififantasylover: Wow, all those theories are possible and concise. You are now my favorite poster on this site. 🙂

  • Were176cRider

    @scififantasylover: Wow, all those theories are possible and concise. You are now my favorite poster on this site. 🙂

  • oromismaster

    @scififantasylover: wow thats alot of theories.

  • oromismaster

    @scififantasylover: wow thats alot of theories.

  • oromismaster

    @scififantasylover: wow thats alot of theories.

  • scififantasylover

    Because I am such a huge fan of the inheritance cycle. I thought I’d read all the past comments. Its taking ages… I am working backwards and I am only on page 26.
    Anyway I thought I’d summarise the theories the fans have so you don’t have to trawl through the pages.

    FOURTH BOOK THEORIES: PART ONE
    • Angela: half elf? Enemy of the Varden? The Green dragon’s rider? Was she a rider before? Werecats are her enemies? Galbatorix’s wife? Descendent of the grey folk? Blessing gone wrong (like Elva)? Fallen in love with Solembum? Tricked of a precious diamond by the king of werecats? One of the dwarven gods? A werecat in the shape of the human? (She must be crucial)
    • Arya: the green dragon’s rider?
    • Murtagh and Thorn: break their oath? Killed by Galbatorix? Chapters from his point of view?
    • Roran: becomes King? The next rider?
    • Dwarves can be riders now Eragon is part of Durgrimst Ingeitum?
    • The two women Angela made Eragon bless (the ones that refused to give their names): on a quest to find the egg?
    • Eragon: won’t be killed by Galbatorix? Leaves with a mystery girl and the green dragon? Has to leave Alagaesia forever because of a spell put on him?
    • Galbatorix: killed by Brisingr?
    • Half of Galbatorix’s army vanished in the Spine because of the werecats?
    • The whole elven race leaves? (Like Lord of the Rings, please no!)
    • King Orrin: the next rider?
    • Rock of Kuthian/Vault of Souls: the same place? The werecats know where they are? Hidden in the dwarves’ mountains? On Vroengard?
    More later

  • scififantasylover

    Because I am such a huge fan of the inheritance cycle. I thought I’d read all the past comments. Its taking ages… I am working backwards and I am only on page 26. Anyway I thought I’d summarise the theories the fans have so you don’t have to trawl through the pages.FOURTH BOOK THEORIES: PART ONE• Angela: half elf? Enemy of the Varden? The Green dragon’s rider? Was she a rider before? Werecats are her enemies? Galbatorix’s wife? Descendent of the grey folk? Blessing gone wrong (like Elva)? Fallen in love with Solembum? Tricked of a precious diamond by the king of werecats? One of the dwarven gods? A werecat in the shape of the human? (She must be crucial)• Arya: the green dragon’s rider? • Murtagh and Thorn: break their oath? Killed by Galbatorix? Chapters from his point of view?• Roran: becomes King? The next rider? • Dwarves can be riders now Eragon is part of Durgrimst Ingeitum?• The two women Angela made Eragon bless (the ones that refused to give their names): on a quest to find the egg?• Eragon: won’t be killed by Galbatorix? Leaves with a mystery girl and the green dragon? Has to leave Alagaesia forever because of a spell put on him?• Galbatorix: killed by Brisingr?• Half of Galbatorix’s army vanished in the Spine because of the werecats?• The whole elven race leaves? (Like Lord of the Rings, please no!)• King Orrin: the next rider? • Rock of Kuthian/Vault of Souls: the same place? The werecats know where they are? Hidden in the dwarves’ mountains? On Vroengard?More later

  • scififantasylover

    Because I am such a huge fan of the inheritance cycle. I thought I’d read all the past comments. Its taking ages… I am working backwards and I am only on page 26. Anyway I thought I’d summarise the theories the fans have so you don’t have to trawl through the pages.FOURTH BOOK THEORIES: PART ONE• Angela: half elf? Enemy of the Varden? The Green dragon’s rider? Was she a rider before? Werecats are her enemies? Galbatorix’s wife? Descendent of the grey folk? Blessing gone wrong (like Elva)? Fallen in love with Solembum? Tricked of a precious diamond by the king of werecats? One of the dwarven gods? A werecat in the shape of the human? (She must be crucial)• Arya: the green dragon’s rider? • Murtagh and Thorn: break their oath? Killed by Galbatorix? Chapters from his point of view?• Roran: becomes King? The next rider? • Dwarves can be riders now Eragon is part of Durgrimst Ingeitum?• The two women Angela made Eragon bless (the ones that refused to give their names): on a quest to find the egg?• Eragon: won’t be killed by Galbatorix? Leaves with a mystery girl and the green dragon? Has to leave Alagaesia forever because of a spell put on him?• Galbatorix: killed by Brisingr?• Half of Galbatorix’s army vanished in the Spine because of the werecats?• The whole elven race leaves? (Like Lord of the Rings, please no!)• King Orrin: the next rider? • Rock of Kuthian/Vault of Souls: the same place? The werecats know where they are? Hidden in the dwarves’ mountains? On Vroengard?More later

  • Deidara

    @oromismaster (Guest): He probably wanted attention

  • Deidara

    @oromismaster (Guest): He probably wanted attention

  • Deidara

    @oromismaster (Guest): He probably wanted attention

  • scififantasylover

    @oromismaster (Guest): Good question about the person who doesn’t like the books.

  • scififantasylover

    @oromismaster (Guest): Good question about the person who doesn’t like the books.

  • scififantasylover

    @oromismaster (Guest): Good question about the person who doesn’t like the books.

  • scififantasylover

    @JCV2013 (Guest): Oh yeah, I forgot about that. So much goes on in the books. Sorry

  • scififantasylover

    @JCV2013 (Guest): Oh yeah, I forgot about that. So much goes on in the books. Sorry

  • scififantasylover

    @JCV2013 (Guest): Oh yeah, I forgot about that. So much goes on in the books. Sorry

  • Eldest

    @The.one:Yo I agree that guy’s a hypocrite. (That’s the most I’m gonna say, don’t want to get banned.)

  • Eldest

    @The.one:Yo I agree that guy’s a hypocrite. (That’s the most I’m gonna say, don’t want to get banned.)

  • Eldest

    @The.one:Yo I agree that guy’s a hypocrite. (That’s the most I’m gonna say, don’t want to get banned.)

  • Dragonrider360

    Hey, wouldn’t it be cool for CP to write a book in a wild dragon’s point of view during the Fall? 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    Hey, wouldn’t it be cool for CP to write a book in a wild dragon’s point of view during the Fall? 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    Hey, wouldn’t it be cool for CP to write a book in a wild dragon’s point of view during the Fall? 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    Thank you Were176crider! Don’t be haten’!!

  • Dragonrider360

    Thank you Were176crider! Don’t be haten’!!

  • Dragonrider360

    Thank you Were176crider! Don’t be haten’!!

  • oromismaster

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): if u hate it so much why r u on this site?

  • oromismaster

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): if u hate it so much why r u on this site?

  • oromismaster

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): if u hate it so much why r u on this site?

  • The.one

    @7th (Guest): hahah…what is with the marna people?

  • The.one

    @7th (Guest): hahah…what is with the marna people?

  • The.one

    @7th (Guest): hahah…what is with the marna people?

  • The.one

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): If u dont like it then dont post it! And if we dont all have a life cause we like this book, and then u just come here and post that, how do u have a life prey tell? and im not like a die hard fand but i really like these books.

  • The.one

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): If u dont like it then dont post it! And if we dont all have a life cause we like this book, and then u just come here and post that, how do u have a life prey tell? and im not like a die hard fand but i really like these books.

  • The.one

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): If u dont like it then dont post it! And if we dont all have a life cause we like this book, and then u just come here and post that, how do u have a life prey tell? and im not like a die hard fand but i really like these books.

  • Were176cRider

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): It would be wise of you not to bash that book on this site. The people who comment here are very kind and accepting for the most part. But, there are some here who are true die-hard fans that are really offended by that and would wish you to either be kinder, or leave the site.

  • Were176cRider

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): It would be wise of you not to bash that book on this site. The people who comment here are very kind and accepting for the most part. But, there are some here who are true die-hard fans that are really offended by that and would wish you to either be kinder, or leave the site.

  • Were176cRider

    @Eragonstinks (Guest): It would be wise of you not to bash that book on this site. The people who comment here are very kind and accepting for the most part. But, there are some here who are true die-hard fans that are really offended by that and would wish you to either be kinder, or leave the site.

  • 7th

    @MSJ: It has to be in a close proximity. “you have opened the Vos please travel to the oppoesite side of the known world for use thank you for your time”. Its going to be close. CP says that he has given little minute details that are huge details. Like Marna, somtheing is going to happen there of a huge signifgance.

  • 7th

    @MSJ: It has to be in a close proximity. “you have opened the Vos please travel to the oppoesite side of the known world for use thank you for your time”. Its going to be close. CP says that he has given little minute details that are huge details. Like Marna, somtheing is going to happen there of a huge signifgance.

  • 7th

    @MSJ: It has to be in a close proximity. “you have opened the Vos please travel to the oppoesite side of the known world for use thank you for your time”. Its going to be close. CP says that he has given little minute details that are huge details. Like Marna, somtheing is going to happen there of a huge signifgance.

  • Eragonstinks

    This was the worst book that i had ever read. It plays out like ALL the books do and It is easy to predict. Everyone who likes it needs to get a life!!!

  • Eragonstinks

    This was the worst book that i had ever read. It plays out like ALL the books do and It is easy to predict. Everyone who likes it needs to get a life!!!

  • Eragonstinks

    This was the worst book that i had ever read. It plays out like ALL the books do and It is easy to predict. Everyone who likes it needs to get a life!!!

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i dont knowonly cp knows foe sure,but its unlikely that he wouldnt look there if thats were the dragos kept their eldunari. but its still possible,maybe their hiding their minds like the razac and i think oromis only looked with his mind.so they could be there. just my opinion tho.

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i dont knowonly cp knows foe sure,but its unlikely that he wouldnt look there if thats were the dragos kept their eldunari. but its still possible,maybe their hiding their minds like the razac and i think oromis only looked with his mind.so they could be there. just my opinion tho.

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): i dont knowonly cp knows foe sure,but its unlikely that he wouldnt look there if thats were the dragos kept their eldunari. but its still possible,maybe their hiding their minds like the razac and i think oromis only looked with his mind.so they could be there. just my opinion tho.

  • DEvin15

    i think that is where it is…i think wat orimis meant was that he looked everywhere but there maybe?

  • DEvin15

    i think that is where it is…i think wat orimis meant was that he looked everywhere but there maybe?

  • DEvin15

    i think that is where it is…i think wat orimis meant was that he looked everywhere but there maybe?

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): its possible but oromis said that he’s looked everywhere and he knows were the dragons kept their hoh.

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): its possible but oromis said that he’s looked everywhere and he knows were the dragons kept their hoh.

  • oromismaster

    @DEvin15 (Guest): its possible but oromis said that he’s looked everywhere and he knows were the dragons kept their hoh.

  • DEvin15

    OK I GOT IMPORTANT NEWS!!

    i was reading brisingr and on page 630 inthe chapter Souls of Stone Glaedar says “Before wee formed our pact with the elves, we kept our HoH in DU FELLS NANGOROTH, the mountains in the center of the Hadarac Desert.

    Later after the rideers established themselvees on the island of Vroengard and built a repository for the Eldunari.”

    maybe the VoS is this DU FELLS NANGOROTH place in the center of hadarac desert?! it makes sense cause before they formed there pact with the elves they kept them there and maybe Galby never found out about that!?

    Please comment or reply on this, i wanna see if im right or not

    THANKS

  • Deidara

    Actually i don’t think saying the AL’s true name would give you control over all things. I think it only works on individuals. Like if i said Fox in the AL I wouldn’t have control over all the foxes would i?

    Discuss.

  • DEvin15

    OK I GOT IMPORTANT NEWS!!
    i was reading brisingr and on page 630 inthe chapter Souls of Stone Glaedar says “Before wee formed our pact with the elves, we kept our HoH in DU FELLS NANGOROTH, the mountains in the center of the Hadarac Desert.
    Later after the rideers established themselvees on the island of Vroengard and built a repository for the Eldunari.”
    maybe the VoS is this DU FELLS NANGOROTH place in the center of hadarac desert?! it makes sense cause before they formed there pact with the elves they kept them there and maybe Galby never found out about that!?
    Please comment or reply on this, i wanna see if im right or not
    THANKS

  • DEvin15

    OK I GOT IMPORTANT NEWS!!
    i was reading brisingr and on page 630 inthe chapter Souls of Stone Glaedar says “Before wee formed our pact with the elves, we kept our HoH in DU FELLS NANGOROTH, the mountains in the center of the Hadarac Desert.
    Later after the rideers established themselvees on the island of Vroengard and built a repository for the Eldunari.”
    maybe the VoS is this DU FELLS NANGOROTH place in the center of hadarac desert?! it makes sense cause before they formed there pact with the elves they kept them there and maybe Galby never found out about that!?
    Please comment or reply on this, i wanna see if im right or not
    THANKS

  • Deidara

    Actually i don’t think saying the AL’s true name would give you control over all things. I think it only works on individuals. Like if i said Fox in the AL I wouldn’t have control over all the foxes would i?

    Discuss.

  • Deidara

    Actually i don’t think saying the AL’s true name would give you control over all things. I think it only works on individuals. Like if i said Fox in the AL I wouldn’t have control over all the foxes would i?

    Discuss.

  • oromismaster

    who says the vos has to be eldunari, couldnt it be spirits? and maybe the rock of kuthian will tell him how to control the spirits. just a thought.

  • oromismaster

    who says the vos has to be eldunari, couldnt it be spirits? and maybe the rock of kuthian will tell him how to control the spirits. just a thought.

  • oromismaster

    who says the vos has to be eldunari, couldnt it be spirits? and maybe the rock of kuthian will tell him how to control the spirits. just a thought.

  • Dragonrider360

    I got another theory! But its different than the on I forgot.

    I was reading on Inheritance Wiki and I got this theory from that theory.
    It said that the Grey Folk dispersed in the population. This may be why humans can use magic. But let\’s not count out that the Grey Folk aren\’t completly gone.

  • Dragonrider360

    I got another theory! But its different than the on I forgot. I was reading on Inheritance Wiki and I got this theory from that theory.It said that the Grey Folk dispersed in the population. This may be why humans can use magic. But let’s not count out that the Grey Folk aren’t completly gone.

  • Dragonrider360

    I got another theory! But its different than the on I forgot. I was reading on Inheritance Wiki and I got this theory from that theory.It said that the Grey Folk dispersed in the population. This may be why humans can use magic. But let’s not count out that the Grey Folk aren’t completly gone.

  • Dragonrider360

    I have some more questions. Some may be unanswerable (It WILL be a word if it already isn’t :)) .

    What exactly is the limit of a HOH’s power? Can it, for example be funneled to make a spell? Like, if a rider said “Brisingr” and fire came out of his palm it would be the dragon’s HOH making (or fueling) the fire?

    If anyone has info on the Grey Folk, please tell me! Even if I already know it! 🙂

    Gosh darn it I forgot a theory I was formulating. Grrrr……

  • Dragonrider360

    I have some more questions. Some may be unanswerable (It WILL be a word if it already isn’t :)) .What exactly is the limit of a HOH’s power? Can it, for example be funneled to make a spell? Like, if a rider said “Brisingr” and fire came out of his palm it would be the dragon’s HOH making (or fueling) the fire?If anyone has info on the Grey Folk, please tell me! Even if I already know it! :)Gosh darn it I forgot a theory I was formulating. Grrrr……

  • Dragonrider360

    I have some more questions. Some may be unanswerable (It WILL be a word if it already isn’t :)) .What exactly is the limit of a HOH’s power? Can it, for example be funneled to make a spell? Like, if a rider said “Brisingr” and fire came out of his palm it would be the dragon’s HOH making (or fueling) the fire?If anyone has info on the Grey Folk, please tell me! Even if I already know it! :)Gosh darn it I forgot a theory I was formulating. Grrrr……

  • MSJ

    @7th (guest): Marna is not the only thing capitalized. There is also Helgrind and Utgard.

    Here is one for you guys. Based off Solembum’s words, there is nothing that really guarantees that RoK and VoS are at same location. He tells Eragon to go to RoK and speak your name to open the VoS. VoS could be somewhere else entirely. Just cause of the Eragon’s name/RoK relation doesn’t necessarily mean the VoS is at the same place.

    Thoughts?

  • MSJ

    @7th (guest): Marna is not the only thing capitalized. There is also Helgrind and Utgard.Here is one for you guys. Based off Solembum’s words, there is nothing that really guarantees that RoK and VoS are at same location. He tells Eragon to go to RoK and speak your name to open the VoS. VoS could be somewhere else entirely. Just cause of the Eragon’s name/RoK relation doesn’t necessarily mean the VoS is at the same place.Thoughts?

  • MSJ

    @7th (guest): Marna is not the only thing capitalized. There is also Helgrind and Utgard.Here is one for you guys. Based off Solembum’s words, there is nothing that really guarantees that RoK and VoS are at same location. He tells Eragon to go to RoK and speak your name to open the VoS. VoS could be somewhere else entirely. Just cause of the Eragon’s name/RoK relation doesn’t necessarily mean the VoS is at the same place.Thoughts?

  • 7th

    @The.one: Thats puushin it. I think it has something to do with marna. Its the only place wih all capitols so i am guessing it is of some signifigance.

  • 7th

    @The.one: Thats puushin it. I think it has something to do with marna. Its the only place wih all capitols so i am guessing it is of some signifigance.

  • 7th

    @The.one: Thats puushin it. I think it has something to do with marna. Its the only place wih all capitols so i am guessing it is of some signifigance.

  • The.one

    @iloveeragon (Guest): Im not sure he could guess his name, cause galby doesnt know enough about eragon.

  • The.one

    @iloveeragon (Guest): Im not sure he could guess his name, cause galby doesnt know enough about eragon.

  • The.one

    @iloveeragon (Guest): Im not sure he could guess his name, cause galby doesnt know enough about eragon.

  • Tulkas

    If the true name of the AL controls everything, then the true name of anything else controls everything that is part of said thing. For example, perhaps he is looking for the true name of the Elves, so he can control all of the Elves?

  • Tulkas

    If the true name of the AL controls everything, then the true name of anything else controls everything that is part of said thing. For example, perhaps he is looking for the true name of the Elves, so he can control all of the Elves?

  • Tulkas

    If the true name of the AL controls everything, then the true name of anything else controls everything that is part of said thing. For example, perhaps he is looking for the true name of the Elves, so he can control all of the Elves?

  • iloveeragon

    what if the true name that galby is close to finding is eragons. Just a thought though. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    what if the true name that galby is close to finding is eragons. Just a thought though. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    what if the true name that galby is close to finding is eragons. Just a thought though. 🙂

  • Vermilius

    @MSJ: I don´t think that your last part is at all too farfetched, what if the last riders and dragons, to protect the RoK/VoS made it so that it was once a real dragon and would only waken up/ open himself to the right rider, the one that could defeat galby, so that the eldunari could be safe and only be used in the final battle, thats a theory

  • Vermilius

    @MSJ: I don´t think that your last part is at all too farfetched, what if the last riders and dragons, to protect the RoK/VoS made it so that it was once a real dragon and would only waken up/ open himself to the right rider, the one that could defeat galby, so that the eldunari could be safe and only be used in the final battle, thats a theory

  • Vermilius

    @MSJ: I don´t think that your last part is at all too farfetched, what if the last riders and dragons, to protect the RoK/VoS made it so that it was once a real dragon and would only waken up/ open himself to the right rider, the one that could defeat galby, so that the eldunari could be safe and only be used in the final battle, thats a theory

  • Evarin

    I think that the thing Galby is searching for will be the true name of the ancient language. Near the beginning of Brisingr, the Ra’zac states that Galby has almost found “the true name.”

  • Evarin

    I think that the thing Galby is searching for will be the true name of the ancient language. Near the beginning of Brisingr, the Ra’zac states that Galby has almost found “the true name.”

  • Evarin

    I think that the thing Galby is searching for will be the true name of the ancient language. Near the beginning of Brisingr, the Ra’zac states that Galby has almost found “the true name.”

  • MSJ

    HexRider, no offense take pal. I was just clearifying my initial suggestion.

    I have another pondering that I have stated a couple times before but seems that no one cared. But now that I know I have a few people intrigued with some of my own theories, I’ll repeat it.

    Does anyone care to know what is the deal with the mountain Marna? It’s not too far from Gilead, and is one of ONLY three mountains that are identified with a completely captalized name, yet to the best of my knowledge, has not been mentioned once in the books. Is this why no one can seem o remember where they hear of the RoK/VoS?

    Also, of all the mountains/hills, it’s the only one (IMO) that could even just slightly resemble a dragon. In correlation to that, I remember Brom telling Eragon that the ancient dragons could pass for hills and that they flourish equally with he land (or something like that). What if Marna was like the first dragon ever?!

    I know that last part is a bit far fetched, but I’m very interested in why Marna has been so distinctly identified in the book’s map if it is nothing important.

  • MSJ

    HexRider, no offense take pal. I was just clearifying my initial suggestion.I have another pondering that I have stated a couple times before but seems that no one cared. But now that I know I have a few people intrigued with some of my own theories, I’ll repeat it.Does anyone care to know what is the deal with the mountain Marna? It’s not too far from Gilead, and is one of ONLY three mountains that are identified with a completely captalized name, yet to the best of my knowledge, has not been mentioned once in the books. Is this why no one can seem o remember where they hear of the RoK/VoS?Also, of all the mountains/hills, it’s the only one (IMO) that could even just slightly resemble a dragon. In correlation to that, I remember Brom telling Eragon that the ancient dragons could pass for hills and that they flourish equally with he land (or something like that). What if Marna was like the first dragon ever?!I know that last part is a bit far fetched, but I’m very interested in why Marna has been so distinctly identified in the book’s map if it is nothing important.

  • MSJ

    HexRider, no offense take pal. I was just clearifying my initial suggestion.I have another pondering that I have stated a couple times before but seems that no one cared. But now that I know I have a few people intrigued with some of my own theories, I’ll repeat it.Does anyone care to know what is the deal with the mountain Marna? It’s not too far from Gilead, and is one of ONLY three mountains that are identified with a completely captalized name, yet to the best of my knowledge, has not been mentioned once in the books. Is this why no one can seem o remember where they hear of the RoK/VoS?Also, of all the mountains/hills, it’s the only one (IMO) that could even just slightly resemble a dragon. In correlation to that, I remember Brom telling Eragon that the ancient dragons could pass for hills and that they flourish equally with he land (or something like that). What if Marna was like the first dragon ever?!I know that last part is a bit far fetched, but I’m very interested in why Marna has been so distinctly identified in the book’s map if it is nothing important.

  • HeXrider

    Yes MSJ i was referring to your theory, now we have at least a good discussion going 😀 Don’t take offence, i only want to get real brainzorming going.

    Verii i think your theory makes a lot of sense. Remember that murthagh said Galby was busy with a “project”? maybe that’s his project. to get all the knowledge about sorcery. Since there are no more eldunari left to control, Galby is likely to want to increase his power by other means.

    Maybe the seven words that brom taught Eragon. Are indeed not ancient language words, but magic beyond the AL. (before the grey folks invented the AL)

    I like that theory of yours very much 😀

  • HeXrider

    Yes MSJ i was referring to your theory, now we have at least a good discussion going 😀 Don’t take offence, i only want to get real brainzorming going.Verii i think your theory makes a lot of sense. Remember that murthagh said Galby was busy with a “project”? maybe that’s his project. to get all the knowledge about sorcery. Since there are no more eldunari left to control, Galby is likely to want to increase his power by other means. Maybe the seven words that brom taught Eragon. Are indeed not ancient language words, but magic beyond the AL. (before the grey folks invented the AL)I like that theory of yours very much 😀

  • HeXrider

    Yes MSJ i was referring to your theory, now we have at least a good discussion going 😀 Don’t take offence, i only want to get real brainzorming going.Verii i think your theory makes a lot of sense. Remember that murthagh said Galby was busy with a “project”? maybe that’s his project. to get all the knowledge about sorcery. Since there are no more eldunari left to control, Galby is likely to want to increase his power by other means. Maybe the seven words that brom taught Eragon. Are indeed not ancient language words, but magic beyond the AL. (before the grey folks invented the AL)I like that theory of yours very much 😀

  • JCV2013

    @scififantasylover: Sorry, but we’ve seen Galby, in essence, as he took control over Glaedr/Oromis’ fight With Thorn/Murtagh. He exists.

  • JCV2013

    @scififantasylover: Sorry, but we’ve seen Galby, in essence, as he took control over Glaedr/Oromis’ fight With Thorn/Murtagh. He exists.

  • JCV2013

    @scififantasylover: Sorry, but we’ve seen Galby, in essence, as he took control over Glaedr/Oromis’ fight With Thorn/Murtagh. He exists.

  • The.one

    @7th (Guest): Or, what if the vos is actually inside eragon? and it realeases greater power?

  • The.one

    @7th (Guest): Or, what if the vos is actually inside eragon? and it realeases greater power?

  • The.one

    I think the cover of the new book should have a pic of eragon and saphira together.

  • The.one

    I think the cover of the new book should have a pic of eragon and saphira together.

  • scififantasylover

    @Bill: Can dragons actually change their appearance? I know elves can.
    ….Completely off subject (kinda): Do shruikan (sp?) and galbatorix actually exist? Are they made up to invoke fear in the citizens of the Empire? I am only saying because they have not actually appeared in the books, they have only been mentioned. Hmmm…

  • scififantasylover

    @Bill: Can dragons actually change their appearance? I know elves can…..Completely off subject (kinda): Do shruikan (sp?) and galbatorix actually exist? Are they made up to invoke fear in the citizens of the Empire? I am only saying because they have not actually appeared in the books, they have only been mentioned. Hmmm…

  • guyoftheyear

    @frank (Guest): the endunaris would have to be somewhere close to him or he wouldnt be able to draw power from them….. so most likely in his castle that he never leaves..

  • guyoftheyear

    @frank (Guest): the endunaris would have to be somewhere close to him or he wouldnt be able to draw power from them….. so most likely in his castle that he never leaves..

  • 7th

    @Salib (Guest): What if the name of the ancient language is in VOS. Also thats why Galby wants his true name so much, because it opens the VOS. And that durza knows where it is. Because in eragon he says that if they come together they can defeat galby together.

  • 7th

    @Salib (Guest): What if the name of the ancient language is in VOS. Also thats why Galby wants his true name so much, because it opens the VOS. And that durza knows where it is. Because in eragon he says that if they come together they can defeat galby together.

  • Bill

    Also, when Grimrr hisses at Angela in chapter King Cat of Book IV, she responds with “Cheep, Cheep.” That’s the sound a bird makes, and cats eat and hunt birds. This is a vital clue, because birds like air, they fly in the air etc…

    Angela is very witty, and strange and on top of all that weird, her personality is just… not human, or elf. Cheep, cheep = bird = air… Dragons belong in the AIR.

    Dragons also work unthinkable magic that is so strong at times, they will the world to change and it does.

    One of the most outrageous theories I have thought of, is Angela a dragon in human form? Did she use such powerful magic it changed her form, did she do something to the werecats if she was a dragon?

    Discuss.

  • Bill

    Also, when Grimrr hisses at Angela in chapter King Cat of Book IV, she responds with “Cheep, Cheep.” That’s the sound a bird makes, and cats eat and hunt birds. This is a vital clue, because birds like air, they fly in the air etc…Angela is very witty, and strange and on top of all that weird, her personality is just… not human, or elf. Cheep, cheep = bird = air… Dragons belong in the AIR. Dragons also work unthinkable magic that is so strong at times, they will the world to change and it does.One of the most outrageous theories I have thought of, is Angela a dragon in human form? Did she use such powerful magic it changed her form, did she do something to the werecats if she was a dragon?Discuss.

  • Bill

    @Vermilius: I think that your theory about Galbatorix becoming a Shade Rider is indeed plausible, due to the fact that Oromis emphasised the fact that there has never been a Rider who was a Shade, and if there was one it would be one of the most horrific things to stalk the land.

    Also, remember how Oromis explained that when Galbatorix first claimed the throne of Alagaesia, he was locked away in his castle for many years (this is how Surda and the Varden managed to retreat and form) and that he came out and reclaimed his empire. After he did this, he then locked himself away again… This may be due to the fact he could be studying sorcery?

  • Bill

    @Vermilius: I think that your theory about Galbatorix becoming a Shade Rider is indeed plausible, due to the fact that Oromis emphasised the fact that there has never been a Rider who was a Shade, and if there was one it would be one of the most horrific things to stalk the land.Also, remember how Oromis explained that when Galbatorix first claimed the throne of Alagaesia, he was locked away in his castle for many years (this is how Surda and the Varden managed to retreat and form) and that he came out and reclaimed his empire. After he did this, he then locked himself away again… This may be due to the fact he could be studying sorcery?

  • Bill

    @Vermilius: I think that your theory about Galbatorix becoming a Shade Rider is indeed plausible, due to the fact that Oromis emphasised the fact that there has never been a Rider who was a Shade, and if there was one it would be one of the most horrific things to stalk the land.Also, remember how Oromis explained that when Galbatorix first claimed the throne of Alagaesia, he was locked away in his castle for many years (this is how Surda and the Varden managed to retreat and form) and that he came out and reclaimed his empire. After he did this, he then locked himself away again… This may be due to the fact he could be studying sorcery?

  • Vermilius

    Now I have registered

    I have a theory that in the final battle, galby will be defeated by eragon after galby kills murtagh, because he joined forces with eragon, and has galby his wonded and about to die he tries to use sprits and his taken in by one and in that way a rider shade is born and with that eragon and saphira use some forbidden magic they hae learned when they were in the VoS and destroy galby, it’s a bit farfetched but at least the part of galby turning into a shade is really possible I think

  • Vermilius

    Now I have registeredI have a theory that in the final battle, galby will be defeated by eragon after galby kills murtagh, because he joined forces with eragon, and has galby his wonded and about to die he tries to use sprits and his taken in by one and in that way a rider shade is born and with that eragon and saphira use some forbidden magic they hae learned when they were in the VoS and destroy galby, it’s a bit farfetched but at least the part of galby turning into a shade is really possible I think

  • MSJ

    @HexRider

    I don’t know if you’re referring to my theroy but if so, here is my rebuttal. Yes, a rider-shade would be even worse than galby, but a shade is from meddling with spirits. This a vault of souls. Spirit – soul: two completely different types of beings

  • MSJ

    @HexRiderI don’t know if you’re referring to my theroy but if so, here is my rebuttal. Yes, a rider-shade would be even worse than galby, but a shade is from meddling with spirits. This a vault of souls. Spirit – soul: two completely different types of beings

  • JCV2013

    @HeXrider: I think what he was saying was not that it is impossible, but rather that Riders understand the risk and would never attempt using spirits for the chance of being taken over and becoming such a horror… but it is still a possibility. Though, I highly doubt we will see that at all in canon yet to come.

  • JCV2013

    @HeXrider: I think what he was saying was not that it is impossible, but rather that Riders understand the risk and would never attempt using spirits for the chance of being taken over and becoming such a horror… but it is still a possibility. Though, I highly doubt we will see that at all in canon yet to come.

  • HeXrider

    like oromis taught in eragons final lessons when he was i ellesmera, A dragon rider shade would be very dangerous,

    i don’t know exactly what the chapter said, but it was somewhat that a dragon rider shade is impossible.

    i’ll look it up

    page 641 :
    Troughout history never has there been a shade who was also a rider. ….off all the horrors that… the worst, even worse then Galby..

    So doesn’t look like much of an option to me

  • HeXrider

    like oromis taught in eragons final lessons when he was i ellesmera, A dragon rider shade would be very dangerous, i don’t know exactly what the chapter said, but it was somewhat that a dragon rider shade is impossible.i’ll look it uppage 641 :Troughout history never has there been a shade who was also a rider. ….off all the horrors that… the worst, even worse then Galby..So doesn’t look like much of an option to me

  • fantasyfan

    @The.one: she might try to have her own children. although that’s kinda gross:P

  • fantasyfan

    @The.one: she might try to have her own children. although that’s kinda gross:P

  • The.one

    @scififantasylover: actually we talked about this a while ago, and i still wanna know, what woulde she do with it?

  • The.one

    @scififantasylover: actually we talked about this a while ago, and i still wanna know, what woulde she do with it?

  • Were176cRider

    @MSJ: That is actually a really good idea. Why would his palm tingle, if Solembum was an ally?

  • Were176cRider

    @MSJ: That is actually a really good idea. Why would his palm tingle, if Solembum was an ally?

  • scififantasylover

    @Rebecca (Guest): Oh wow, I didn’t think of that. It would make sense because Linnea (the Menoa tree) is a jealous lover.

  • scififantasylover

    @Rebecca (Guest): Oh wow, I didn’t think of that. It would make sense because Linnea (the Menoa tree) is a jealous lover.

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Valinor is the city where Tulkas lives.

    About Roran becoming king- Would Nasuada and/or Orrin allow this to happen? For this to happen Nasuada would have to either become the dragon rider or die, and have Roran take her place.

  • Tulkas

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): Valinor is the city where Tulkas lives.About Roran becoming king- Would Nasuada and/or Orrin allow this to happen? For this to happen Nasuada would have to either become the dragon rider or die, and have Roran take her place.

  • Rebecca

    @Seven (Guest): Not his gut, his lower abdomen. The Menoa Tree was created when the maiden was abandoned by her lover. What if she took away Eragon’s ability to have children? Arya said in Eldest that elves value children above all else, so taking that would have been the highest price that she could have offered as an elf. Taking away that ability would cause a man a twinge in the lower abdomen….

  • Rebecca

    @Seven (Guest): Not his gut, his lower abdomen. The Menoa Tree was created when the maiden was abandoned by her lover. What if she took away Eragon’s ability to have children? Arya said in Eldest that elves value children above all else, so taking that would have been the highest price that she could have offered as an elf. Taking away that ability would cause a man a twinge in the lower abdomen….

  • fantasyfan

    @Salib: but it would be so comical!!!!!!!!

    @MSJ: i wonder if we’ve completely missed the most important part? we discussed practically everyone but solembum.

  • fantasyfan

    @Salib: but it would be so [email protected]: i wonder if we’ve completely missed the most important part? we discussed practically everyone but solembum.

  • MSJ

    I’m also starting to wonder if VoS contains a dark magic not meant to be taught/learned but Eragon controls it rather than lose control and become a shade, another galb, or etc. That’s why he is to only go when all hope is lost. His “fire” for all forms of life will be his strength not to become evil

  • MSJ

    I’m also starting to wonder if VoS contains a dark magic not meant to be taught/learned but Eragon controls it rather than lose control and become a shade, another galb, or etc. That’s why he is to only go when all hope is lost. His “fire” for all forms of life will be his strength not to become evil

  • frank

    @Salib (Guest): what we meant is galbatorix’s store of eldunaris is in the vault of souls and by releasing them his power would level out more with eragons

  • frank

    @Salib (Guest): what we meant is galbatorix’s store of eldunaris is in the vault of souls and by releasing them his power would level out more with eragons

  • Salib

    I think it would be almost disappointing for Arya to become the next rider merely because its so predictable. What Im interested in is the seven words of power Brom told Eragon when he died, and what the Menoa tree took From Eragon.

  • Salib

    I think it would be almost disappointing for Arya to become the next rider merely because its so predictable. What Im interested in is the seven words of power Brom told Eragon when he died, and what the Menoa tree took From Eragon.

  • Salib

    For all those that think the Vault of Souls AT The rock of Kuithan ( yes they are the same place ) Is a store of Eldunari, it says on Page 636 of Brisingr that it is \” Inconceivable that any great store of Eldunari might be lying hiden somewhere, ready to help us if we could but locate them \” Sorry =/ lol

  • Salib

    For all those that think the Vault of Souls AT The rock of Kuithan ( yes they are the same place ) Is a store of Eldunari, it says on Page 636 of Brisingr that it is ” Inconceivable that any great store of Eldunari might be lying hiden somewhere, ready to help us if we could but locate them ” Sorry =/ lol

  • MSJ

    I just came across another small (possibly overlooked) “coincedence”. At least I think so. As Eragon, Brom, and Joed begin on their mission to read the shipping records, they pass angela’s shop when Eragon catching movement on the roof. Though it’s safe to assume it was Solembum fllowing them as he warns Eragon in the same chapter, “he sees nothing but his palm tingled” it says. Now correct me if I’m wrong but Eragon’s palm only tingled when he was A) bonds with Saphira, B) performs magic or C) is soon to be in danger. Since none of these apply here, what about Solembum would make Eragon’s palm tingle? I think it’s more than the fact that he is a werecat cause Eragon’s palm doesn’t tingle when he meets the other werecats.

  • MSJ

    I just came across another small (possibly overlooked) “coincedence”. At least I think so. As Eragon, Brom, and Joed begin on their mission to read the shipping records, they pass angela’s shop when Eragon catching movement on the roof. Though it’s safe to assume it was Solembum fllowing them as he warns Eragon in the same chapter, “he sees nothing but his palm tingled” it says. Now correct me if I’m wrong but Eragon’s palm only tingled when he was A) bonds with Saphira, B) performs magic or C) is soon to be in danger. Since none of these apply here, what about Solembum would make Eragon’s palm tingle? I think it’s more than the fact that he is a werecat cause Eragon’s palm doesn’t tingle when he meets the other werecats.

  • WhatsinaName

    My question is that when ayra and eragon finally do get together will CP can them Mr and Mrs Shadeslayer? lol

  • WhatsinaName

    My question is that when ayra and eragon finally do get together will CP can them Mr and Mrs Shadeslayer? lol

  • Deidara

    @ash (Guest): Im not even sure CP knows yet.

  • Deidara

    @ash (Guest): Im not even sure CP knows yet.

  • Deidara

    @ash (Guest): Im not even sure CP knows yet.

  • Seven

    @The.one: haha oh of course, his gall bladder! Somewhere beneath her roots she has a collection of gall bladders of all the people she hates…. it’s one way to pass the time i suppose…

  • Seven

    @The.one: haha oh of course, his gall bladder! Somewhere beneath her roots she has a collection of gall bladders of all the people she hates…. it’s one way to pass the time i suppose…

  • Aryafan

    @frank (Guest): EXCELLENT idea!!
    i never thought of it like that, but it makes a lot of sense.

  • Aryafan

    @frank (Guest): EXCELLENT idea!!i never thought of it like that, but it makes a lot of sense.

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: thnx i wonder wat thatt meant tho

  • oromismaster

    @The.one: thnx i wonder wat thatt meant tho

  • The.one

    @Seven (Guest): either they planned it that way or they picked that chapter cause it doesnt give that much away and raises more qestions than answers

  • The.one

    @Seven (Guest): either they planned it that way or they picked that chapter cause it doesnt give that much away and raises more qestions than answers

  • The.one

    @Seven (Guest): hehe it took his gall bladder do it cant be infected and does absolutley nothing

  • The.one

    @Seven (Guest): hehe it took his gall bladder do it cant be infected and does absolutley nothing

  • Seven

    Scififantasylover – I think they planned it that way. They pre-released the third chapter of Brisingr, the third book, with later editions of Eldest, and so now they’re releasing the fourth chapter of the fourth book.

    I really, really want to know what the Menoa tree did to/took from Eragon when he felt the twinge in his gut – it has to have some meaning otherwise why mention it. I like the ideas people were suggesting earlier about the menoa tree demanding Eragon and Saphira leave Alagaesia for attacking her, but how that relates to Eragon’s gut i can’t fathom!

  • Seven

    Scififantasylover – I think they planned it that way. They pre-released the third chapter of Brisingr, the third book, with later editions of Eldest, and so now they’re releasing the fourth chapter of the fourth book.I really, really want to know what the Menoa tree did to/took from Eragon when he felt the twinge in his gut – it has to have some meaning otherwise why mention it. I like the ideas people were suggesting earlier about the menoa tree demanding Eragon and Saphira leave Alagaesia for attacking her, but how that relates to Eragon’s gut i can’t fathom!

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): i just looked it up its 659 in brisngr

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): i just looked it up its 659 in brisngr

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): i dont remember what page its on..but its when he goes to the manoa tree and asks for the brightsteel..and then goes to rhunans place and makes th sword

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): i dont remember what page its on..but its when he goes to the manoa tree and asks for the brightsteel..and then goes to rhunans place and makes th sword

  • Were176cRider

    Is it safe for us to assume that if Angela knows where the VoS is, along with the RoK, that Solembum would know where these are, and could lead Eragon to them?

  • Were176cRider

    Is it safe for us to assume that if Angela knows where the VoS is, along with the RoK, that Solembum would know where these are, and could lead Eragon to them?

  • oromismaster

    [email protected] do u know were it said he had a twinge in his stomach?

  • oromismaster

    [email protected] do u know were it said he had a twinge in his stomach?

  • scififantasylover

    Isn’t it ironic how they have released the fourth chapter of the fourth book?

  • scififantasylover

    Isn’t it ironic how they have released the fourth chapter of the fourth book?

  • iloveeragon

    its sooo crazy how much comments are on this page and they are all from like the same group of people but i do enjoy discussing the topic of the 4th book and all the theories. although im noy to good at coming up with them. cant wait for the 4th book to come out! 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    its sooo crazy how much comments are on this page and they are all from like the same group of people but i do enjoy discussing the topic of the 4th book and all the theories. although im noy to good at coming up with them. cant wait for the 4th book to come out! 🙂

  • Eldest

    @HeXrider:That’s a good theory. That would be cool if Angela knew where the VOS is.

  • Eldest

    @HeXrider:That’s a good theory. That would be cool if Angela knew where the VOS is.

  • Eldest

    @ash (Guest): Wha?

  • Eldest

    @ash (Guest): Wha?

  • Dragonrider360

    @ heXrider: If Angela has some inkling of where or what the VoS ans the RoK is, then why hasn’t Eragon asked her yet?

    @Frank: I never thought of Utgard before….hmmm… *stares off into distance and twirling her imaginary mustache*

  • Dragonrider360

    @ heXrider: If Angela has some inkling of where or what the VoS ans the RoK is, then why hasn’t Eragon asked her yet? @Frank: I never thought of Utgard before….hmmm… *stares off into distance and twirling her imaginary mustache*

  • frank

    i think its pretty safe to assume that galbatorix’s eldunaris are in the vault of souls which means that the vault of souls (and the rock of kuthian) have to be somewhere in the empire because he wouldnt place something so valuable outside of his control when there are people like brom and the elves still alive to search for it. i think its either on vroengard, or more likely on utgard because the top of the mountain can only be reached by air, not by foot so only dragon riders could reach the top which before eragon, was just galbatorix

  • frank

    i think its pretty safe to assume that galbatorix’s eldunaris are in the vault of souls which means that the vault of souls (and the rock of kuthian) have to be somewhere in the empire because he wouldnt place something so valuable outside of his control when there are people like brom and the elves still alive to search for it. i think its either on vroengard, or more likely on utgard because the top of the mountain can only be reached by air, not by foot so only dragon riders could reach the top which before eragon, was just galbatorix

  • HeXrider

    Hehe lol thanks for liking my theories, no im not CP in disguise, i’m just applying my job to the books: puzzling and thinking things out to the bottom.About angela. Hmmm. it could make good sense she is eragon’s mother, but in another way it would be very false too think about it:Can: she is very good at manipulating things, speaking in riddles and being handy with potions and enchanted items. She knows how to poison people, and how to make them hallucinate (battle op Burning plains)Can’t: She is VERY old and she laughs about when people guess her too young. She was apprentice of Thenga, who is very old too. Ow by the way, she is NOT i repeat NOT a dragon rider. She is not clever by magic, but by applying natural recourses, potions and other stuff to her use. I’d say she is a collector of the (by the elves named:) “Wild magic” the magic just there in ALRemember the shocking stick eragon used to grab for the first time in teirm? I think that wasn’t “made” magic i think that was natural magic. Since she was alone with thenga for very long, she could have learned all kinds of things that where forbidden to learn under galby’s rule. I’m thinking of LOCATIONS of such magical items. Maybe she allready knows the location of the VoS. I can’t recall eragon ever asking her, but i may be wrong. I’m more wandering WHAT she knows, and if she will ever reveal herself.Yes Angela is going to play a big role in the last book i just know it. Why? because in RL angela is CP’s sister. And remember how he begins every book with how much support he has from his family? so he want’s to do something back. Why not give his sister a major role.I don’t think that role we be as a dragon rider, simply because then eragon moves too far to the background. Angela is a mystical person, but if he’d make her a “regular” dragon rider, she wouldn’t be interesting to the story anymore. At least now we are still all guessing WHAT she is/knows etc :Dgosh it has gotten longer then i thought 😀 hope u guys like it 😀

  • HeXrider

    Hehe lol thanks for liking my theories, no im not CP in disguise, i’m just applying my job to the books: puzzling and thinking things out to the bottom.

    About angela. Hmmm. it could make good sense she is eragon’s mother, but in another way it would be very false too think about it:

    Can: she is very good at manipulating things, speaking in riddles and being handy with potions and enchanted items. She knows how to poison people, and how to make them hallucinate (battle op Burning plains)

    Can’t: She is VERY old and she laughs about when people guess her too young. She was apprentice of Thenga, who is very old too.

    Ow by the way, she is NOT i repeat NOT a dragon rider. She is not clever by magic, but by applying natural recourses, potions and other stuff to her use. I’d say she is a collector of the (by the elves named:) “Wild magic” the magic just there in AL

    Remember the shocking stick eragon used to grab for the first time in teirm? I think that wasn’t “made” magic i think that was natural magic.

    Since she was alone with thenga for very long, she could have learned all kinds of things that where forbidden to learn under galby’s rule. I’m thinking of LOCATIONS of such magical items. Maybe she allready knows the location of the VoS. I can’t recall eragon ever asking her, but i may be wrong.

    I’m more wandering WHAT she knows, and if she will ever reveal herself.

    Yes Angela is going to play a big role in the last book i just know it. Why? because in RL angela is CP’s sister. And remember how he begins every book with how much support he has from his family? so he want’s to do something back. Why not give his sister a major role.

    I don’t think that role we be as a dragon rider, simply because then eragon moves too far to the background. Angela is a mystical person, but if he’d make her a “regular” dragon rider, she wouldn’t be interesting to the story anymore. At least now we are still all guessing WHAT she is/knows etc 😀

    gosh it has gotten longer then i thought 😀 hope u guys like it 😀

  • Bob

    @The.one: It’s just kinda funny that you all still visit this old post to discuss your theories!

    I see you guys are getting some good use out of the reply feature I made! Cool!

  • Bob

    @The.one: It’s just kinda funny that you all still visit this old post to discuss your theories!I see you guys are getting some good use out of the reply feature I made! Cool!

  • fantasyfan

    @The.one: that make sense now… I didn’t know that the last egg was green i just thought that was an assumption.

    although i don’t see the point of stopping the book just so greenie can grow up. it doesnt sound very CPish.

  • fantasyfan

    @The.one: that make sense now… I didn’t know that the last egg was green i just thought that was an assumption.although i don’t see the point of stopping the book just so greenie can grow up. it doesnt sound very CPish.

  • The.one

    well the egg is green. and in eldest murtagh told eragon that the dragon egg was a guy…idk it might not be though…

  • The.one

    well the egg is green. and in eldest murtagh told eragon that the dragon egg was a guy…idk it might not be though…

  • fantasyfan

    @The.one: I’m confused . can you please explain how you know these things?

    and i never said the egg was female i said eragon 1st’s dragon was a girl not that i know if it really is.

  • fantasyfan

    @The.one: I’m confused . can you please explain how you know these things? and i never said the egg was female i said eragon 1st’s dragon was a girl not that i know if it really is.

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): well a long time ago we talked about this but i disargreed with what they said. it had something to do with the twinge in his stomache

  • The.one

    @oromismaster (Guest): well a long time ago we talked about this but i disargreed with what they said. it had something to do with the twinge in his stomache

  • oromismaster

    i wonder wat the menoa tree will want from eragon? it sounds alot like the urgal story nar garzhvog told eragon

  • oromismaster

    i wonder wat the menoa tree will want from eragon? it sounds alot like the urgal story nar garzhvog told eragon

  • blade12

    @fantasyfan:it i possible but i doupt it remebver what orimis siad that they done teach that type of stuff until the ready i would think orimis would not have had time to teach that to brom and if that was treu then brom would have had her heart of hearts

  • blade12

    @fantasyfan:it i possible but i doupt it remebver what orimis siad that they done teach that type of stuff until the ready i would think orimis would not have had time to teach that to brom and if that was treu then brom would have had her heart of hearts

  • The.one

    @ash (Guest): yeah im not sure what u ment there……oh and can an egg b opened by magic?

  • The.one

    @ash (Guest): yeah im not sure what u ment there……oh and can an egg b opened by magic?

  • The.one

    @scififantasylover: man we talked about this forever ago……NO SHES NOT!! end of story

  • The.one

    @scififantasylover: man we talked about this forever ago……NO SHES NOT!! end of story

  • The.one

    @fantasyfan: DUDE!!the dragon is a male this we know! it was an egg in eldest this we know it is not eragon 1s dragon ok!?

  • The.one

    @fantasyfan: DUDE!!the dragon is a male this we know! it was an egg in eldest this we know it is not eragon 1s dragon ok!?

  • Were176cRider

    That is true, I didn’t think that by being a dragon rider she would be serving all of Alagesia. So, because that would include her people, I believe that is possible. Good ides DragonRider360!

  • Were176cRider

    That is true, I didn’t think that by being a dragon rider she would be serving all of Alagesia. So, because that would include her people, I believe that is possible. Good ides DragonRider360!

  • Dragonrider360

    Arya could still serve her people if she were a dragon rider plus she would be serving

    Alagesia.

  • Dragonrider360

    Arya could still serve her people if she were a dragon rider plus she would be serving
    Alagesia.

  • Were176cRider

    HeXrider-Dude, how many theories do you have. Your a total genius!

    MSJ-I also agree with you that Arya should not be the dragon-rider. Her position is next in line to the elven throne, and the elves always have to put their people first. If she became a dragon-rider, then she could not first serve her people.

    (p.s. I still think that there is a very likely possibility that CP will make Arya the next dragon rider.)

  • Were176cRider

    HeXrider-Dude, how many theories do you have. Your a total genius!

    MSJ-I also agree with you that Arya should not be the dragon-rider. Her position is next in line to the elven throne, and the elves always have to put their people first. If she became a dragon-rider, then she could not first serve her people.

    (p.s. I still think that there is a very likely possibility that CP will make Arya the next dragon rider.)

  • scififantasylover

    @HeXrider: You have some pretty cool theories. 🙂
    Are you sure you aren’t CP in disguise? Lol

  • scififantasylover

    @HeXrider: You have some pretty cool theories. 🙂 Are you sure you aren’t CP in disguise? Lol

  • scififantasylover

    Actually, forget my last post. I have an idea… Selena and Angela could be the same person. She is in hiding so has taken up a new personality as the witch. Think about it….

  • scififantasylover

    Actually, forget my last post. I have an idea… Selena and Angela could be the same person. She is in hiding so has taken up a new personality as the witch. Think about it….

  • scififantasylover

    @ash (Guest): Selena, the Black hand is Eragon’s mother. I think you need to read the books again.

  • scififantasylover

    @ash (Guest): Selena, the Black hand is Eragon’s mother. I think you need to read the books again.

  • scififantasylover

    @fantasyfan: I think your idea is as good as any

  • scififantasylover

    @fantasyfan: I think your idea is as good as any

  • ash

    @The.one:
    my last post was aimed at u

  • ash

    @The.one:my last post was aimed at u

  • ash

    @Eldest (Guest):
    cant be 100% but since ur not CP u cant be 100% sure on whether or not each theory can or cant be true, since only CP knows

  • ash

    @Eldest (Guest):cant be 100% but since ur not CP u cant be 100% sure on whether or not each theory can or cant be true, since only CP knows

  • fantasyfan

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): i dont think greenie is a hatchling i thinks SHE will be a full grown dragon. possibly eragon I dragon since CP said a dragon could change color if it wanted to.(have they even said THE FIRST ERAGONS DRAGON IS WHITE cause i only heard the egg was.

    also does anyone think maybe saphira, broms dragon,could have fled into her eldunari.

    this is the second time i’ve posted this since no-one is giving me input!!!!!!

  • fantasyfan

    @Dragonrider360 (Guest): i dont think greenie is a hatchling i thinks SHE will be a full grown dragon. possibly eragon I dragon since CP said a dragon could change color if it wanted to.(have they even said THE FIRST ERAGONS DRAGON IS WHITE cause i only heard the egg was.also does anyone think maybe saphira, broms dragon,could have fled into her eldunari.this is the second time i’ve posted this since no-one is giving me input!!!!!!

  • fantasyfan

    @iloveeragon (Guest): if you look at the top of the page, click fan things,fan art, any more questions just ask.

  • fantasyfan

    @iloveeragon (Guest): if you look at the top of the page, click fan things,fan art, any more questions just ask.

  • iloveeragon

    do u peoples knowwhere i can go to look at the pics drawn by people cuz i want to see them

  • iloveeragon

    do u peoples knowwhere i can go to look at the pics drawn by people cuz i want to see them

  • dragongirl

    grrrrrrrrr!when will the 4th book come out???

  • dragongirl

    grrrrrrrrr!when will the 4th book come out???

  • Dragonrider360

    You know, the green dragon will be a hatchling, and Eragon probably won’t have time to train the rider. But, if the dragon hatches before Eragon confronts Galby, at the last battle, greenie could preform a powerful magic under pressure.

    But just a thought. If that’s confusing, please tell me, cause right now I’m confused and I don’t know why. 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    You know, the green dragon will be a hatchling, and Eragon probably won’t have time to train the rider. But, if the dragon hatches before Eragon confronts Galby, at the last battle, greenie could preform a powerful magic under pressure.But just a thought. If that’s confusing, please tell me, cause right now I’m confused and I don’t know why. 🙂

  • Eldest

    @ash (Guest): Hey thats what I said!

  • Eldest

    @ash (Guest): Hey thats what I said!

  • Eldest

    @Bill: Maybe Angela is actualy a rider and her dragon is still alive!

  • Eldest

    @Bill: Maybe Angela is actualy a rider and her dragon is still alive!

  • Dragonrider360

    Hey dudes I was exploring this website a little more and man yall’s art is awesome!!!! Coodos to Padfoot! Man, I tried to draw Thorn and I epically failed. I drew Sapheria and Glaedr and they looked decent (my art just can’t comprehend what ya’ll’s art looks like). Sorry about this random outburst but I just thought I’d share my opinion. 🙂

    PS: If I were a Rider, I’d have a white dragon named Valinor( don’t know where that name came from) and my sword would be Wrydas Baen.

  • Dragonrider360

    Hey dudes I was exploring this website a little more and man yall’s art is awesome!!!! Coodos to Padfoot! Man, I tried to draw Thorn and I epically failed. I drew Sapheria and Glaedr and they looked decent (my art just can’t comprehend what ya’ll’s art looks like). Sorry about this random outburst but I just thought I’d share my opinion. :)PS: If I were a Rider, I’d have a white dragon named Valinor( don’t know where that name came from) and my sword would be Wrydas Baen.

  • 7th

    Has anyone ever liked super anaylized eragons prophecy. Because on of the lines was like

    “you will have a love in your life of royal blood. But i cannot see weither it will end in tragedy or success i cannot determine.”.

    My question is if this is possiblly arya it will work out but she will die resulting in a tragedy? Has anyone ever thought of it this way.

  • 7th

    Has anyone ever liked super anaylized eragons prophecy. Because on of the lines was like

    “you will have a love in your life of royal blood. But i cannot see weither it will end in tragedy or success i cannot determine.”.

    My question is if this is possiblly arya it will work out but she will die resulting in a tragedy? Has anyone ever thought of it this way.

  • MSJ

    I too have pondered Arya being a rider and not saying but I HIGHLY doubt it to be true. Of course when I think of it, there is no real SOLID evidence to prove either way. Though I remember Arya being criticized/ridiculed by her mother for her choices. It’s actually funny how everyone is focused on Angela cause if you think about it, there is much we don’t know about a good number of characters.

    I’m actually trying not to theorize anymore cause when I did too much of that on Brisingr, I was disappointed ahoy a couple outcomes. I’d rather not get to hopeful toward any ONE possibility only to be wrong/let down

  • MSJ

    I too have pondered Arya being a rider and not saying but I HIGHLY doubt it to be true. Of course when I think of it, there is no real SOLID evidence to prove either way. Though I remember Arya being criticized/ridiculed by her mother for her choices. It’s actually funny how everyone is focused on Angela cause if you think about it, there is much we don’t know about a good number of characters.I’m actually trying not to theorize anymore cause when I did too much of that on Brisingr, I was disappointed ahoy a couple outcomes. I’d rather not get to hopeful toward any ONE possibility only to be wrong/let down

  • The.one

    hey john flanagans books out soon

  • The.one

    hey john flanagans books out soon

  • The.one

    What i still want to know is, can u use magic to open a dragon egg? if so then mayb thats what galbys trying to do.

  • The.one

    What i still want to know is, can u use magic to open a dragon egg? if so then mayb thats what galbys trying to do.

  • 7th

    What i am wondering is if you were a rider and your dragon died for some reason then could you bond with another egg and make it hatch become a rider again. Not like galby’s dark magic but naturally.

  • 7th

    What i am wondering is if you were a rider and your dragon died for some reason then could you bond with another egg and make it hatch become a rider again. Not like galby’s dark magic but naturally.

  • 7th

    @sirsimon (Guest): If the green dragon appeared before then it would be on eragons mind non-stop. like when he discovered murtagh as thorns rider. Murtaugh’s name was on every chapter in 3rd book. And there weren’t that many new names besides the wereking and lord B.

  • 7th

    @sirsimon (Guest): If the green dragon appeared before then it would be on eragons mind non-stop. like when he discovered murtagh as thorns rider. Murtaugh’s name was on every chapter in 3rd book. And there weren’t that many new names besides the wereking and lord B.

  • fantasyfan

    @HeXrider: i like your theory but what about angela?

  • fantasyfan

    @HeXrider: i like your theory but what about angela?

  • HeXrider

    I’m out LOL i talked about everything i think will happen. Can’t wait for the book now 😀

    I’ll keep reading posts, maybe get some inspiration for new theories from them.

    Anyway just for summing up this is what i think:

    Eragon I COULD but i think not be alive.
    I think Greeny hatched allready and has hidden himself and the rider somewhere. I think somewhere in the east.

    I think Galby doesn’t want this to go public, so he magically kills all or bounds all who want to talk about it.

    I think Murthagh will turn on galby for his own reasons, and die while defending the Varden, doing something heroic to the varden to make good what his father Morzan did wrong.

    I hope arya will be the next rider (i wich case she isn’t hidden herself, only kept silence)

    I think Roran will be the new king because he can rule like one.

    I think the RoK and VoS is in the Spine and the urgals are the safekeepers of it. I think it contains the eldunari of wild dragons.

    I think that there are lots of other countries yet to be explored.

    That’s about it. Nice work so far everyone 😀

  • HeXrider

    I’m out LOL i talked about everything i think will happen. Can’t wait for the book now :DI’ll keep reading posts, maybe get some inspiration for new theories from them. Anyway just for summing up this is what i think:Eragon I COULD but i think not be alive. I think Greeny hatched allready and has hidden himself and the rider somewhere. I think somewhere in the east.I think Galby doesn’t want this to go public, so he magically kills all or bounds all who want to talk about it.I think Murthagh will turn on galby for his own reasons, and die while defending the Varden, doing something heroic to the varden to make good what his father Morzan did wrong.I hope arya will be the next rider (i wich case she isn’t hidden herself, only kept silence)I think Roran will be the new king because he can rule like one. I think the RoK and VoS is in the Spine and the urgals are the safekeepers of it. I think it contains the eldunari of wild dragons.I think that there are lots of other countries yet to be explored. That’s about it. Nice work so far everyone 😀

  • fantasyfan

    can you delete your posts?

  • fantasyfan

    can you delete your posts?

  • fantasyfan

    you know how CP said if a dragon really wanted to be a different color it could. what if that happened to eragon the firsts dragon. then eragon I could be greenies rider.

    P.S. was it even stated that eragon the first had a white dragon, cause it only said he was holding a white egg in the fairth.

  • fantasyfan

    you know how CP said if a dragon really wanted to be a different color it could. what if that happened to eragon the firsts dragon. then eragon I could be greenies rider.P.S. was it even stated that eragon the first had a white dragon, cause it only said he was holding a white egg in the fairth.

  • The.one

    @ash (Guest): dude we discused this along time ago she is not his mom

  • The.one

    @ash (Guest): dude we discused this along time ago she is not his mom

  • fantasyfan

    [email protected] (Guest): i can rule out most of those people

  • fantasyfan

    [email protected] (Guest): i can rule out most of those people

  • fantasyfan

    but if angela was eragons mom why would she hide it. besides his mom died.

  • fantasyfan

    but if angela was eragons mom why would she hide it. besides his mom died.

  • ash

    angela could be eragons mom…. she doesnt like to speak of her

  • ash

    angela could be eragons mom…. she doesnt like to speak of her

  • The.one

    @sirsimon (Guest): hot chocolate? now woulndt i rather have some coffee or some tea as u u britts like. 🙂 sirsimon its banned for ever…man it would suck to be banned form this website….its awesome…

  • The.one

    @sirsimon (Guest): hot chocolate? now woulndt i rather have some coffee or some tea as u u britts like. 🙂 sirsimon its banned for ever…man it would suck to be banned form this website….its awesome…

  • The.one

    @Robert Cox: well theres not really anywhere else to post these things if we post em somewhere else we get yelled at

  • The.one

    @Robert Cox: well theres not really anywhere else to post these things if we post em somewhere else we get yelled at

  • Bob

    Interesting, there are a ton of posts in here…

  • Bob

    Interesting, there are a ton of posts in here…

  • The.one

    @7th (Guest): well there are some other vague people, like jomondour, birgit and all those people from carvahal

  • The.one

    @7th (Guest): well there are some other vague people, like jomondour, birgit and all those people from carvahal

  • zasekr1

    i was thinkinh just there that this is only an exerpt of that chapter. remember when they released the chapter for brisngr they left out half of it. so although this glimpse is such a tease there could be still quite a bit left out from the chapter which may or may not include another new dragon or the egg.

  • zasekr1

    i was thinkinh just there that this is only an exerpt of that chapter. remember when they released the chapter for brisngr they left out half of it. so although this glimpse is such a tease there could be still quite a bit left out from the chapter which may or may not include another new dragon or the egg.

  • NEEDTOREADBOOK!!!!!

    NEED TO READ BOOK!!!!! GAWD WANT THIS BOOK OUT CAN ANYONE ANYONE AT ALL GIVE US A DATE, GAWD THAT CHAPTER GIVES US SOME Q\’s IM WITH ARYA BEING THE NEW DRAGON RIDER. AND I THINK ANGELA IS A DRAGON RIDER FROM ANOTHER PLACE, LIKE FROM WHERE THE ELVES OR SOME OTHER RACE CAME FROM, SO WHAT U THINK

  • NEEDTOREADBOOK!!!!!

    NEED TO READ BOOK!!!!! GAWD WANT THIS BOOK OUT CAN ANYONE ANYONE AT ALL GIVE US A DATE, GAWD THAT CHAPTER GIVES US SOME Q’s IM WITH ARYA BEING THE NEW DRAGON RIDER. AND I THINK ANGELA IS A DRAGON RIDER FROM ANOTHER PLACE, LIKE FROM WHERE THE ELVES OR SOME OTHER RACE CAME FROM, SO WHAT U THINK

  • sirsimon

    I believe that the green dragon could have appeared before the King Cat chapter, but not touched upon because Paolini didn’t want to reveal such stuff yet.

    i think Roran deserves to be a rider, he performed something Eragon would never have been able to do, lead an entire village half way across the heart of the empire, without a dragon, without an old rider like Brom, I admire Roran and his courage, Roran should be rider, or at least king.

    Now…where’s my hot chocolate? lol

  • sirsimon

    I believe that the green dragon could have appeared before the King Cat chapter, but not touched upon because Paolini didn’t want to reveal such stuff yet.

    i think Roran deserves to be a rider, he performed something Eragon would never have been able to do, lead an entire village half way across the heart of the empire, without a dragon, without an old rider like Brom, I admire Roran and his courage, Roran should be rider, or at least king.

    Now…where’s my hot chocolate? lol

  • 7th

    people in all 3 books so far that are possible riders
    1.arya
    2.roran
    3.orik
    4.nasuada
    5.elva
    6.sloan
    7.katrina
    8. horst and his sons
    9.joed
    10. angela

    quote me or reply i would like to make this list larger giving us a generall understand on who the rider could be.

    what i belive will happen.

    1. Also in the guide it said that this force has influence in the halls of this certain place. and that the rider was whisked away by strangers. This means to me there is more than a couple riders. also this means to me the rider will enter the 4 book and will die because they would have the same amount of exeriance as eragon and in the guide eragon says HE and SAPHIRA left.more experiance = more help

    2. I think that the book will be at least 1 yr long because greenie has to reach maturitry and mate with saphira making a clutch of eggs. At least a dozen. giving birth to a new generation of riders.

    3. ROK is a beorian mountain with VOS.

    4. I believe that non of this could happen or all of this coould happen.

    reply i would love to bounce i ideas off people.

  • 7th

    people in all 3 books so far that are possible riders1.arya2.roran3.orik4.nasuada5.elva6.sloan7.katrina8. horst and his sons9.joed10. angelaquote me or reply i would like to make this list larger giving us a generall understand on who the rider could be.what i belive will happen.1. Also in the guide it said that this force has influence in the halls of this certain place. and that the rider was whisked away by strangers. This means to me there is more than a couple riders. also this means to me the rider will enter the 4 book and will die because they would have the same amount of exeriance as eragon and in the guide eragon says HE and SAPHIRA left.more experiance = more help2. I think that the book will be at least 1 yr long because greenie has to reach maturitry and mate with saphira making a clutch of eggs. At least a dozen. giving birth to a new generation of riders.3. ROK is a beorian mountain with VOS.4. I believe that non of this could happen or all of this coould happen.reply i would love to bounce i ideas off people.

  • fantasyfan

    it is unlikely but still possible. now i really want to know more about angela.

    anyway, do you have any ideas about saphira the 1st accidently fleeing into her eldunari or the color of galbys real dragon?

  • fantasyfan

    it is unlikely but still possible. now i really want to know more about angela. anyway, do you have any ideas about saphira the 1st accidently fleeing into her eldunari or the color of galbys real dragon?

  • Tulkas

    Also, for the hidden dragons thing- Oromis would doubtless have been searching for him/her, but doubtless Galby would have been too. Therefore, any dragon would hid himself/herself as much as is magicially possible.

  • Tulkas

    Also, for the hidden dragons thing- Oromis would doubtless have been searching for him/her, but doubtless Galby would have been too. Therefore, any dragon would hid himself/herself as much as is magicially possible.

  • Tulkas

    How big were the dragon knucklebones, then? For Angela to kill a dragon, it would have to be rather small…

  • Tulkas

    How big were the dragon knucklebones, then? For Angela to kill a dragon, it would have to be rather small…

  • Bill

    @fantasyfan: Generally a person would touch a dragon with their hands at first touch, and if I can recall properly there has been no mention of Angela having ‘dirty’ hands like Brom did, or wearing gloves, possible obscuring a gedwey ignasia. But then again with Angela being so weird, she may have touched the dragon with any part of her body, lol.

    But, if she did touch an unbonded hatchling, this event may have made her weird like she is today, she may have been a normal person. But at this point in time, all discussions are theories upon theories.

  • Bill

    @fantasyfan: Generally a person would touch a dragon with their hands at first touch, and if I can recall properly there has been no mention of Angela having ‘dirty’ hands like Brom did, or wearing gloves, possible obscuring a gedwey ignasia. But then again with Angela being so weird, she may have touched the dragon with any part of her body, lol. But, if she did touch an unbonded hatchling, this event may have made her weird like she is today, she may have been a normal person. But at this point in time, all discussions are theories upon theories.

  • fantasyfan

    @Bill: true, but i still think its possible that she could have hidden a gedwey ignasia. and if i can figure out how to submit questions in the Q&A i think i’ll ask if being accidentially bonded with a dragon would extend your life and make it possible for you to use magic.

  • fantasyfan

    @Bill: true, but i still think its possible that she could have hidden a gedwey ignasia. and if i can figure out how to submit questions in the Q&A i think i’ll ask if being accidentially bonded with a dragon would extend your life and make it possible for you to use magic.

  • Bill

    @fantasyfan: CP didn’t exactly ellaborate on the details if this event happened to a person, but I guess we won’t find out about until Book IV or if not never. But in Q&A six, CP did say that the dragon that touched a person who was not intended to, then that dragon would usually kill the intruder on that bond.

    Therefore, I put this forward, that Angela may have touched a dragon before the intended Rider did so, and after the dragon grew it tried to kill Angela, maybe that is how she acquired the dragon knuckles, it was a kill or be killed situation. How she could alone kill a dragon is beyond my imagination, but it could have happened.

    This theory, however, is rebutted by the fact that she does not possess a gedwey ignasia (that we know of) as CP said the person who touched the dragon before the proper bond was made would then bear the mark of the Riders.

  • Bill

    @fantasyfan: CP didn’t exactly ellaborate on the details if this event happened to a person, but I guess we won’t find out about until Book IV or if not never. But in Q&A six, CP did say that the dragon that touched a person who was not intended to, then that dragon would usually kill the intruder on that bond. Therefore, I put this forward, that Angela may have touched a dragon before the intended Rider did so, and after the dragon grew it tried to kill Angela, maybe that is how she acquired the dragon knuckles, it was a kill or be killed situation. How she could alone kill a dragon is beyond my imagination, but it could have happened.This theory, however, is rebutted by the fact that she does not possess a gedwey ignasia (that we know of) as CP said the person who touched the dragon before the proper bond was made would then bear the mark of the Riders.

  • fantasyfan

    you know how CP was being vague about complications (5th Q&A) if someone touched a hatched dragon before the chosen person did.
    what if angela did that???that could explain her age and limited magical ability’s.

    then again, CP said nothing about extended life spans or use of magic. but it would be cool. and if it did happen what dragon could it have happened with?

    also still wondering about her dragon knuckles?

  • fantasyfan

    you know how CP was being vague about complications (5th Q&A) if someone touched a hatched dragon before the chosen person did.what if angela did that???that could explain her age and limited magical ability’s.then again, CP said nothing about extended life spans or use of magic. but it would be cool. and if it did happen what dragon could it have happened with?also still wondering about her dragon knuckles?

  • fantasyfan

    question: just because CP said that brom’s saphira didn’t disgorge her eldunari does that mean she couldn’t havefled into her eldunari when she died?if so could eragon find her eldunari. it’s kinda far fetched but it would be cool.

    also does anyone have an idea about why CP didn’t want to tell the color of galby’s first dragon. i just read all the Q&A’s and CP says more by not saying anything if you know what i mean.

  • fantasyfan

    question: just because CP said that brom’s saphira didn’t disgorge her eldunari does that mean she couldn’t havefled into her eldunari when she died?if so could eragon find her eldunari. it’s kinda far fetched but it would be cool. also does anyone have an idea about why CP didn’t want to tell the color of galby’s first dragon. i just read all the Q&A’s and CP says more by not saying anything if you know what i mean.

  • HeXrider

    About my last theory about another dragon being around: it’s even more plausible because of a few reasons:

    1 Galbatorix (tried to) destroy(ed) all evidence that contradicts his strength and the history of AL. So think how a dictator should: if there is a bigger power then you out of your reach, would you want it to become common knowledge? No! you will want your people to believe you are the strongest.

    I’m not gonna repeat myself but AL is much bigger then the map we saw. So there is much ground still left to explore. Remember that in the books was commented that the empire was much and much larger when the riders ruled. and that since galby remained the only of the Fornswon (correct?) left alive, the empire he controlled is much less big.

    Also the place where the wild dragons lived (east of du weldenvarden if i’m correct) isn’t anywhere on the maps

    I love the idea of more dragon still alive, it would also make the subject of dragons as a race more interesting

    What if saphira isn’t the only one female dragon? Just because galby want’s his subjects to believe that doesn’t mean it is the absolute truth. Maybe he believes there are no wild female dragons left, then he could have said so in the ancient language.

    What if there ARE dragons left and also FEMALE dragons? that would mean a proper “breeding” of dragons is still possible without saphira’s kids having to mate eachother

  • HeXrider

    About my last theory about another dragon being around: it’s even more plausible because of a few reasons:1 Galbatorix (tried to) destroy(ed) all evidence that contradicts his strength and the history of AL. So think how a dictator should: if there is a bigger power then you out of your reach, would you want it to become common knowledge? No! you will want your people to believe you are the strongest. I’m not gonna repeat myself but AL is much bigger then the map we saw. So there is much ground still left to explore. Remember that in the books was commented that the empire was much and much larger when the riders ruled. and that since galby remained the only of the Fornswon (correct?) left alive, the empire he controlled is much less big. Also the place where the wild dragons lived (east of du weldenvarden if i’m correct) isn’t anywhere on the mapsI love the idea of more dragon still alive, it would also make the subject of dragons as a race more interestingWhat if saphira isn’t the only one female dragon? Just because galby want’s his subjects to believe that doesn’t mean it is the absolute truth. Maybe he believes there are no wild female dragons left, then he could have said so in the ancient language. What if there ARE dragons left and also FEMALE dragons? that would mean a proper “breeding” of dragons is still possible without saphira’s kids having to mate eachother

  • MSJ

    Actually, after I just reread my Angela theory, I realize it’s total sh*t, lol. If she weren’t good at magic, she probably couldn’t summon at all and if so, would easily be overpowered. But hey, it was a thought, no?

  • MSJ

    Actually, after I just reread my Angela theory, I realize it’s total sh*t, lol. If she weren’t good at magic, she probably couldn’t summon at all and if so, would easily be overpowered. But hey, it was a thought, no?

  • MSJ

    I have a few thoughts to give here.

    1. It seems everyone wants to know what role, if any, the woman and teenage girl that Angela spoke with will have. I came up with a new direction. What did solembum say to the few people that Angela gave fortune-telling to? With Eragon, solembum’s words were-are vital. Could this be the same for everyone else he spoke to?

    2.As far as a wild dragon being alive, I find it almost a certainty. A few reasons. A)As some have said, there is how much territory outside of the empire’s control. It’s definitely important to consider. B)With Galby’s arrogance, it’s easily plausible that oromis/glaedr were not the only ones to hid well from the empire. Unless they strike first, Galbs is just gonna continue on his “project”. C) Also as many have stated, time is the problem with having to start with a hatchling unless they use twisted magic to speed it’s growth, which the varden won’t, so it’s almost for sure that another one is out there somewhere.

    3.What if Angela was successful at summoning spirits? Shades are from “evil” spirits taking over. What if Angela somehow prevented/avoided this misfortune? A)She is only human according to CP, correct? B)She is not very good at magic, if at all. C)As far as we know, there is no signs/proof that she could be/have been a rider, but there is more we DON’T know than we DO about her, lol.

    I had one or two more ideas/theories but they got lost on me during my typing. I look forward to hearing thoughts.

  • MSJ

    I have a few thoughts to give here.1. It seems everyone wants to know what role, if any, the woman and teenage girl that Angela spoke with will have. I came up with a new direction. What did solembum say to the few people that Angela gave fortune-telling to? With Eragon, solembum’s words were-are vital. Could this be the same for everyone else he spoke to?2.As far as a wild dragon being alive, I find it almost a certainty. A few reasons. A)As some have said, there is how much territory outside of the empire’s control. It’s definitely important to consider. B)With Galby’s arrogance, it’s easily plausible that oromis/glaedr were not the only ones to hid well from the empire. Unless they strike first, Galbs is just gonna continue on his “project”. C) Also as many have stated, time is the problem with having to start with a hatchling unless they use twisted magic to speed it’s growth, which the varden won’t, so it’s almost for sure that another one is out there somewhere.3.What if Angela was successful at summoning spirits? Shades are from “evil” spirits taking over. What if Angela somehow prevented/avoided this misfortune? A)She is only human according to CP, correct? B)She is not very good at magic, if at all. C)As far as we know, there is no signs/proof that she could be/have been a rider, but there is more we DON’T know than we DO about her, lol.I had one or two more ideas/theories but they got lost on me during my typing. I look forward to hearing thoughts.

  • MaggiMc1

    The RoK and the VoS are intricately linked. One is a location at which to find the other.

    I love the idea of a fully grown dragon already around. However the egg is definitely one of those magically promised to the rider’s (and is male) and we know a rider has a female dragon after Eragon leaves so a wild prehatched dragon would be in addition to the new dragons. Thats alot of dragons.

  • MaggiMc1

    The RoK and the VoS are intricately linked. One is a location at which to find the other. I love the idea of a fully grown dragon already around. However the egg is definitely one of those magically promised to the rider’s (and is male) and we know a rider has a female dragon after Eragon leaves so a wild prehatched dragon would be in addition to the new dragons. Thats alot of dragons.

  • hey

    1.the weapon under the meona tree is found with the elves
    2.The rock of Kuthian is w/ the dwarves
    3. The vault of souls is with the humans
    ???

  • hey

    1.the weapon under the meona tree is found with the elves2.The rock of Kuthian is w/ the dwarves3. The vault of souls is with the humans???

  • fantasyfan

    I think it makes the most sense. because we know eragon won’t leave alagaesia without arya and if the green dragon was a hatchling it wouldn’t make much of a difference in the war.

    although i was thinking the dragon would be in the beor mountains since it would be strong enough to fly to their tops. but the desert works to.

  • fantasyfan

    I think it makes the most sense. because we know eragon won’t leave alagaesia without arya and if the green dragon was a hatchling it wouldn’t make much of a difference in the war.although i was thinking the dragon would be in the beor mountains since it would be strong enough to fly to their tops. but the desert works to.

  • HeXrider

    No more abusing, first thingi did>register 😀

    Anyway the theory of a second egg/dragon is quit intriguing. I wouldn’t know if sapira would mate early in the book, but i don’t think so. Just because she is as intelligent as humans. So i wont think she will commit herself too soon to such things.

    I like the idea that another generations of dragons will stay in AL while eragon and another rider leave. that way the dragon aren’t completely extinct. And they still have hope of growing in vast numbers again.

    maybe there are still some wild dragon hidden somewhere? Galby only rules his part of the kingdom. Remember that dragons love the heat of the desert, and that at the eastern border of AL is unexplored. If you look closely to the map, the eastern part is desert and not sea so beyond that border could there be more dragons that have fled from galby?

  • HeXrider

    No more abusing, first thingi did>register :DAnyway the theory of a second egg/dragon is quit intriguing. I wouldn’t know if sapira would mate early in the book, but i don’t think so. Just because she is as intelligent as humans. So i wont think she will commit herself too soon to such things. I like the idea that another generations of dragons will stay in AL while eragon and another rider leave. that way the dragon aren’t completely extinct. And they still have hope of growing in vast numbers again.maybe there are still some wild dragon hidden somewhere? Galby only rules his part of the kingdom. Remember that dragons love the heat of the desert, and that at the eastern border of AL is unexplored. If you look closely to the map, the eastern part is desert and not sea so beyond that border could there be more dragons that have fled from galby?

  • HeXrider

    First of all after the Q&A thingy i wrote i didn’t writ (was asleep) so the comment to tulkas wasn’t mine (someone abused my guestname)

  • HeXrider

    First of all after the Q&A thingy i wrote i didn’t writ (was asleep) so the comment to tulkas wasn’t mine (someone abused my guestname)

  • Tulkas

    @MasterOfTheWraiths: Maggie stated my arguement there.

  • Tulkas

    @MasterOfTheWraiths: Maggie stated my arguement there.

  • fantasyfan

    I think there will be two dragons.

    One fully grown green dragon and a dragon hatchling as arya’s dragon. then arya and eragon will leave alagaesia forever like angela predicted and like in eragon’s vision.

    just a theory.

  • fantasyfan

    I think there will be two dragons.One fully grown green dragon and a dragon hatchling as arya’s dragon. then arya and eragon will leave alagaesia forever like angela predicted and like in eragon’s vision. just a theory.

  • MaggiMc1

    @Tulkas- Not necessarily. We have no idea who Nasuada’s mother is and therefore can not rule out any possible relatives based on that alone. (BTW I don’t see this comment as racist at all simply a genetic fact of inheritance, there was no negative connotation or derogatory reference… why is simply stating someone’s colour racist?) However, what would be added to the story by these people being related to Nasuada. She doesn’t seem like the warm bunny feelings type and has shown no loyalty to the wandering tribes over the rest of the Varden. However the strange women and teenager become important I feel it will have little to do with Nasuada.

    @Eldest: We don’t know if the green dragon will even hatch before the battle. He might not be helpful at all… However, based on the guide we know whoever Eragon is talking to rides a FEMALE dragon. We also know from Canon that the dragon in the egg is MALE. Therefore we will have to have two separate Dragons with two different rider’s appear in the story somewhere (the second most likely in an epilogue). We have no idea which of these Dragon’s in green because we don’t know the colour of the final egg. Unless there is one hell of an epilogue I’m thinking the first dragon needs to be hatched early enough in the story to include time to mate with Saphira (or for thorn to… that will still take some mighty story progression) and lay a second egg (assuming the one we know about already is ACTUALLY the last in AL and not just believed to be the last).
    It is possible that the egg in Galby’s possession doesn’t hatch at all in the story but it seems unlikely. How does this tell us if the dragon will be big enough to help… well is doesn’t really. My comment sort of went in a direction all it’s own but I feel like it is an important observation.

    Unrelated and off topic plea… To one of the wonderful team member’s… I can’t find my activation e-mail for MaggiMc and was wondering if it could be resent or manually activated. Thanks!

  • MaggiMc1

    @Tulkas- Not necessarily. We have no idea who Nasuada’s mother is and therefore can not rule out any possible relatives based on that alone. (BTW I don’t see this comment as racist at all simply a genetic fact of inheritance, there was no negative connotation or derogatory reference… why is simply stating someone’s colour racist?) However, what would be added to the story by these people being related to Nasuada. She doesn’t seem like the warm bunny feelings type and has shown no loyalty to the wandering tribes over the rest of the Varden. However the strange women and teenager become important I feel it will have little to do with Nasuada. @Eldest: We don’t know if the green dragon will even hatch before the battle. He might not be helpful at all… However, based on the guide we know whoever Eragon is talking to rides a FEMALE dragon. We also know from Canon that the dragon in the egg is MALE. Therefore we will have to have two separate Dragons with two different rider’s appear in the story somewhere (the second most likely in an epilogue). We have no idea which of these Dragon’s in green because we don’t know the colour of the final egg. Unless there is one hell of an epilogue I’m thinking the first dragon needs to be hatched early enough in the story to include time to mate with Saphira (or for thorn to… that will still take some mighty story progression) and lay a second egg (assuming the one we know about already is ACTUALLY the last in AL and not just believed to be the last). It is possible that the egg in Galby’s possession doesn’t hatch at all in the story but it seems unlikely. How does this tell us if the dragon will be big enough to help… well is doesn’t really. My comment sort of went in a direction all it’s own but I feel like it is an important observation. Unrelated and off topic plea… To one of the wonderful team member’s… I can’t find my activation e-mail for MaggiMc and was wondering if it could be resent or manually activated. Thanks!

  • Eldest

    Hey how would the green dragon grow fast enough to fight galby?
    Maybe they use that grith spell.
    Or I was thinking maybe Murtagh and Thorn turn good and steal the egg. They bring it to the Varden were it hatches (probbably for Arya). Then Galby gets all mad and comes after them. Eragon, Saphira, Mutagh, Thorn, the new rider, and his/her dragon thenhide in the vault of souls. Were Eragon and Murtagh train the new rider. Also Saphira and Thorn train the new dragon. Galby kills all the Varden and then the three riders topple him.
    What u guys think.

  • Eldest

    Hey how would the green dragon grow fast enough to fight galby?Maybe they use that grith spell.Or I was thinking maybe Murtagh and Thorn turn good and steal the egg. They bring it to the Varden were it hatches (probbably for Arya). Then Galby gets all mad and comes after them. Eragon, Saphira, Mutagh, Thorn, the new rider, and his/her dragon thenhide in the vault of souls. Were Eragon and Murtagh train the new rider. Also Saphira and Thorn train the new dragon. Galby kills all the Varden and then the three riders topple him.What u guys think.

  • MasterOfTheWraiths

    @CursedSight33: Thank’s, I haven’t found anything that makes it unlikely yet either, but i’m looking.

  • MasterOfTheWraiths

    @CursedSight33: Thank’s, I haven’t found anything that makes it unlikely yet either, but i’m looking.

  • HeXrider

    @tulkas that is so racist!

  • HeXrider

    @tulkas that is so racist!

  • Deidara

    Opps I mean where it probably takes place.

  • Deidara

    Opps I mean where it probably takes place.

  • Deidara

    Why would it be called brains if they are f inding an egg? Besides the next chapter is called Leona Lake so that means Belatona is where brains takes place.

  • Deidara

    Why would it be called brains if they are f inding an egg? Besides the next chapter is called Leona Lake so that means Belatona is where brains takes place.

  • HeXrider

    Great! a new Q&A hmm here goes another theory:

    Since animals can be shades. and more about magic is being explained in book 4 😀 how about his:

    Werecats are “good” types of shades. The live alone (like shades) the can change form with their magic, and they know of everything and want to be part of it. In that case, an alliance with werecats is incredibly valuable.

    Oromis has a family name that isn’t mentioned till book 4 so it’s of significance. What significance could a name be?

    What is the “thing that happened between galby and murthagh”?

    Just another wild theory 😀 comment if u like.

  • HeXrider

    Great! a new Q&A hmm here goes another theory:Since animals can be shades. and more about magic is being explained in book 4 😀 how about his:Werecats are “good” types of shades. The live alone (like shades) the can change form with their magic, and they know of everything and want to be part of it. In that case, an alliance with werecats is incredibly valuable.Oromis has a family name that isn’t mentioned till book 4 so it’s of significance. What significance could a name be? What is the “thing that happened between galby and murthagh”? Just another wild theory 😀 comment if u like.

  • Tulkas

    The.one- For those people to be related to Nasuada, they would have to be black.

  • Tulkas

    The.one- For those people to be related to Nasuada, they would have to be black.

  • voiceofreason

    Brains might be the chapter where they try to steel the dragon egg from Galby… Idk!

  • voiceofreason

    Brains might be the chapter where they try to steel the dragon egg from Galby… Idk!

  • Deidara

    Does anybody have a theory about the chapter 8: brains?

  • Deidara

    Does anybody have a theory about the chapter 8: brains?

  • iloveeragon

    the 4th book needs to come out i want to read it sooo bad!

  • iloveeragon

    the 4th book needs to come out i want to read it sooo bad!

  • Were176cRider

    Sirsimon-noble birth does not mean royal, it could just be someone of noble character.

  • Were176cRider

    Sirsimon-noble birth does not mean royal, it could just be someone of noble character.

  • HeXrider

    Good Theory about murtagh, i hope he will change sides, and i think he will that way the green dragon and rider aren’t necessarily needed in the battle but it could happen that three dragons and riders stand up to galby. I hope they don’t kill shruikan though. He’s innocent to all the crimes galby has committed.

    who knows…. i like to think how in the future when we all have the 4th book i will think back to these discussions thinking about things we were right about 😀 things we discussed etc.

    can’t wait for the 4th to come… but i’ll just have to be patient. The longer the waiting the better appreciated the reward.

  • HeXrider

    Good Theory about murtagh, i hope he will change sides, and i think he will that way the green dragon and rider aren’t necessarily needed in the battle but it could happen that three dragons and riders stand up to galby. I hope they don’t kill shruikan though. He’s innocent to all the crimes galby has committed. who knows…. i like to think how in the future when we all have the 4th book i will think back to these discussions thinking about things we were right about 😀 things we discussed etc. can’t wait for the 4th to come… but i’ll just have to be patient. The longer the waiting the better appreciated the reward.

  • yo.blagden

    I also agree with the theory that the rock is related to the forsworn’s dragons or their Eldunari.Becoz Arya &Oromis have heard of it but do not recollect it.Elves hardly forget something [especially ones like a princess &a dragonrider.]It could be the effect of the Banishing of Names.

  • yo.blagden

    I also agree with the theory that the rock is related to the forsworn’s dragons or their Eldunari.Becoz Arya &Oromis have heard of it but do not recollect it.Elves hardly forget something [especially ones like a princess &a dragonrider.]It could be the effect of the Banishing of Names.

  • yo.blagden

    In the Inheritance books ‘rock’ is connected with dwarves.So rock of kuthian maybe related to them.Afterall menoa tree was related to elves so the rock cud be related to dwarves.

  • yo.blagden

    In the Inheritance books ‘rock’ is connected with dwarves.So rock of kuthian maybe related to them.Afterall menoa tree was related to elves so the rock cud be related to dwarves.

  • The.one

    haha sirsimon, i think the words that brom told eragon are the 7 different words for duck in the ancient language.:)

  • The.one

    haha sirsimon, i think the words that brom told eragon are the 7 different words for duck in the ancient language.:)

  • voiceofreason

    @sirsimon DUDE! I never thought about Galby capturing Nasuada and all that…

  • voiceofreason

    @sirsimon DUDE! I never thought about Galby capturing Nasuada and all that…

  • The.one

    i know i just posted but i came up wit something. the battle in the fourth book is probly belatona, the next city the varden were going to attack, and lord bradburn is the governer guy there.

  • The.one

    i know i just posted but i came up wit something. the battle in the fourth book is probly belatona, the next city the varden were going to attack, and lord bradburn is the governer guy there.

  • sirsimon

    I believe the seven words that Brom spoke of has three possibilities,

    1) the true name of the ancient language

    2) the true name of Alagaesia, therefore everyone in the land will unite and fight against Galbatorix.

    3) the true name of Eragon I

  • sirsimon

    I believe the seven words that Brom spoke of has three possibilities,

    1) the true name of the ancient language
    2) the true name of Alagaesia, therefore everyone in the land will unite and fight against Galbatorix.
    3) the true name of Eragon I

  • The.one

    Oh theory! i think that the woman and her daughter that eragon blessed and engela gave there fortune, are ralated to nasuada.

  • sirsimon

    I think Nasuada and Eragon will not get together, because it would be of royal blood.

    Though Nasuada is the daughter of the leader of the Varden, she isn’t a princess descended from a royal line.

    We must remember that the varden is a kingdom, but a rebel faction created only shortly after Galbatorix’s reign, about 80 years before the first book.

    Generally, Nasauda would have to have been born from a thousand year old line of queens and kings.

    Therefore in conclusion, it would be Arya, because Nasuada is the daughter of a rebellious ruler, whom declared himself leader by choosing, not blood.

    Arya has descended from a line dating back thousands of years, probably to the time of the dragon riders creation.

    So unless I am mistaken, or something strange happens, Eragon and Nasauda will not have a relationship.

    A more possible theory is Galbatorix capturing Nasauda as a ransom victim, or to discover a varden secret. This would anger Murtagh and this would make him take action against the king, therefore changing his true name.

    A final thing to the Nasauda/Eragon relationship is that she probably won’t be a rider, nor will Elva. Elva was destined to be a normal child, but Eragon changed her fate, and this wasn’t intended by time. Elva in reality is just a child, even a baby that has been given a curse, therefore she isn’t worthy of becoming the next rider. Nasuada, though a leader, she is the leader of a group that have no ties to nobility, royality, there are more an extremist group, like the quakers of england.

    Arya fits both, she is of royal heritage and her fate is to be the bride of the rider.

    that will be her title.

    thanks for listening intentively. hopefully my words will spark discussion.

  • The.one

    Oh theory! i think that the woman and her daughter that eragon blessed and engela gave there fortune, are ralated to nasuada.

  • sirsimon

    I think Nasuada and Eragon will not get together, because it would be of royal blood.

    Though Nasuada is the daughter of the leader of the Varden, she isn’t a princess descended from a royal line.

    We must remember that the varden is a kingdom, but a rebel faction created only shortly after Galbatorix’s reign, about 80 years before the first book.
    Generally, Nasauda would have to have been born from a thousand year old line of queens and kings.

    Therefore in conclusion, it would be Arya, because Nasuada is the daughter of a rebellious ruler, whom declared himself leader by choosing, not blood.
    Arya has descended from a line dating back thousands of years, probably to the time of the dragon riders creation.
    So unless I am mistaken, or something strange happens, Eragon and Nasauda will not have a relationship.
    A more possible theory is Galbatorix capturing Nasauda as a ransom victim, or to discover a varden secret. This would anger Murtagh and this would make him take action against the king, therefore changing his true name.
    A final thing to the Nasauda/Eragon relationship is that she probably won’t be a rider, nor will Elva. Elva was destined to be a normal child, but Eragon changed her fate, and this wasn’t intended by time. Elva in reality is just a child, even a baby that has been given a curse, therefore she isn’t worthy of becoming the next rider. Nasuada, though a leader, she is the leader of a group that have no ties to nobility, royality, there are more an extremist group, like the quakers of england.

    Arya fits both, she is of royal heritage and her fate is to be the bride of the rider.

    that will be her title.

    thanks for listening intentively. hopefully my words will spark discussion.

  • The.one

    i still think that when eragon lives alagaisia i think it will just be changing the name of alagaisia its self

  • The.one

    i still think that when eragon lives alagaisia i think it will just be changing the name of alagaisia its self

  • enigo.montoya

    i dont think that nasuada is eragons epic romance because shes not of royal blood as far as i knnow.

  • enigo.montoya

    i dont think that nasuada is eragons epic romance because shes not of royal blood as far as i knnow.

  • zasekr1

    although the theory that the rock of kuthian is morzans dragon is good i think that its incorrect for the very fact that its name can be said by somebody, when the dragons preformed the banishing of the names the forsworn’s dragons names were erased completely from everything so the fact that both oromis and arya remember but do not know why they cant fully recall and that solembum and others are able to say and remeber the rock of kuithians name means that it cant be morzans dragons elenduri or what ever the theory stated because they can still remember in a way

  • zasekr1

    although the theory that the rock of kuthian is morzans dragon is good i think that its incorrect for the very fact that its name can be said by somebody, when the dragons preformed the banishing of the names the forsworn’s dragons names were erased completely from everything so the fact that both oromis and arya remember but do not know why they cant fully recall and that solembum and others are able to say and remeber the rock of kuithians name means that it cant be morzans dragons elenduri or what ever the theory stated because they can still remember in a way

  • oromismaster

    i cant wait for the 4th book to come out,but i think it is a good theory that the rock of kuthian was morzans dragon.

  • oromismaster

    i cant wait for the 4th book to come out,but i think it is a good theory that the rock of kuthian was morzans dragon.

  • scififantasylover

    Ooo, will the fourth book be released at the same time in England as USA?

  • scififantasylover

    Ooo, will the fourth book be released at the same time in England as USA?

  • scififantasylover

    There’s some pretty good theories. :>
    I like that the Spine may be important. Kinda ironic that Eragon returns to his home.
    Angela has got to be crucial to the plot of the fourth book (empire?). Remember Tenga in Brisingr… he knew Angela.
    Also, the green dragon could be outside of alagaesia and Eragon meets it when he leaves alagaesia forever.

  • scififantasylover

    There’s some pretty good theories. :>I like that the Spine may be important. Kinda ironic that Eragon returns to his home.Angela has got to be crucial to the plot of the fourth book (empire?). Remember Tenga in Brisingr… he knew Angela. Also, the green dragon could be outside of alagaesia and Eragon meets it when he leaves alagaesia forever.

  • HeXrider

    Good thinking that, would ben a good twitch in the storyline. Maybe that too will cripple galbatorix’ courage to defeat the varden. maybe that’s why he let Durza enslave the urgals. Maybe that’s why he sent his army there, to find hi original dragons’ HoH.

    like that theory 😀

  • HeXrider

    Good thinking that, would ben a good twitch in the storyline. Maybe that too will cripple galbatorix’ courage to defeat the varden. maybe that’s why he let Durza enslave the urgals. Maybe that’s why he sent his army there, to find hi original dragons’ HoH.like that theory 😀

  • FireFox

    HeXrider- I was thinking, Galbatorix’s original dragon was killed by urgals. What if the dragon’s Edulnari is in the Vault of Souls and he helps Eragon when fighting Galbatorix?

  • FireFox

    HeXrider- I was thinking, Galbatorix’s original dragon was killed by urgals. What if the dragon’s Edulnari is in the Vault of Souls and he helps Eragon when fighting Galbatorix?

  • Eldest

    It’s the true name of the ancient language.

  • Eldest

    It’s the true name of the ancient language.

  • vioceofreason

    @sififantasylover: I think that is a legit theory!

    Eragon obviosly deeply respects Nausada, and she is always looking for ways to make the rebellion stronger, and form new ties… I kinda like that idea!

  • vioceofreason

    @sififantasylover: I think that is a legit theory!
    Eragon obviosly deeply respects Nausada, and she is always looking for ways to make the rebellion stronger, and form new ties… I kinda like that idea!

  • Mistgun1204

    @Harts- The one he did in October 2008 it’s on this site.

  • Mistgun1204

    @Harts- The one he did in October 2008 it’s on this site.

  • Harts

    mistgun- What interview did CP say that?

  • Harts

    mistgun- What interview did CP say that?

  • Mistgun1204

    I just listened to the interview CP and he said Galby’s sword will make quite the impression. I think Galby might have Brom’s Dragon Rider Sword.

    Just a thought.

  • Mistgun1204

    I just listened to the interview CP and he said Galby’s sword will make quite the impression. I think Galby might have Brom’s Dragon Rider Sword.Just a thought.

  • H3ND

    LOL

    I’m not gunna worry about it

    just forget it for a year or so and i’ll know when it’s out :]

  • H3ND

    LOL
    I’m not gunna worry about it
    just forget it for a year or so and i’ll know when it’s out :]

  • CursedSight33

    btw dragonrider360 i think that CP just needed a way to make the Dwarves hate the dragons enough that they would not join in the magic bestowed upon the elves and later the humans. He would have need of these things for many of the plot parts in the book such as Az Sweldn rak Anhuin hating and almost killing Eragon. Other than that i dont think there will be a given reason.

  • CursedSight33

    btw dragonrider360 i think that CP just needed a way to make the Dwarves hate the dragons enough that they would not join in the magic bestowed upon the elves and later the humans. He would have need of these things for many of the plot parts in the book such as Az Sweldn rak Anhuin hating and almost killing Eragon. Other than that i dont think there will be a given reason.

  • CursedSight33

    i would really like to find out the fate of sloan in the last book as well as seeing more angela. These two characters are very underrated compared with Arya and Roran ect… but i think sloan could possibly play a big part in the final outcome of things especially because of the influence he could have on Roran and Katrina if they discover him. And just as a question does anyone think that Eragons guide to Alagaesia is worth buying because it looks like it just recaps the books but ive seen that it has some letters and such??????? worth the money????

  • CursedSight33

    i would really like to find out the fate of sloan in the last book as well as seeing more angela. These two characters are very underrated compared with Arya and Roran ect… but i think sloan could possibly play a big part in the final outcome of things especially because of the influence he could have on Roran and Katrina if they discover him. And just as a question does anyone think that Eragons guide to Alagaesia is worth buying because it looks like it just recaps the books but ive seen that it has some letters and such??????? worth the money????

  • CursedSight33

    masterofwraiths your comment is utterly amazing! i cant believe i have not though of that before. It makes almost perfect sense. i haven’t found any denial of this theory when reading the books and the urgals could have many heart of hearts. Remember they killed galby’s dragon so maybe that is what he was after in the spine!!!!!!

  • CursedSight33

    masterofwraiths your comment is utterly amazing! i cant believe i have not though of that before. It makes almost perfect sense. i haven’t found any denial of this theory when reading the books and the urgals could have many heart of hearts. Remember they killed galby’s dragon so maybe that is what he was after in the spine!!!!!!

  • Dragonrider360

    Dwarves, I mean, not draves. Opps….

  • Dragonrider360

    Dwarves, I mean, not draves. Opps….

  • Dragonrider360

    Opps…..should’ve read farther. Also in Eragon (on page 387) Murtagh says there may be other children of the Forsworn. That would be cool. And on page 411 Ajihad said that dragons stool the draves gold. Why? And draves live longer than humans. How long? And how old was Hrothgar when he died? Last question( although they never end), on page 453 the first book said that Ajihad came alone with Nasuada to the Varden. What happended to her mother and who was her mother?

  • Dragonrider360

    Opps…..should’ve read farther. Also in Eragon (on page 387) Murtagh says there may be other children of the Forsworn. That would be cool. And on page 411 Ajihad said that dragons stool the draves gold. Why? And draves live longer than humans. How long? And how old was Hrothgar when he died? Last question( although they never end), on page 453 the first book said that Ajihad came alone with Nasuada to the Varden. What happended to her mother and who was her mother?

  • scififantasylover

    OMG! I really cannot wait until the fourth book comes out. Just finished reading Brisingr for the umpteenth time. I love the series! IWhern is the fourth book released in England?????? By the way, has anyone thought that the epic romance may be between Eragon and Nasuada?

  • scififantasylover

    OMG! I really cannot wait until the fourth book comes out. Just finished reading Brisingr for the umpteenth time. I love the series! IWhern is the fourth book released in England?????? By the way, has anyone thought that the epic romance may be between Eragon and Nasuada?

  • Were176cRider

    Seven-I did not mean that CP is a slow writer. Most of the Harry Potter Books took 2-3 years to come out. All I am saying is that James Patterson practically breathes a new book every month.

  • Were176cRider

    Seven-I did not mean that CP is a slow writer. Most of the Harry Potter Books took 2-3 years to come out. All I am saying is that James Patterson practically breathes a new book every month.

  • HeXrider

    hmmm nice theory about the VoS. That could also mean we now kow WHY galbatorix send his army into the spine.

    Maybe he tried to get there himself and allmost died, so he tried the second time with his entire army. It is also said the urgals live in the spine, maybe they know exactly where the VoS could be, that would be interesting because maybe the VoS is some holy place for them.

    Since eragon got an invitation to visit the urgal town from nar garvrog (dunno if i type it right), maybe he can get the respect of the urgals. remember that roran also earned their respect by wrestling one and winning. So they could search together.

    Maybe the urgals are bound to the spine, maybe they are bound to defend the VoS. So that could be the reason they want to win the battle. So they are no longer bound to guard it against galby (since he is dead then). And ten they can make a piece of land for their own

  • HeXrider

    hmmm nice theory about the VoS. That could also mean we now kow WHY galbatorix send his army into the spine.Maybe he tried to get there himself and allmost died, so he tried the second time with his entire army. It is also said the urgals live in the spine, maybe they know exactly where the VoS could be, that would be interesting because maybe the VoS is some holy place for them.Since eragon got an invitation to visit the urgal town from nar garvrog (dunno if i type it right), maybe he can get the respect of the urgals. remember that roran also earned their respect by wrestling one and winning. So they could search together.Maybe the urgals are bound to the spine, maybe they are bound to defend the VoS. So that could be the reason they want to win the battle. So they are no longer bound to guard it against galby (since he is dead then). And ten they can make a piece of land for their own

  • MasterOfTheWraiths

    Since no body seems to be able to recall where they heard of The Rock of Kuthian, but say it sound’s familiar, could Kuthian be the name of one of the Forsworns dragon? Morzan’s,, perhap’s?

  • MasterOfTheWraiths

    Since no body seems to be able to recall where they heard of The Rock of Kuthian, but say it sound’s familiar, could Kuthian be the name of one of the Forsworns dragon? Morzan’s,, perhap’s?

  • MasterOfTheWraiths

    @ Vermilius (guest).
    Note that Galbatorix did lose half of his army in the Spine, which could also be a reason he doesn’t send anyone there (maybe in conjunction with your theory).

  • MasterOfTheWraiths

    @ Vermilius (guest).Note that Galbatorix did lose half of his army in the Spine, which could also be a reason he doesn’t send anyone there (maybe in conjunction with your theory).

  • Ty

    I bet that Roran is the green rider. The brothers will be reunited and they will play a significant role.

  • Ty

    I bet that Roran is the green rider. The brothers will be reunited and they will play a significant role.

  • iloveeragon

    Oops! i mean the 4th book to come out. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    Oops! i mean the 4th book to come out. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    im just glad he wrote the books. i started reading them in april 2010 like 2-3 weeks ago. i started reading them cuz this whole year all i read was one-worded titles and eragon, eldest, and brisingr were all one-worded titles and im glad i started reading those kind of books or i wouldnt of read it. so i am very happy. i told my brother about them and he started reading about a week ago and he really likes them to we both cant wait for them to come out.

  • iloveeragon

    im just glad he wrote the books. i started reading them in april 2010 like 2-3 weeks ago. i started reading them cuz this whole year all i read was one-worded titles and eragon, eldest, and brisingr were all one-worded titles and im glad i started reading those kind of books or i wouldnt of read it. so i am very happy. i told my brother about them and he started reading about a week ago and he really likes them to we both cant wait for them to come out.

  • Seven

    Were176cRider – lol well obviously some authors can write books in one year or less. Yes, you’re right, some authors like James Patterson practically sneeze them out. But i said most, not all, books take more than two years (depending on the genre). Especially when they’re as popular as the Inheritance books, and especially when they are written by first-time authors like CP.

  • Seven

    Were176cRider – lol well obviously some authors can write books in one year or less. Yes, you’re right, some authors like James Patterson practically sneeze them out. But i said most, not all, books take more than two years (depending on the genre). Especially when they’re as popular as the Inheritance books, and especially when they are written by first-time authors like CP.

  • Vermilius

    I have a theory why Galbatorix is so afraid of the spine and doesn´t want anyone to go there, it’s because the vault of souls that was prophetized to eragon is there and the vault has edulnari of drgons that fought galbatorix and with the riders they found a way to guard them there and only someone who is the one who is prophetized to defeat galbatorix can enter there, thats my theory

  • Vermilius

    I have a theory why Galbatorix is so afraid of the spine and doesn´t want anyone to go there, it’s because the vault of souls that was prophetized to eragon is there and the vault has edulnari of drgons that fought galbatorix and with the riders they found a way to guard them there and only someone who is the one who is prophetized to defeat galbatorix can enter there, thats my theory

  • HeXrider

    i am still very interested in all of you opinion what he unnamed shadow could be? anyone?

  • HeXrider

    i am still very interested in all of you opinion what he unnamed shadow could be? anyone?

  • voiceofreason

    Dragonrider360- it later goes on to say that Eragon realised what was wrong… “He was captured by Urgals, not humans.” At that time he didn’t know that the Empire made a treaty with the Urgals.

    harts- I have been asking myself that question too! I was thinking maybe Helgrind or the Spine…

  • voiceofreason

    Dragonrider360- it later goes on to say that Eragon realised what was wrong… “He was captured by Urgals, not humans.” At that time he didn’t know that the Empire made a treaty with the Urgals.

    harts- I have been asking myself that question too! I was thinking maybe Helgrind or the Spine…

  • Were176cRider

    Seven, that is not true. James Patterson writes about 5 books each year, from like 5 different series.

  • Were176cRider

    Seven, that is not true. James Patterson writes about 5 books each year, from like 5 different series.

  • Seven

    Joeragon – yes, you are being a tad unreasonable. Brisingr was released barely two years ago. In the world of books, that is nothing. Generally, two years is the absolute minimum waiting time for a book to come out. Most take 3 to 5, and often more. Besides, most authors give absolutely nothing away until the book is released. Paolini has given us numerous Q&A’s. That is quite generous.Patience. It’s not the same as waiting for something like a movie to come out.

  • Seven

    Joeragon – yes, you are being a tad unreasonable. Brisingr was released barely two years ago. In the world of books, that is nothing. Generally, two years is the absolute minimum waiting time for a book to come out. Most take 3 to 5, and often more. Besides, most authors give absolutely nothing away until the book is released. Paolini has given us numerous Q&A’s. That is quite generous.

    Patience. It’s not the same as waiting for something like a movie to come out.

  • dragoneater

    unnamed shadow… could have something to do with galby’s true name or maybe he changed his true name somehow. i remember when eragon slayed the last razac, he told him that galby was close to finding out the name, but didn’t mention whose name.
    or it could be that he jsut didn’t want to mention galby’s name so as not to stir up the new rider’s emotions, similar to Lord Voldemort.

  • dragoneater

    unnamed shadow… could have something to do with galby’s true name or maybe he changed his true name somehow. i remember when eragon slayed the last razac, he told him that galby was close to finding out the name, but didn’t mention whose name. or it could be that he jsut didn’t want to mention galby’s name so as not to stir up the new rider’s emotions, similar to Lord Voldemort.

  • Were176cRider

    DragonRider360-

    Don’t be so critical of your theories. It may well indeed be important, but we just don’t know why yet.

  • Were176cRider

    DragonRider360-

    Don’t be so critical of your theories. It may well indeed be important, but we just don’t know why yet.

  • Dragonrider360

    I’ve been reading Eragon for, like, the 5th time and I came across a paragrah( this was when Eragon was imprisoned in Gil’ead) that said:

    “A street full of busy people ran past the side of his cell, beyond which were rows of identical log houses. Feeling weak, Eragon slid to the floor and stared at it blankly. What he had seen outside disturbed him, but he was unsure why.” (Paolini,293). This may have no signifigance whatsoever, but what disturbed Eragon in his cell?

  • Dragonrider360

    I’ve been reading Eragon for, like, the 5th time and I came across a paragrah( this was when Eragon was imprisoned in Gil’ead) that said:

    “A street full of busy people ran past the side of his cell, beyond which were rows of identical log houses. Feeling weak, Eragon slid to the floor and stared at it blankly. What he had seen outside disturbed him, but he was unsure why.” (Paolini,293). This may have no signifigance whatsoever, but what disturbed Eragon in his cell?

  • Tulkas

    JOEragon- Yes, commiting suicide because you have to wait a few months for book 4 news is unreasonable.

  • Tulkas

    JOEragon- Yes, commiting suicide because you have to wait a few months for book 4 news is unreasonable.

  • harts

    In eragon, Brom recounts the story of the fall of the riders. During his narrative, Brom says that after morzan helped Galbatorix steal a new dragon, they fled and hid on “an evil place the riders dare not venture.” what could possibly have freightened the riders at the height of their power so much they were freightened to approach it?
    Thoughts? ideas?

  • harts

    In eragon, Brom recounts the story of the fall of the riders. During his narrative, Brom says that after morzan helped Galbatorix steal a new dragon, they fled and hid on “an evil place the riders dare not venture.” what could possibly have freightened the riders at the height of their power so much they were freightened to approach it?Thoughts? ideas?

  • Dragonrider360

    Um….well that sort of sucks…. Well, I like your theory! 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    Um….well that sort of sucks…. Well, I like your theory! 🙂

  • JOEragon

    This doesn’t go with the conversations but I just wanna say, I finished Brisingr the day after it came out and I was pissed when I got on the computer and there wasn’t anything on the fourth book. I’m about to kill myself because there isn’t any release date on the fourth yet. Am I being unreasonable?

  • JOEragon

    This doesn’t go with the conversations but I just wanna say, I finished Brisingr the day after it came out and I was pissed when I got on the computer and there wasn’t anything on the fourth book. I’m about to kill myself because there isn’t any release date on the fourth yet. Am I being unreasonable?

  • HeXrider

    i state from the letter in the guide: … When an unnamed shadow stalks the land.

    What is this unamed shadow? Galby has a name shruikan has a name, shades have names, so what is this ?

    Your training will have to wait until saphira and i return.
    So he is away for something(battle or some quest) And he is hereby saying that the rider WILL be trained.

    What i am saying is that the new rider DOES have tie to get trained. So in book 4 not all battles will go without end, and if they do, then AFTER galby is dead the rider will be trained. All i’m saying is that training takes a lot of time. even when Eragon himself was trained very fast.

    ..Who live in this hall, could be Ellesmera hall, or in farthen dur. (dont recall the name of ellesmera hall)

    ..recall us as part of your family.
    Us? being ONLY eragon and saphira? or us like all the elves? He end’s with the elven goodbye so i say the new rider is somewhere in ellesmera

    ideas theories?

  • HeXrider

    i state from the letter in the guide: … When an unnamed shadow stalks the land. What is this unamed shadow? Galby has a name shruikan has a name, shades have names, so what is this ?Your training will have to wait until saphira and i return.So he is away for something(battle or some quest) And he is hereby saying that the rider WILL be trained. What i am saying is that the new rider DOES have tie to get trained. So in book 4 not all battles will go without end, and if they do, then AFTER galby is dead the rider will be trained. All i’m saying is that training takes a lot of time. even when Eragon himself was trained very fast…Who live in this hall, could be Ellesmera hall, or in farthen dur. (dont recall the name of ellesmera hall)..recall us as part of your family. Us? being ONLY eragon and saphira? or us like all the elves? He end’s with the elven goodbye so i say the new rider is somewhere in ellesmeraideas theories?

  • dragoneater

    doesn’t kvetha shur’tugal just mean welcome dragon rider?

  • dragoneater

    doesn’t kvetha shur’tugal just mean welcome dragon rider?

  • yo.blagden

    The dragonrider cud not be Trianna.In ER guide 2 AL- Eragon wrote ‘Kvetha Shur’tugal’He doesnt know who the rider is; just that there is 1.

  • yo.blagden

    The dragonrider cud not be Trianna.In ER guide 2 AL- Eragon wrote ‘Kvetha Shur’tugal’He doesnt know who the rider is; just that there is 1.

  • yo.blagden

    Dragonrider360-Brom gave Eragon a blessing.Generally blessings r like ”May..or Let…”.U know how Brom said he defeated his enemies with BRAINS not just by battering against their mind.May be he gave some trick or advice or spell of that sort.

    Hey I know u’ll think I m silly but cud the chapter in bk4 ‘Brains’ be about this?

  • dragoneater

    Was Trianna in all 3 books? What about the possibility of her being the next rider? Eragon has always kinda had a thing for that chick.

  • yo.blagden

    Dragonrider360-Brom gave Eragon a blessing.Generally blessings r like ”May..or Let…”.U know how Brom said he defeated his enemies with BRAINS not just by battering against their mind.May be he gave some trick or advice or spell of that sort. Hey I know u’ll think I m silly but cud the chapter in bk4 ‘Brains’ be about this?

  • dragoneater

    Was Trianna in all 3 books? What about the possibility of her being the next rider? Eragon has always kinda had a thing for that chick.

  • dragoneater

    I don’t think Vanir was in all 3 books. I’m not sure where we heard that was a qualification from i think a q&a w/ CP. otherwise i think Vanir would be a sweet rider.

  • dragoneater

    I don’t think Vanir was in all 3 books. I’m not sure where we heard that was a qualification from i think a q&a w/ CP. otherwise i think Vanir would be a sweet rider.

  • zasekr1

    the egg’s new rider could be vanir if its an elf

    OMG!

    i just remebered CP said that the next dragon would be green not that the last egg would be green! in my mind that supports my and everyone else view that there is another green dragon out there!!

  • zasekr1

    the egg’s new rider could be vanir if its an elf

    OMG!
    i just remebered CP said that the next dragon would be green not that the last egg would be green! in my mind that supports my and everyone else view that there is another green dragon out there!!

  • Were176cRider

    All I have to say about the new dragon-rider is that it better not be Elva. She is way too annoying. PDBE(PLEASE DON’T BE ELVA!!!!!)

  • Were176cRider

    All I have to say about the new dragon-rider is that it better not be Elva. She is way too annoying. PDBE(PLEASE DON’T BE ELVA!!!!!)

  • Dragonrider360

    yo.blagden: Its on page 1 of the Q&A: Solotions and Questions. Better hurry, though. I think there going to shut down the comments on that page.

    I think there is a rider or a dragon already out there. Possibly in the Spine. Just a question: What goes on in Vronengard nowadays? I think the green dragon will hatch to an elf, not nessicerily Arya, but an elf.

  • Dragonrider360

    yo.blagden: Its on page 1 of the Q&A: Solotions and Questions. Better hurry, though. I think there going to shut down the comments on that page.

    I think there is a rider or a dragon already out there. Possibly in the Spine. Just a question: What goes on in Vronengard nowadays? I think the green dragon will hatch to an elf, not nessicerily Arya, but an elf.

  • zasekr1

    i’d say that there is another dragon out there sumwhere thats gona make an appearance. i dont think that the last egg will hatch untill the end making it a nice ending and the fact that there was egg shards in du fells nagroth in eldest . so another dragon/rider will make an appearance during the 4th book n help eragon win and steal the last egg

  • zasekr1

    i’d say that there is another dragon out there sumwhere thats gona make an appearance. i dont think that the last egg will hatch untill the end making it a nice ending and the fact that there was egg shards in du fells nagroth in eldest . so another dragon/rider will make an appearance during the 4th book n help eragon win and steal the last egg

  • Were176cRider

    Whoever Greenie’s dragon rider is, we shouldn’t expect anything. CP always switches the popular ideas at the last second, and then we have to deal with it. I don’t think its fair for us to get our hopes up without 100% evidence of who the new rider will be.

  • Were176cRider

    Whoever Greenie’s dragon rider is, we shouldn’t expect anything. CP always switches the popular ideas at the last second, and then we have to deal with it. I don’t think its fair for us to get our hopes up without 100% evidence of who the new rider will be.

  • Were176cRider

    Is it just me, or does anyone else think that the new dragon won’t hatch until the end of the novel?

  • Were176cRider

    Is it just me, or does anyone else think that the new dragon won’t hatch until the end of the novel?

  • DEVINslayer333

    idk who posted it but broms dragon was blue because in brisingr when eragon is lookikng for a sword he asked rhuon about broms sword because it was the same color..do u guys remeber? ill look up the page later

  • DEVINslayer333

    idk who posted it but broms dragon was blue because in brisingr when eragon is lookikng for a sword he asked rhuon about broms sword because it was the same color..do u guys remeber? ill look up the page later

  • MSJ

    Oh another quick thing.

    When Eragon gets hostile, if you will, when Angela laughs at discovering Brom’s name, she says “Peace, peace”. I wonder if “cheep, cheep” wasn’t just the werecats way of saying “peace, peace”.

  • MSJ

    Oh another quick thing.When Eragon gets hostile, if you will, when Angela laughs at discovering Brom’s name, she says “Peace, peace”. I wonder if “cheep, cheep” wasn’t just the werecats way of saying “peace, peace”.

  • iloveeragon

    msj- notto be rude but everything has a true name even a blade of grass has a true name so im positive that werecats have true names too.

    i think he used to be called something else and did something to make people mad and angela may have known so she took him as a pet and changed his name.

  • iloveeragon

    msj- notto be rude but everything has a true name even a blade of grass has a true name so im positive that werecats have true names too.

    i think he used to be called something else and did something to make people mad and angela may have known so she took him as a pet and changed his name.

  • MSJ

    zasekr1- thank you for the explanation. I didn’t read Eragon’s guide, so I was unaware.

    On yet another side note, I noticed something else I personally found interesting. On page 201 of Eragon when Eragon first meets Solembum, Solembum tells Eragon “If you are looking for my proper name, you’ll have to look elsewhere. However, you may call me Solembum.”

    could his PROPER name be his TRUE name? If so, I would think the werecats are the decendants of the grey folk. As far as I am aware, only elves and humans could have true names. Perhaps I’m just overanalyzing a bit.

    Thoughts?

  • MSJ

    zasekr1- thank you for the explanation. I didn’t read Eragon’s guide, so I was unaware. On yet another side note, I noticed something else I personally found interesting. On page 201 of Eragon when Eragon first meets Solembum, Solembum tells Eragon “If you are looking for my proper name, you’ll have to look elsewhere. However, you may call me Solembum.”could his PROPER name be his TRUE name? If so, I would think the werecats are the decendants of the grey folk. As far as I am aware, only elves and humans could have true names. Perhaps I’m just overanalyzing a bit. Thoughts?

  • eragonrocks

    As you all know I havn’t posted for a while and this topic is totally different from the main one but do you think that Arya will in the fourth book marry eragon and if Arya is the greenie rider and when the book ends Arya is pregnant and C.P makes a new series about eragon and Arya’s child being the rider if greenie is a boy and mates with Saphira causing Saphira to lay an egg or two which eragon and Arya’s child becomes rider to and starts a new epic adventure.

  • eragonrocks

    As you all know I havn’t posted for a while and this topic is totally different from the main one but do you think that Arya will in the fourth book marry eragon and if Arya is the greenie rider and when the book ends Arya is pregnant and C.P makes a new series about eragon and Arya’s child being the rider if greenie is a boy and mates with Saphira causing Saphira to lay an egg or two which eragon and Arya’s child becomes rider to and starts a new epic adventure.

  • MistGun1204

    What Dream are you guys talking about?

  • MistGun1204

    What Dream are you guys talking about?

  • iloveeragon

    i was rereading some of the comments and it was about eragons dream. k so you know how two dragons are going to be flying off the beach and somebody is on the shore screaming. i think the other dragon and rider is either murtagh and thorn or greenie and its rider. and the person on the shore is galby screaming.

    i say this because somebody said the book dominance of fate predicted a terrible event that will destroy the whole of AL. and eragon leaving could be him not defeating galby and having galby curse him so that he will leave AL forever and regrets cursing eragon afterwards.and he may of found his true name and told eragon to leave and never come back.(and galbys drgaon could of died also)

    wow that was alot of typing 🙂 hope you like my theory

  • iloveeragon

    i was rereading some of the comments and it was about eragons dream. k so you know how two dragons are going to be flying off the beach and somebody is on the shore screaming. i think the other dragon and rider is either murtagh and thorn or greenie and its rider. and the person on the shore is galby screaming.

    i say this because somebody said the book dominance of fate predicted a terrible event that will destroy the whole of AL. and eragon leaving could be him not defeating galby and having galby curse him so that he will leave AL forever and regrets cursing eragon afterwards.and he may of found his true name and told eragon to leave and never come back.(and galbys drgaon could of died also)

    wow that was alot of typing 🙂 hope you like my theory

  • MistGun1204

    @vannet- Then Saphira an Grennie Probably mated and he is talking to a new Dragon Rider.

  • MistGun1204

    @vannet- Then Saphira an Grennie Probably mated and he is talking to a new Dragon Rider.

  • dragoneater

    zasekr1, I don’t think Eragon has left AL, he is just away from wherever the new rider is, probably Farthen Dur but that’s just a guess.

  • vannet

    @MistGun1204-Greenie cannot be a girl dragon cause in Eldest, Murtagh says that the last dragon is male, making Saphira the last Girl dragon in existance.

  • dragoneater

    zasekr1, I don’t think Eragon has left AL, he is just away from wherever the new rider is, probably Farthen Dur but that’s just a guess.

  • vannet

    @MistGun1204-Greenie cannot be a girl dragon cause in Eldest, Murtagh says that the last dragon is male, making Saphira the last Girl dragon in existance.

  • MistGun1204

    On page 289 in Brisingr Jeod tells Eragon about a secretive sect that believes all knowledge is sacred and dedicates themselves to collecting every piece of information when they believe a catastrophe will destroy all the civilizations in Alagaesia.

    Maybe this is where Angela is from.

  • MistGun1204

    On page 289 in Brisingr Jeod tells Eragon about a secretive sect that believes all knowledge is sacred and dedicates themselves to collecting every piece of information when they believe a catastrophe will destroy all the civilizations in Alagaesia.Maybe this is where Angela is from.

  • MistGun1204

    In Eragon’s Guide To Alagaesia. The part when he talks about Dragon Riders, he talks about The Ever Lasting Bond and says, “The bond the formed between you and you dragon when SHE hatched is what makes you a Dragon Rider.

    So Greenie is a girl Dragon.

  • MistGun1204

    In Eragon’s Guide To Alagaesia. The part when he talks about Dragon Riders, he talks about The Ever Lasting Bond and says, “The bond the formed between you and you dragon when SHE hatched is what makes you a Dragon Rider.So Greenie is a girl Dragon.

  • zasekr1

    iloveeragon – i dont know of any online sites to read eragons guide to AL ur prob just gona have to buy it or be like me and read it in the book shop ^^

  • zasekr1

    iloveeragon – i dont know of any online sites to read eragons guide to AL ur prob just gona have to buy it or be like me and read it in the book shop ^^

  • iloveeragon

    oh and is there a way i can read eragons guide to AL with out buying it?

  • iloveeragon

    oh and is there a way i can read eragons guide to AL with out buying it?

  • iloveeragon

    ya can somebody also tell me where i can read the letters cuz im very confused and i want read them.

    CP needs to finish the book i want to read it sooo bad! 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    ya can somebody also tell me where i can read the letters cuz im very confused and i want read them.

    CP needs to finish the book i want to read it sooo bad! 🙂

  • Theremier

    could someone give me a link or tell me where to go to read eragons letters to the new rider

  • Theremier

    could someone give me a link or tell me where to go to read eragons letters to the new rider

  • zasekr1

    MSJ – according to eragon’s guide to AL in the letter he writes to the new rider he says that he has left glaedr’s HOH with the new rider for the riders protection etc, if we are to assume that eragons guide to AL is significant in its subtle plot hint/spoilers this must mean that eragon has left AL like he states and the new rider has emerged and glaedr’s HOH is with the new rider.

    this make me want the last book to come out so much more!

  • zasekr1

    MSJ – according to eragon’s guide to AL in the letter he writes to the new rider he says that he has left glaedr’s HOH with the new rider for the riders protection etc, if we are to assume that eragons guide to AL is significant in its subtle plot hint/spoilers this must mean that eragon has left AL like he states and the new rider has emerged and glaedr’s HOH is with the new rider.
    this make me want the last book to come out so much more!

  • MSJ

    Dragoneater- Why do you say “And this also means Eragon is w/out Glaedr’s HOH!”? What means Eragon does not have Glaedr’s HoH?

  • MSJ

    Dragoneater- Why do you say “And this also means Eragon is w/out Glaedr’s HOH!”? What means Eragon does not have Glaedr’s HoH?

  • dragoneater

    Let me say what these letters seem to tell me.
    1. The rider is unfamiliar with the Varden, since strangers swept him or her away from their family.
    2. Galby is now stocking the land on the look out.
    3. My guess is the new rider and dragon are in Farthen Dur
    4. Eragon has probably figured out some way to drastically increase his power because I can’t imagine him parting ways with Glaedr’s Eldunari otherwise.

  • dragoneater

    Let me say what these letters seem to tell me. 1. The rider is unfamiliar with the Varden, since strangers swept him or her away from their family.2. Galby is now stocking the land on the look out.3. My guess is the new rider and dragon are in Farthen Dur 4. Eragon has probably figured out some way to drastically increase his power because I can’t imagine him parting ways with Glaedr’s Eldunari otherwise.

  • dragoneater

    thanks yo.blagden. This only makes me more confused about who the next rider will be. And this also means Eragon is w/out Glaedr’s HOH! Jeez this is gonna get crazy

  • dragoneater

    thanks yo.blagden. This only makes me more confused about who the next rider will be. And this also means Eragon is w/out Glaedr’s HOH! Jeez this is gonna get crazy

  • yo.blagden

    sent it

  • yo.blagden

    sent it

  • dragoneater

    [email protected]

  • dragoneater

    [email protected]

  • yo.blagden

    just type ur address.I’ll send.

  • yo.blagden

    just type ur address.I’ll send.

  • dragoneater

    can i PM on this blog?

  • dragoneater

    can i PM on this blog?

  • yo.blagden

    dragoneater-Will u give me ur email id?I’ll send the letters

  • yo.blagden

    dragoneater-Will u give me ur email id?I’ll send the letters

  • yo.blagden

    Eragon created a red werelight in Helgrind..It does not mean his magic is red.Okay bigger magic like”brisingr”is blue but maybe its related to his personality.Remember what Rhunon said?
    same way Brom can create magic in any color.I think its also related to the nature of that magic

  • yo.blagden

    Eragon created a red werelight in Helgrind..It does not mean his magic is red.Okay bigger magic like”brisingr”is blue but maybe its related to his personality.Remember what Rhunon said?same way Brom can create magic in any color.I think its also related to the nature of that magic

  • dragoneater

    Forgive me i’ve not read the guide to AL, but is it possible that Eragon wrote the letter to the next rider before he knew who it was? or is it specific that he knows who he’s writing to?

  • dragoneater

    Forgive me i’ve not read the guide to AL, but is it possible that Eragon wrote the letter to the next rider before he knew who it was? or is it specific that he knows who he’s writing to?

  • yo.blagden

    HeXrider-any1 who knows about eldunari cant be the rider.Read my comment on May 9th 4:13 pm.

  • yo.blagden

    HeXrider-any1 who knows about eldunari cant be the rider.Read my comment on May 9th 4:13 pm.

  • Tulkas

    On the Dragon colors thing: When in Ellesmera in Brisingr, Eragon says that he could retrieve Brom’s sword because it would be blue like Saphira’s. We think that it could be red because when Brom dulled his sword for sparring there was a red spark between his fingers, and when he started a fire on the Burning Plains it glowed red, though of course he would have made it do that.

  • Tulkas

    On the Dragon colors thing: When in Ellesmera in Brisingr, Eragon says that he could retrieve Brom’s sword because it would be blue like Saphira’s. We think that it could be red because when Brom dulled his sword for sparring there was a red spark between his fingers, and when he started a fire on the Burning Plains it glowed red, though of course he would have made it do that.

  • HeXrider

    iloveeragon: Dragons can have many eggs, remember the story of saphira\’s egg. it said something like: when dragons mate they give one or two eggs to the riders, wich the riders imbue with their magic. so the egg will only hatch for its rider.

    So dragons can have many eggs per \”mate\”

    — The Elva as rider theory is probably a bust. why?
    1 like mentioned from the Guide, Elva doesn\’t have family.
    2 Elva is very unpredictable. She can feel the suffering of those around her but she can decide for her own now if she wants to help. That is not how a rider should be. A rider is a helper of the people. Elva was being very arrogant and selfish when she left the varden\’s camp. If Elva should become a rider it would only disappoint lots of fans, because it would mean Greeny has to be selfish and mean too.

    Arya is a helper for her people, she does whatever necessary to destroy her enemies. she fits the role of a rider perfectly, only greeny is missing. The green magic thing she has, has no meaning. Why? because a riders magic changes to the dragon\’s colour after the link.

  • HeXrider

    iloveeragon: Dragons can have many eggs, remember the story of saphira’s egg. it said something like: when dragons mate they give one or two eggs to the riders, wich the riders imbue with their magic. so the egg will only hatch for its rider.So dragons can have many eggs per “mate”– The Elva as rider theory is probably a bust. why?1 like mentioned from the Guide, Elva doesn’t have family. 2 Elva is very unpredictable. She can feel the suffering of those around her but she can decide for her own now if she wants to help. That is not how a rider should be. A rider is a helper of the people. Elva was being very arrogant and selfish when she left the varden’s camp. If Elva should become a rider it would only disappoint lots of fans, because it would mean Greeny has to be selfish and mean too.Arya is a helper for her people, she does whatever necessary to destroy her enemies. she fits the role of a rider perfectly, only greeny is missing. The green magic thing she has, has no meaning. Why? because a riders magic changes to the dragon’s colour after the link.

  • yo.blagden

    Dragonrider360-Cud u plz check & tell me the date on which u posted ur theory in the Q&Asol&prob.U have posted sooo many.I’d love to comment

  • yo.blagden

    Dragonrider360-Cud u plz check & tell me the date on which u posted ur theory in the Q&Asol&prob.U have posted sooo many.I’d love to comment

  • yo.blagden

    CP definitely said that readers could get a gist of where the story is heading in book4 by reading Eragons guide to AL.I dont think he would do it to confuse us.Whatever he has written is related to book4

    Mistgun18-In Eragons letter to the new rider he tells that the rider has been separated from his/her family.Elva doesnt have a family.

  • yo.blagden

    CP definitely said that readers could get a gist of where the story is heading in book4 by reading Eragons guide to AL.I dont think he would do it to confuse us.Whatever he has written is related to book4Mistgun18-In Eragons letter to the new rider he tells that the rider has been separated from his/her family.Elva doesnt have a family.

  • JCV2013

    As far as considering the Guide canonical or not, CP did state once in an interview about the book that if one looks closely enough, he or she can pretty much piece togethor the plot of the rest of the story from clues in the Guide.

    Therefore, I don’t think its just an interest piece… Unless, of course, he just said that to distract us…

  • JCV2013

    As far as considering the Guide canonical or not, CP did state once in an interview about the book that if one looks closely enough, he or she can pretty much piece togethor the plot of the rest of the story from clues in the Guide.

    Therefore, I don’t think its just an interest piece… Unless, of course, he just said that to distract us…

  • disdragonrider

    Were176cRider.
    lol. saphira was one of a few eggs. so a dragon can lay more than 1 egg. and only saphira was given

  • disdragonrider

    Were176cRider.lol. saphira was one of a few eggs. so a dragon can lay more than 1 egg. and only saphira was given

  • dragoneater

    That prospect actaully scares me more than any. She could prove to be a very nasty enemy indeed.

  • dragoneater

    That prospect actaully scares me more than any. She could prove to be a very nasty enemy indeed.

  • MistGun18

    What if the last dragon rider is Elva.

  • MistGun18

    What if the last dragon rider is Elva.

  • dragoneater

    Back to the “cheep cheep” double meaning. I think Angela is close to finding something significant out about the werecats. Afterall she was an apprentice of Tenga, who spends all his time gaining knowledge one answer at a time. This explains why Angela follows Solembum around for the time being and also why Halfpaw won’t allow her inside his head.
    What if Solembum is the next rider? Hasn’t he been in all 3 books, which is really our only criteria to follow.

  • dragoneater

    Back to the “cheep cheep” double meaning. I think Angela is close to finding something significant out about the werecats. Afterall she was an apprentice of Tenga, who spends all his time gaining knowledge one answer at a time. This explains why Angela follows Solembum around for the time being and also why Halfpaw won’t allow her inside his head. What if Solembum is the next rider? Hasn’t he been in all 3 books, which is really our only criteria to follow.

  • Were176cRider

    Reading all of these comments just makes me want to know when Book#4 will come out!

  • Were176cRider

    Reading all of these comments just makes me want to know when Book#4 will come out!

  • Dragonrider360

    I just got another theory:

    This is sort of hard to explain but I’ll try my best.

    Since Galbatorix enslaves his HOHs, could it mean that the HOHs he’s enslved not be working for him at there full power? Like, for example, if Eragon got Glaedr’s HOH to work for him, it could be worth two of Galby’s HOH? And if (this would probably never happen but we can’t just close the door on this possibility) Eragon aquired 50 HOHs, it would be worth a 100 of Galby’s HOHs? This would explain why Galby would have to get a lot of HOHs.

    PS:What happened to Saphira1’s HOH? And has there ever been a dragon who’s rider died and the dragon lived on?

  • Dragonrider360

    I just got another theory:
    This is sort of hard to explain but I’ll try my best.
    Since Galbatorix enslaves his HOHs, could it mean that the HOHs he’s enslved not be working for him at there full power? Like, for example, if Eragon got Glaedr’s HOH to work for him, it could be worth two of Galby’s HOH? And if (this would probably never happen but we can’t just close the door on this possibility) Eragon aquired 50 HOHs, it would be worth a 100 of Galby’s HOHs? This would explain why Galby would have to get a lot of HOHs.

    PS:What happened to Saphira1’s HOH? And has there ever been a dragon who’s rider died and the dragon lived on?

  • Were176cRider

    I agree with MaggiMe that we should only take Eragon’s Guide to Alagesia as cannon. After all, with not even a release date for the next book, why would CP already be revealing spoilers like that?

    p.s. Why are these books always reminding me of Lord of the Rings?

  • Were176cRider

    I agree with MaggiMe that we should only take Eragon’s Guide to Alagesia as cannon. After all, with not even a release date for the next book, why would CP already be revealing spoilers like that?

    p.s. Why are these books always reminding me of Lord of the Rings?

  • Dragonrider360

    Okay, still in the topic of colors, could Brom’s magic have changed colors after Saphira1 died? That explains why I’m so confused?

    PS: Has anybody looked at my theory on the Q&A: Solotions and Problems? I know it’s old and hasn’t been comented on in ages, but I’d really appreciate the feedback. Please?????

  • Dragonrider360

    Okay, still in the topic of colors, could Brom’s magic have changed colors after Saphira1 died? That explains why I’m so confused?

    PS: Has anybody looked at my theory on the Q&A: Solotions and Problems? I know it’s old and hasn’t been comented on in ages, but I’d really appreciate the feedback. Please?????

  • Were176cRider

    Well, actually, dragons having more than one egg is not a stupid question?

    Furthermore, there is no such thing as a stupid question on this site. Only theories, that others agree upon.

    Actually, we don’t if dragons can have only one egg or more, so can’t for book #4.

  • Were176cRider

    Well, actually, dragons having more than one egg is not a stupid question?

    Furthermore, there is no such thing as a stupid question on this site. Only theories, that others agree upon.

    Actually, we don’t if dragons can have only one egg or more, so can’t for book #4.

  • iloveeragon

    i have a question and it is probably stupid but im gonna ask it anyway. can dragons have nore than one egg?

    cuz if they can. then if thorn dies and saphira and greenie mate then they can have more than one egg and bring the dragons back.

  • iloveeragon

    i have a question and it is probably stupid but im gonna ask it anyway. can dragons have nore than one egg?
    cuz if they can. then if thorn dies and saphira and greenie mate then they can have more than one egg and bring the dragons back.

  • mollik

    It could be possible arya is the next rider, eragon and arya fight galby and in the battle arya and her dragon dies,eragon finishes the battle with galby and assuming that murtagh and thorn has already retired from the world from a prior confrontation,eragon is the only rider with no way to repopulate the dragons , so he leaves alagaesia so that humans could live in peace…..IRONICALLY ERAGON BECOMES THE FIRST AND THE LAST DRAGON RIDER TO WALK THE LAND OF THE HUMANS….
    As far as angela is concerned, she could be a dragon rider with a dead dragon…fights the empire and keeps her identity intact. She could know abt the vault of souls…could be an enemy of the werecats with solebum(spellings r possibly wrong) being the exception (traitor)….she could be in some way related to galby and IS definately the key to the last battle or one of the most imp. Keys….roran becomes the king of alagaesia (since nasuada dies in the last battle)
    Another possibility is that werecats know abt the vault of souls and all…eragon offers a truce…they help him,he helps them, a win win situation. My thoughts on possible story progress…

  • mollik

    It could be possible arya is the next rider, eragon and arya fight galby and in the battle arya and her dragon dies,eragon finishes the battle with galby and assuming that murtagh and thorn has already retired from the world from a prior confrontation,eragon is the only rider with no way to repopulate the dragons , so he leaves alagaesia so that humans could live in peace…..IRONICALLY ERAGON BECOMES THE FIRST AND THE LAST DRAGON RIDER TO WALK THE LAND OF THE HUMANS….As far as angela is concerned, she could be a dragon rider with a dead dragon…fights the empire and keeps her identity intact. She could know abt the vault of souls…could be an enemy of the werecats with solebum(spellings r possibly wrong) being the exception (traitor)….she could be in some way related to galby and IS definately the key to the last battle or one of the most imp. Keys….roran becomes the king of alagaesia (since nasuada dies in the last battle)Another possibility is that werecats know abt the vault of souls and all…eragon offers a truce…they help him,he helps them, a win win situation. My thoughts on possible story progress…

  • Dragonrider360

    Sorry. In the sentence “But where, then, did it say that Brom’s magic was brown?”, I meant red instead of brown. Sorry if that confused yall.
    yo.blagden: How’d you know what kind of blue Bram’s dragon was?
    I’m sorry if I’m obsessing of colors, but for some reason they seem really signifigant to me. So, if anybody knows or can guess, what colors were Saphira2’s parents?

  • Dragonrider360

    Sorry. In the sentence “But where, then, did it say that Brom’s magic was brown?”, I meant red instead of brown. Sorry if that confused yall. yo.blagden: How’d you know what kind of blue Bram’s dragon was?I’m sorry if I’m obsessing of colors, but for some reason they seem really signifigant to me. So, if anybody knows or can guess, what colors were Saphira2’s parents?

  • theories

    Okay, two theories. What if Katrina and Roran’s child is going to be the new Rider?

    Next, what if the green dragon has already hatched? In Eldest, when Eragon helps Saphira after her and Glaedr had a fight in the old nesting place, Eragon noticed green egg fragments. It may have already hatched for someone.

  • theories

    Okay, two theories. What if Katrina and Roran’s child is going to be the new Rider?

    Next, what if the green dragon has already hatched? In Eldest, when Eragon helps Saphira after her and Glaedr had a fight in the old nesting place, Eragon noticed green egg fragments. It may have already hatched for someone.

  • MaggiMc

    I don’t know how much we should rely on Eragon’s Guide to AL as canon. It is more of a point of interest and does not further the story in any way. I would think CP would be meticulously careful about spoilers while writing the guide so we shouldn’t treat it the same way we do the other books.

  • MaggiMc

    I don’t know how much we should rely on Eragon’s Guide to AL as canon. It is more of a point of interest and does not further the story in any way. I would think CP would be meticulously careful about spoilers while writing the guide so we shouldn’t treat it the same way we do the other books.

  • yo.blagden

    If Saphira mates with Greeni ,they have an egg, it hatches–then who will be its mate??& continue the geneology?? So Thorn cannot die.

    Story2-Saphira=Thorn,Greeni=Saphira,Thorn’s kid

  • yo.blagden

    If Saphira mates with Greeni ,they have an egg, it hatches–then who will be its mate??& continue the geneology?? So Thorn cannot die.Story2-Saphira=Thorn,Greeni=Saphira,Thorn’s kid

  • iloveeragon

    yo.blagden-it could be likei saaid before. murtagh and thorn die and greenie hatches. assuming its a male and arya is its rider. saphira and greenie mate and have an egg. they leave on a quest(outside of alagesia). then the egg hatches for someone and that is who eragon is writing to.

  • iloveeragon

    yo.blagden-it could be likei saaid before. murtagh and thorn die and greenie hatches. assuming its a male and arya is its rider. saphira and greenie mate and have an egg. they leave on a quest(outside of alagesia). then the egg hatches for someone and that is who eragon is writing to.

  • zasekr1

    yo.blagden – i also thought that when i read eragons guide to AL it must mean that the new dragon rider isnt arya or roran but a character that has been in all three books and is far away from either uru’baen or that they arewhere-ever the egg is taken to, it hatches for them and they are swept away with eragon.

    on the subject of the sex of the last egg, in eldest we are told that the dragon is male. eragon may have said ‘ its not every day that a dragon chooses you to be HER rider’ because his own dragon is female.

  • zasekr1

    yo.blagden – i also thought that when i read eragons guide to AL it must mean that the new dragon rider isnt arya or roran but a character that has been in all three books and is far away from either uru’baen or that they arewhere-ever the egg is taken to, it hatches for them and they are swept away with eragon.
    on the subject of the sex of the last egg, in eldest we are told that the dragon is male. eragon may have said ‘ its not every day that a dragon chooses you to be HER rider’ because his own dragon is female.

  • yo.blagden

    In Eragons guide to Alagaesia it is said that the new rider was Flown out of Alagaesia.Eragon himself has not met the rider coz he said that ”Wish saphira & i were there to welcome u”.So another rider must have flown the new rider.It could be Murtagh who flew him.ITS COMPLICATED!!!!

  • yo.blagden

    In Eragons guide to Alagaesia it is said that the new rider was Flown out of Alagaesia.Eragon himself has not met the rider coz he said that ”Wish saphira & i were there to welcome u”.
    So another rider must have flown the new rider.It could be Murtagh who flew him.ITS COMPLICATED!!!!

  • yo.blagden

    EVERYONE-PLZ READ MY COMMENT ON 9th MAY 4:13PM

  • yo.blagden

    EVERYONE-PLZ READ MY COMMENT ON 9th MAY 4:13PM

  • SolKinto

    Sorry. Forgot to point out one last overlooked question. What were the words Brom taught Eragon in his dying breath, and what signifigance do they hold?

  • SolKinto

    Sorry. Forgot to point out one last overlooked question. What were the words Brom taught Eragon in his dying breath, and what signifigance do they hold?

  • yo.blagden

    Dragonrider360-The colour of Saphira1 was a different shade of blue than Saphira2.It was of aquamarine hue

  • yo.blagden

    Dragonrider360-The colour of Saphira1 was a different shade of blue than Saphira2.It was of aquamarine hue

  • SolKinto

    What if Angela is in some way related to Eragon and Murtagh. We know that she is based off of Christopher’s real life sister. Let us assume that the protagonist is based on the writer, as is often the case in most books, and that there is a possibility that she is related. She may be Eragons mother, though I doubt this. None the less, Paolini has something up his sleeve. Let us ask why does he so pointedly avoid revealing her age? What could this fact reveal about her charachter that would need to be revealed later in the story? Lets focus on what was not revealed and ask why, instead of trying to rely on information that was given to us and meant to lead us away from guessing at plot spoiler. Also, don’t assume Arya is going to be Eragon’s love. Nasuada is a valid candidate. Finally, what is Paolini’s intent when he makes Eragon leave Alagesia? We know Eragon is oppposed to holding power. Perhaps he wants to avoid being followed and worshipped be the people of Alagesia while he is the only rider alive, and intends to go elsewhere to allow the dragons to repopulate. Or perhaps he fears the rise of another powerful rider in the future. Who is the final rider? Roran is a popular guess, but I doubt it. Arya? More likely. If it is her, than I assume she will become Eragon’s lover and they will leave Alagesia together. I think that is the only way Arya would be Eragon’s lover and survive the fourth book. She is a very ready character for death, built up to the point by Eragon’s love, and his destiny. Lol. It’d be funny if Sloan became a rider.

  • SolKinto

    What if Angela is in some way related to Eragon and Murtagh. We know that she is based off of Christopher’s real life sister. Let us assume that the protagonist is based on the writer, as is often the case in most books, and that there is a possibility that she is related. She may be Eragons mother, though I doubt this. None the less, Paolini has something up his sleeve. Let us ask why does he so pointedly avoid revealing her age? What could this fact reveal about her charachter that would need to be revealed later in the story? Lets focus on what was not revealed and ask why, instead of trying to rely on information that was given to us and meant to lead us away from guessing at plot spoiler. Also, don’t assume Arya is going to be Eragon’s love. Nasuada is a valid candidate. Finally, what is Paolini’s intent when he makes Eragon leave Alagesia? We know Eragon is oppposed to holding power. Perhaps he wants to avoid being followed and worshipped be the people of Alagesia while he is the only rider alive, and intends to go elsewhere to allow the dragons to repopulate. Or perhaps he fears the rise of another powerful rider in the future. Who is the final rider? Roran is a popular guess, but I doubt it. Arya? More likely. If it is her, than I assume she will become Eragon’s lover and they will leave Alagesia together. I think that is the only way Arya would be Eragon’s lover and survive the fourth book. She is a very ready character for death, built up to the point by Eragon’s love, and his destiny. Lol. It’d be funny if Sloan became a rider.

  • Chris

    If brom’s magic is any color, it’d be blue like his dragon.

  • Chris

    If brom’s magic is any color, it’d be blue like his dragon.

  • HeXrider

    sorry last line was meant for CP, but some marks got deleted i’m a big fan i want more then four books! 😀

  • HeXrider

    sorry last line was meant for CP, but some marks got deleted i’m a big fan i want more then four books! 😀

  • HeXrider

    If murtagh and galby die, and greenie mates with saphira, they would have to have more then one egg. because else you got the same problem, no male or female dragon.

    I agree the menoa tree dislikes dragons. so maybe she looked inside eragon’s soul, and saw his real name. that way she can force eragon to leave alageisia forever. by commanding him with his true name and the AL. sounds more plausible at that 😀

    So how ends book 4? Eragon and Saphira leave alageisia with arya and greeny. they leave for the homeland of the humans, ad roran is the crying king af alageisia standing on the shore.

    but if you read the Dune books, you also know that besides the main story lot’s of other books exsist. so maybe CP will start writing about eragon’s adventures in the new land. He can also write about the grey folks, about the beginning of the AL, about the beginning of the riders about ALL things around magic ETC ETC ETC i really don’t want you to stop writing these great books! make as many books as brain and frank herbert & gang!!

  • HeXrider

    If murtagh and galby die, and greenie mates with saphira, they would have to have more then one egg. because else you got the same problem, no male or female dragon. I agree the menoa tree dislikes dragons. so maybe she looked inside eragon’s soul, and saw his real name. that way she can force eragon to leave alageisia forever. by commanding him with his true name and the AL. sounds more plausible at that 😀 So how ends book 4? Eragon and Saphira leave alageisia with arya and greeny. they leave for the homeland of the humans, ad roran is the crying king af alageisia standing on the shore.but if you read the Dune books, you also know that besides the main story lot’s of other books exsist. so maybe CP will start writing about eragon’s adventures in the new land. He can also write about the grey folks, about the beginning of the AL, about the beginning of the riders about ALL things around magic ETC ETC ETC i really don’t want you to stop writing these great books! make as many books as brain and frank herbert & gang!!

  • yo.blagden

    In Eragons guide to Alagaesia,Eragon writes to the new rider-“Its not everyday a dragon chooses you to be HER rider”.This means the dragon must be a female.

    If that is so Thorn & Saphira will have to bond.

    2-Eragon also says that its not everyday strangers sweep u from ur family & FLY you across the WHOLE OF ALAGAESIA & BEYOND.In the letter at the end he writes that-”I would not tell a new rider like u about the Eldunari especially as ur dragon is too young to understand this”
    That means the rider could not be Arya/Roran or anyone who knows about Eldunari.

  • yo.blagden

    In Eragons guide to Alagaesia,Eragon writes to the new rider-“Its not everyday a dragon chooses you to be HER rider”.This means the dragon must be a female.If that is so Thorn & Saphira will have to bond.2-Eragon also says that its not everyday strangers sweep u from ur family & FLY you across the WHOLE OF ALAGAESIA & BEYOND.In the letter at the end he writes that-”I would not tell a new rider like u about the Eldunari especially as ur dragon is too young to understand this”That means the rider could not be Arya/Roran or anyone who knows about Eldunari.

  • Dragonrider360

    Huh, that’s confusing. I don’t think CP said Brom’s magic was brown, my friend did, and I think he’s crazy because I’ve read Eragon 5 times and not once did it say Brom’s magic was brown. But where, then, did it say Brom’s magic was brown? And also, I think I read and heard that Glader has mated. Who with? Did it result in an egg? Could Glader’s mate be Brom’s dragon?

    Gosh my head hurts…… 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    Huh, that’s confusing. I don’t think CP said Brom’s magic was brown, my friend did, and I think he’s crazy because I’ve read Eragon 5 times and not once did it say Brom’s magic was brown. But where, then, did it say Brom’s magic was brown? And also, I think I read and heard that Glader has mated. Who with? Did it result in an egg? Could Glader’s mate be Brom’s dragon?Gosh my head hurts…… 🙂

  • yo.blagden

    U know ‘Dominance of fate’ predicted that some terrible event will destroy the whole of Alagaesia.Maybe thats why Eragon will have to leave Alagaesia.

    or maybe the Menoa tree will order Eragon to leave Alagaesia forever.Remember she said-Fire must be extinguished’She wont want dragons in Ellesmera

  • yo.blagden

    U know ‘Dominance of fate’ predicted that some terrible event will destroy the whole of Alagaesia.Maybe thats why Eragon will have to leave Alagaesia.or maybe the Menoa tree will order Eragon to leave Alagaesia forever.Remember she said-Fire must be extinguished’She wont want dragons in Ellesmera

  • Deidara

    This is a posible and perfect [and perhaps weird] plot twist.

    Brom and Galbatorix are brothers, Selena and garrow are Galbitorixs children, and Galb. is Eragon and Murtaghs grandfather and eragons uncle.

  • Deidara

    This is a posible and perfect [and perhaps weird] plot twist.
    Brom and Galbatorix are brothers, Selena and garrow are Galbitorixs children, and Galb. is Eragon and Murtaghs grandfather and eragons uncle.

  • zasekr1

    dragonrider360 – i dont think we are ever told what colour saphira1 was, because of her name i presumed she was blue but broms magic was red, so she could have been red. i dont know where the brown colouring came from maybe cp said somewhere in an interview

  • zasekr1

    dragonrider360 – i dont think we are ever told what colour saphira1 was, because of her name i presumed she was blue but broms magic was red, so she could have been red. i dont know where the brown colouring came from maybe cp said somewhere in an interview

  • Dragonrider360

    Okay let me get something straight. Brom’s Saphira is blue, right? Some one in the comments said she was red and my friend said she was brown, because apparently that’s what the colors of Brom’s magic. I think she’s blue, but now I’m confused.

  • Dragonrider360

    Okay let me get something straight. Brom’s Saphira is blue, right? Some one in the comments said she was red and my friend said she was brown, because apparently that’s what the colors of Brom’s magic. I think she’s blue, but now I’m confused.

  • zasekr1

    eragon wont die because angela predicted that he would have a long life or live forever!

    though i do think that he will leave AL for some quest or another and thats why he left the letter for the new rider.

    but on the subject of the letter in eragons Guide to AL he states that the rider and its dragon are still very young and not ready for battle!? so this makes me think that they wont appear in the fourth book till the end, the egg at least could be captured half way through though. any thought???

  • zasekr1

    eragon wont die because angela predicted that he would have a long life or live forever!
    though i do think that he will leave AL for some quest or another and thats why he left the letter for the new rider.
    but on the subject of the letter in eragons Guide to AL he states that the rider and its dragon are still very young and not ready for battle!? so this makes me think that they wont appear in the fourth book till the end, the egg at least could be captured half way through though. any thought???

  • iloveeragon

    and thats who hes writing the letter to. the new rider

  • iloveeragon

    and thats who hes writing the letter to. the new rider

  • xhuggybearx

    if greenie is a female then it can reprodce with thorn, being that in this theory thorn and murtaugh are good

  • xhuggybearx

    if greenie is a female then it can reprodce with thorn, being that in this theory thorn and murtaugh are good

  • iloveeragon

    ok i was thinking. what if murtagh and thorn die and greenie hatches. say arya is the next rider. greenie and saphira mate and have an egg. then eragon and arya leave on a quest and thats why eragon was writing the letter in eragons guide to algesia. because then the egg would hatch and will start a new generatoion of dragons.

  • iloveeragon

    ok i was thinking. what if murtagh and thorn die and greenie hatches. say arya is the next rider. greenie and saphira mate and have an egg. then eragon and arya leave on a quest and thats why eragon was writing the letter in eragons guide to algesia. because then the egg would hatch and will start a new generatoion of dragons.

  • HeXrider

    1 problem at that: saphira is the last frmale dragon… She would go crazy if not dead too f eragon died.. What then is the benefit of greeny to hatch ?

  • HeXrider

    1 problem at that: saphira is the last frmale dragon… She would go crazy if not dead too f eragon died.. What then is the benefit of greeny to hatch ?

  • xhuggybearx

    if eragon does end up dying then greenies rider will train the new riders (assuming that they arent under galbys control)

    another thought that just came to me what if eragon and arya hook up and she ends up pregnant and then eragon dies in battle while defeating galby, then he does an epilogue and in it arya is queen of the elves and her and eragons son touches the egg and greenie is born

    the reason i think this is that unless greenie was born sometime in brisinger then he really wouldnt have any significance to the final battles and so it could make sense that maybe murtaugh becomes good and between him and arya the new rider is trained

  • xhuggybearx

    if eragon does end up dying then greenies rider will train the new riders (assuming that they arent under galbys control) another thought that just came to me what if eragon and arya hook up and she ends up pregnant and then eragon dies in battle while defeating galby, then he does an epilogue and in it arya is queen of the elves and her and eragons son touches the egg and greenie is bornthe reason i think this is that unless greenie was born sometime in brisinger then he really wouldnt have any significance to the final battles and so it could make sense that maybe murtaugh becomes good and between him and arya the new rider is trained

  • iloveeragon

    because it said he would leave algesia and never come back and what if thats the reason

  • iloveeragon

    because it said he would leave algesia and never come back and what if thats the reason

  • iloveeragon

    omg! i just thought of the worst possible thing ever. k i was reading the q&a’s and it said he would leave algesia forever. then in eragons guide to algesia it talks about him teaching the new dragon rider when he gets back.

    but what if he doesnt come back. as if like he died. that would be soooo horrible! 🙁

    i hope that doesnt happen but i thought it as i read the Q&A’s.

  • iloveeragon

    omg! i just thought of the worst possible thing ever. k i was reading the q&a’s and it said he would leave algesia forever. then in eragons guide to algesia it talks about him teaching the new dragon rider when he gets back.

    but what if he doesnt come back. as if like he died. that would be soooo horrible! 🙁

    i hope that doesnt happen but i thought it as i read the Q&A’s.

  • Tulkas

    MSJ- Why can you not post? Anyway, I shall post that.

  • Tulkas

    MSJ- Why can you not post? Anyway, I shall post that.

  • HeXrider

    Very interesting…. i think we all agree angela knows SOMETHING the werecats don’t want her to know. as the king cat very much insisted it wasn’t going to be angela doing the search in their brains.

    What if she came to know WHAT wherecats REALLy are? HOW they can have 2 appearances and how the can know everything.

    Angela tells fortune to those Solembum talks to. So maybe fortune telling has also something to do with werecats.

    By the way, everyone is saying:”how solembum follows angela” it’s the other way around, when eragon meets angela in the halls of farthen dur, angela sais something like: Solembum was leaving, and i wanted to see what was going to happen. interesting things seem to happen around werecats

    So maybe werecats KNOW the future, but they want to see for themselves.

    just to get a discussion going: what do you guys think werecats are? wich abilities they have, what they know/do/think etc

  • HeXrider

    Very interesting…. i think we all agree angela knows SOMETHING the werecats don’t want her to know. as the king cat very much insisted it wasn’t going to be angela doing the search in their brains. What if she came to know WHAT wherecats REALLy are? HOW they can have 2 appearances and how the can know everything. Angela tells fortune to those Solembum talks to. So maybe fortune telling has also something to do with werecats. By the way, everyone is saying:”how solembum follows angela” it’s the other way around, when eragon meets angela in the halls of farthen dur, angela sais something like: Solembum was leaving, and i wanted to see what was going to happen. interesting things seem to happen around werecatsSo maybe werecats KNOW the future, but they want to see for themselves. just to get a discussion going: what do you guys think werecats are? wich abilities they have, what they know/do/think etc

  • Roranson

    haha, i have abit of an absurd comment/ thought. CP says that “the origins of werecats will be explored in book 4” or somthing to that effect. well the word origins intrigues me. perhaps the grey folk by some mystical means become werecats. so this might mean the greyfolk/werecats are very familiar with the ancient language since it is infact their language and them who bound magic to the language. so this would explain why they have such magical abilities? and perhaps angela learnt of this relationship through solebum which explains that long life (she has advanced control over the language). and once the werecats discovered that solebum told her the name of the ancient language and what werecats actually are they, they turned on him.

    I am fully aware that there are so many holes to this theory that it throws the sentiment into ridecule, but i’d thought i’d throw that out there, and maybe someone can ceal the holes, and makes sense of it 😛

  • Roranson

    haha, i have abit of an absurd comment/ thought. CP says that “the origins of werecats will be explored in book 4” or somthing to that effect. well the word origins intrigues me. perhaps the grey folk by some mystical means become werecats. so this might mean the greyfolk/werecats are very familiar with the ancient language since it is infact their language and them who bound magic to the language. so this would explain why they have such magical abilities? and perhaps angela learnt of this relationship through solebum which explains that long life (she has advanced control over the language). and once the werecats discovered that solebum told her the name of the ancient language and what werecats actually are they, they turned on him.
    I am fully aware that there are so many holes to this theory that it throws the sentiment into ridecule, but i’d thought i’d throw that out there, and maybe someone can ceal the holes, and makes sense of it 😛

  • MSJ

    I wonder if somehow Angela tricked the werecqts into giving up Solembum. Does anyone else think she may have done this the same way she tricked dwarves (I think) into obtaining that weapon she uses in battle? I personally don’t see Angela as a bad guy just cause of the werecats’ reaction. I just think that there is personal dispute between them and it’s not exactly crucial to victory/defeat for the varden and etc.

  • MSJ

    I wonder if somehow Angela tricked the werecqts into giving up Solembum. Does anyone else think she may have done this the same way she tricked dwarves (I think) into obtaining that weapon she uses in battle? I personally don’t see Angela as a bad guy just cause of the werecats’ reaction. I just think that there is personal dispute between them and it’s not exactly crucial to victory/defeat for the varden and etc.

  • MSJ

    Tulkas- you can ask it as I usually am not available to partake in those interviews.

    I have another possible theory/speculation that refers to the VoS. I think there is a chance it could be MARNA if not UTGARD. Why, you ask. Well if you look at the map of Alagaesia, there are three locations I’d like you to focus on: UTGARD, HELGRIND, MARNA. They are all a mountain of sorts and all have completely capitalized names. Why is that? We have already been told of two of these (if even just very brieflyin regards to Utgard). But so far, in all 3 books, I’ve not seen ANY mention of Marna AT ALL. So my question is:

    Could Marna be the RoK/VoS?

  • MSJ

    Tulkas- you can ask it as I usually am not available to partake in those interviews.I have another possible theory/speculation that refers to the VoS. I think there is a chance it could be MARNA if not UTGARD. Why, you ask. Well if you look at the map of Alagaesia, there are three locations I’d like you to focus on: UTGARD, HELGRIND, MARNA. They are all a mountain of sorts and all have completely capitalized names. Why is that? We have already been told of two of these (if even just very brieflyin regards to Utgard). But so far, in all 3 books, I’ve not seen ANY mention of Marna AT ALL. So my question is: Could Marna be the RoK/VoS?

  • Abr.du.fells

    -xBaboo
    -iloveeragon
    -Claytagh

    “Cheap Cheap” absolutely sounds like there is more to it than we know at this point. Especially considering Eragon and even Saphira’s surprised and even “taken back” response when she said that. She most definitely knows something that we do not. But as to what? I couldn’t begin to speculate. I think in this case it is something that CP has not let us know about yet. I don’t think we will be able to guess, CP has to add some new unseen dimensions to this book, or else frankly it is going to suck. I think this, what appears to be a feud, between Angela and most werecats will be something new to installment 4.
    (Not at all trying to bash anyone’s theories they are as good if not better than my own, simply an opinion)

  • Abr.du.fells

    -xBaboo-iloveeragon-Claytagh”Cheap Cheap” absolutely sounds like there is more to it than we know at this point. Especially considering Eragon and even Saphira’s surprised and even “taken back” response when she said that. She most definitely knows something that we do not. But as to what? I couldn’t begin to speculate. I think in this case it is something that CP has not let us know about yet. I don’t think we will be able to guess, CP has to add some new unseen dimensions to this book, or else frankly it is going to suck. I think this, what appears to be a feud, between Angela and most werecats will be something new to installment 4.(Not at all trying to bash anyone’s theories they are as good if not better than my own, simply an opinion)

  • Tulkas

    yo.blagden- I think that CP spoke of the chapter named brains in one of his last newsletters…

  • Tulkas

    yo.blagden- I think that CP spoke of the chapter named brains in one of his last newsletters…

  • yo.blagden

    1-In WIKIA its said that in book4 theres a chapter named ‘Brains’

    3-The origin of werecats will be thoroughly explored

  • yo.blagden

    1-In WIKIA its said that in book4 theres a chapter named ‘Brains’3-The origin of werecats will be thoroughly explored

  • yo.blagden

    Brent-U could go on google search for king cat. In WIKIA result-click the link U’ll get the whole chapter or go to http://www.amazon.com-books- brisingr-look inside-in search type’halfpaw’

    Claytagh-welcome.I think what u say is possible & knowing Angela even more so.

    People-If given a choice what would u name book4 ???

  • yo.blagden

    Brent-U could go on google search for king cat. In WIKIA result-click the link U’ll get the whole chapter or go to http://www.amazon.com-books- brisingr-look inside-in search type’halfpaw’Claytagh-welcome.I think what u say is possible & knowing Angela even more so.People-If given a choice what would u name book4 ???

  • eragonrocks

    I know my comment is a little late but Hexrider and huggybear the quest idea is a pretty good idea to go with why somebody is leaving and why someone is on the beach crying.

  • eragonrocks

    I know my comment is a little late but Hexrider and huggybear the quest idea is a pretty good idea to go with why somebody is leaving and why someone is on the beach crying.

  • xhuggybearx

    -iloveeragon

    i think that it would make a little more sense that angela new one of their secrets since they are afraid of her

    this could explain solumbum(sp) because if he accidentally told the secret then maybe he was sentenced to follow angela around and make sure that she keeps this secret to herself from like the werecat king

    i dunno this could explain the solumbum angela relationship because cp never said how they met (i dont think)

  • xhuggybearx

    -iloveeragoni think that it would make a little more sense that angela new one of their secrets since they are afraid of herthis could explain solumbum(sp) because if he accidentally told the secret then maybe he was sentenced to follow angela around and make sure that she keeps this secret to herself from like the werecat kingi dunno this could explain the solumbum angela relationship because cp never said how they met (i dont think)

  • iloveeragon

    xbaboo

    i think that since cheep cheep means that. it adds a whole new possibility. like what if the werecats found out something about angela she didnt want anyone to know about. or she knows something about thtem.

    thats what i think though but you may have differnet idea. feel free to add or change what you think about it. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    xbaboo

    i think that since cheep cheep means that. it adds a whole new possibility. like what if the werecats found out something about angela she didnt want anyone to know about. or she knows something about thtem.

    thats what i think though but you may have differnet idea. feel free to add or change what you think about it. 🙂

  • brent

    hello, i’ve got the hardcover edition of brisingr. i’ve been looking diligently, but i’m unable to find the excerpt. is there any way to read it without buying a book i already own?

  • brent

    hello, i’ve got the hardcover edition of brisingr. i’ve been looking diligently, but i’m unable to find the excerpt. is there any way to read it without buying a book i already own?

  • Tulkas

    Welcome, Claytagh.
    MSJ- Ask that for the next interview. If you don’t I will. That is extremely interesting. But Brom could make it red if he wanted too…

  • Tulkas

    Welcome, Claytagh.MSJ- Ask that for the next interview. If you don’t I will. That is extremely interesting. But Brom could make it red if he wanted too…

  • xBaboo

    Welcome Claytagh. Thanks for taking the time to read through all of the posts, it usually leads to better ideas being posted, and a better progression of thought in general.

    I agree that “cheep cheep” was a bit of an odd thing to say. I just assumed that she was sort of poking fun at them, comparing them to normal cats with a bird noise. But is there more than that, why is she portraying a bird?

    I looked up “cheep” on dictionary.com to see if there was any other meanings of the word. It mentioned one meaning (other than a chirp or peep) that was a little interesting – “to reveal or tell a secret” and is supposedly used mainly in the south-midland U.S.

    It’s probably just a coincidence, but interesting none the less.

  • xBaboo

    Welcome Claytagh. Thanks for taking the time to read through all of the posts, it usually leads to better ideas being posted, and a better progression of thought in general.I agree that “cheep cheep” was a bit of an odd thing to say. I just assumed that she was sort of poking fun at them, comparing them to normal cats with a bird noise. But is there more than that, why is she portraying a bird?I looked up “cheep” on dictionary.com to see if there was any other meanings of the word. It mentioned one meaning (other than a chirp or peep) that was a little interesting – “to reveal or tell a secret” and is supposedly used mainly in the south-midland U.S.It’s probably just a coincidence, but interesting none the less.

  • MaggiMc

    I think in the chapter where Eragon makes Brisingr, Rhunon says Broms dragon was the same color as Saphira. Maybe this is a mis memory… I don’t have my book at hand at the moment.

  • MaggiMc

    I think in the chapter where Eragon makes Brisingr, Rhunon says Broms dragon was the same color as Saphira. Maybe this is a mis memory… I don’t have my book at hand at the moment.

  • Claytagh

    Hey everyone..

    This is my first post, as I have finally just finished reading the 21 pages of comments to get up to speed with what everyone else is thinking could come in the next book before I post something completely off topic of my own haha..

    I do like the initiative everyone has been showing and I like a few of the theories, like Roran becoming king and him being the man on the shore screaming as Eragon leaves forever..

    But I also think a few things are a little out there even if it would be great to see them happen haha..

    I personally think there is something interesting to do with the “cheep cheep” from Angela in the new chapter.. Although I do think she is only a human.. But that subtle cheep cheep for me hints to something that maybe the werecats are afraid of or something along those lines..

    I dunno, I have a lot of theories about what could happen and lots of things I want to happen. But mostly I just want the book to come out haha.

    I really look forward to more discussion 🙂

  • Claytagh

    Hey everyone.. This is my first post, as I have finally just finished reading the 21 pages of comments to get up to speed with what everyone else is thinking could come in the next book before I post something completely off topic of my own haha.. I do like the initiative everyone has been showing and I like a few of the theories, like Roran becoming king and him being the man on the shore screaming as Eragon leaves forever.. But I also think a few things are a little out there even if it would be great to see them happen haha.. I personally think there is something interesting to do with the “cheep cheep” from Angela in the new chapter.. Although I do think she is only a human.. But that subtle cheep cheep for me hints to something that maybe the werecats are afraid of or something along those lines.. I dunno, I have a lot of theories about what could happen and lots of things I want to happen. But mostly I just want the book to come out haha. I really look forward to more discussion 🙂

  • zasekr1

    MSJ- that is interesting. i always autmatically assumed that since broms dragon was called saphira she would be blue but the fact that his magic was red could mean that she was red. it probably doesnt mean anything plot wise but it is very interesting

  • zasekr1

    MSJ- that is interesting. i always autmatically assumed that since broms dragon was called saphira she would be blue but the fact that his magic was red could mean that she was red. it probably doesnt mean anything plot wise but it is very interesting

  • MSJ

    I know this is off topic and I apologize. I just want to see what some of you may think. I was rereading Eragon and noticed on page 159 that it when the time comes and Brom says that \”it\’s time for the blade\”, or something like that. Well when he shows Eragon how to put that protective ward on it, it says the spark between his fingers was red.

    Anyone find that interesting?

    Also, I like the idea that a green dragon currently exists in addition to the green egg.

  • MSJ

    I know this is off topic and I apologize. I just want to see what some of you may think. I was rereading Eragon and noticed on page 159 that it when the time comes and Brom says that “it’s time for the blade”, or something like that. Well when he shows Eragon how to put that protective ward on it, it says the spark between his fingers was red.Anyone find that interesting?Also, I like the idea that a green dragon currently exists in addition to the green egg.

  • iloveeragon

    dragoneater

    i really like your theory. i was hoping greenie would come and help fight in the final battle and that would be perfect because than the varden have a chance and greenie is big enough to fight. so while greenies fighting murtagh eragon is fighting galby?maybe

  • iloveeragon

    dragoneater

    i really like your theory. i was hoping greenie would come and help fight in the final battle and that would be perfect because than the varden have a chance and greenie is big enough to fight. so while greenies fighting murtagh eragon is fighting galby?maybe

  • dragoneater

    How bout this idea for making the green dragon relevant in battle for book 4. Arya is the dragon’s rider. Arya already is a powerful magic user and has vast experience with it, moreso than previous riders since most riders are chosen at a young age. This would likely have some effect on how quickly her dragon develops and grows, allowing the pair of them to be ready for the final battle. Throw in some other combinations of wild dragons or original Eragon’s dragon’s HOH’s (or whatever else lives in the Vault ‘o souls) and that’s how greenie gets involved in the action.

  • dragoneater

    How bout this idea for making the green dragon relevant in battle for book 4. Arya is the dragon’s rider. Arya already is a powerful magic user and has vast experience with it, moreso than previous riders since most riders are chosen at a young age. This would likely have some effect on how quickly her dragon develops and grows, allowing the pair of them to be ready for the final battle. Throw in some other combinations of wild dragons or original Eragon’s dragon’s HOH’s (or whatever else lives in the Vault ‘o souls) and that’s how greenie gets involved in the action.

  • HeXrider

    Huggybear,i also thought that 😀 it would seem more happy that way, maybe it’s just some mission to vroengard maybe to find the VoS or whatever,

    It could be a significant quest (attaining information, or whatever) but not a definitive leave from alagaesia. It is true however that angela tols eragon his faith was to leave forever. Maybe we must not link those two things together. maybe it’s galby leaving and murthagh maybe eragon is going to find the real homeland of the humans (where the ra’zac came from too)

    Who knows maybe eragons leaving is something very different

  • HeXrider

    Huggybear,i also thought that 😀 it would seem more happy that way, maybe it’s just some mission to vroengard maybe to find the VoS or whatever, It could be a significant quest (attaining information, or whatever) but not a definitive leave from alagaesia. It is true however that angela tols eragon his faith was to leave forever. Maybe we must not link those two things together. maybe it’s galby leaving and murthagh maybe eragon is going to find the real homeland of the humans (where the ra’zac came from too)Who knows maybe eragons leaving is something very different

  • Bill

    Eldest- Eragon could not have punished gably the way he punished sloan because galby put wards in place killing anyone who uses his true name

  • Bill

    Eldest- Eragon could not have punished gably the way he punished sloan because galby put wards in place killing anyone who uses his true name

  • xhuggybearx

    i think that were looking at the vision the wrong way, who said that they were leaving forever on that boat, maybe they were going on some kind of mission and had to appear as a human couple and there dragons were going off to hide

  • xhuggybearx

    i think that were looking at the vision the wrong way, who said that they were leaving forever on that boat, maybe they were going on some kind of mission and had to appear as a human couple and there dragons were going off to hide

  • yo.blagden

    Whoever it is the ruler of Alagaesia will be a mortal.Orrin had said”We do not want another gallbatorix”So no dragonrider could be king.

    Elves are immortal so if Islanzadi doesnt die she will continue to rule.

    Angela is human.Oromis said so.Even if she altered her appearance her concience remains that of a human.
    Angela herself told Nasuada that apart from Galby she was old considering humans

  • yo.blagden

    Whoever it is the ruler of Alagaesia will be a mortal.Orrin had said”We do not want another gallbatorix”So no dragonrider could be king.Elves are immortal so if Islanzadi doesnt die she will continue to rule.Angela is human.Oromis said so.Even if she altered her appearance her concience remains that of a human.Angela herself told Nasuada that apart from Galby she was old considering humans

  • dragoneater

    No one said we were sure. I said for the purpose of this convo, let’s assume this is the case. According the majority of this board, Arya is likely to be the next rider, so my thought is that IF she is the next rider, it seems she is giving up a lot, ie becoming the Queen of Ellesmera.
    I’m not sure why Nasuada would leave her people, she seems well suited for leadership, I doubt she would leave the Varden, but who knows!

  • dragoneater

    No one said we were sure. I said for the purpose of this convo, let’s assume this is the case. According the majority of this board, Arya is likely to be the next rider, so my thought is that IF she is the next rider, it seems she is giving up a lot, ie becoming the Queen of Ellesmera. I’m not sure why Nasuada would leave her people, she seems well suited for leadership, I doubt she would leave the Varden, but who knows!

  • voiceofreason

    There are a bunch of evles who would be good candidates to be their king or queen.

    What bothers me is that we are so sure that it’s Eragon and Arya that are leaving on the ship.
    What about Eragon and Nasuada?
    What about Roran and Katrina, leaving Sloan on the beach?

    Ahhh! I hate not knowing!!!

  • voiceofreason

    There are a bunch of evles who would be good candidates to be their king or queen.

    What bothers me is that we are so sure that it\’s Eragon and Arya that are leaving on the ship.

    What about Eragon and Nasuada?

    What about Roran and Katrina, leaving Sloan on the beach?

    Ahhh! I hate not knowing!!!

  • dragoneater

    “His most exalted royal highness, Grimrr Halfpaw, King of the Werecats, Lord of the lonely places, Ruler of the night reaches, and he who walks alone”

  • dragoneater

    “His most exalted royal highness, Grimrr Halfpaw, King of the Werecats, Lord of the lonely places, Ruler of the night reaches, and he who walks alone”

  • Avantir

    Can anyone tell me exactly (Word for word) what the werecat king was called when his presence was announced? It seems to have disappeared off Amazon and I need the information for a theory article I’m writing.

  • Avantir

    Can anyone tell me exactly (Word for word) what the werecat king was called when his presence was announced? It seems to have disappeared off Amazon and I need the information for a theory article I’m writing.

  • dragoneater

    Let me interject with something a little bit off topic and will hopefully begin a new convo. Lets supposed Arya will be the next dragon rider, which isn’t all that hard to imagine, and then lets also suppose she is the one leaving with eragon in the dream. Who then does that leave to rule Ellesmera? She is heir to the throne, but as mentioned in Eldest, Elves do not choose rulers who are unwilling to devote themselves whoheartedly to their duties. Also, is Tenga an Elf? If not, what is he?

  • dragoneater

    Let me interject with something a little bit off topic and will hopefully begin a new convo. Lets supposed Arya will be the next dragon rider, which isn’t all that hard to imagine, and then lets also suppose she is the one leaving with eragon in the dream. Who then does that leave to rule Ellesmera? She is heir to the throne, but as mentioned in Eldest, Elves do not choose rulers who are unwilling to devote themselves whoheartedly to their duties. Also, is Tenga an Elf? If not, what is he?

  • iloveeragon

    voiceofreason

    im like you i want all these things to happen but it would be a good twist if something/someone else took the person/thing i wanted it to be.

  • iloveeragon

    voiceofreason

    im like you i want all these things to happen but it would be a good twist if something/someone else took the person/thing i wanted it to be.

  • Maawww

    zasekr1 – Elfs do not reveal anyone’s secret, whatever Oromis told about Angela is that already known fact, but it is just a part of what Angela is, human and caster, they would never reveal any friends secret. I beleive that Angela is partly Grey Folk.

  • Maawww

    zasekr1 – Elfs do not reveal anyone’s secret, whatever Oromis told about Angela is that already known fact, but it is just a part of what Angela is, human and caster, they would never reveal any friends secret. I beleive that Angela is partly Grey Folk.

  • voiceofreason

    Angela is one of my favorite charatres, if not my most fave.

    But at the end of Eragon after he killed the shade Angela said that her powers aren\’t like Aryas or his. And that she has to use herbs to heal… I think Angela is really clever but not powerfull.

  • voiceofreason

    Angela is one of my favorite charatres, if not my most fave.
    But at the end of Eragon after he killed the shade Angela said that her powers aren’t like Aryas or his. And that she has to use herbs to heal… I think Angela is really clever but not powerfull.

  • voiceofreason

    I don\’t think we have to get too worked up about the green dragon missing from this ONE chapter.

    Just because Greenie wasn\’t mentioned in this chapter (when the focus was on werecats) does not mean it no longer exsists.

    As to a dwarf dragon rider… for some reason in every good book I read that had dwarves in it, they never liked being to high off the ground. It might happen, I don\’t think so, but it might happen.

    I kind of want Arya to be the next DR, but at the same time it would almist be to perfect…

    Just like I kind of want her and Eragon to get together, but then I kind of don\’t.

  • voiceofreason

    I don’t think we have to get too worked up about the green dragon missing from this ONE chapter.
    Just because Greenie wasn’t mentioned in this chapter (when the focus was on werecats) does not mean it no longer exsists.

    As to a dwarf dragon rider… for some reason in every good book I read that had dwarves in it, they never liked being to high off the ground. It might happen, I don’t think so, but it might happen.

    I kind of want Arya to be the next DR, but at the same time it would almist be to perfect…
    Just like I kind of want her and Eragon to get together, but then I kind of don’t.

  • Were176cRider

    zasekr1-thanks for the agreement with my theory. Yeah, I agree with you that Angela is probably more powerful than she lets on.

  • Were176cRider

    zasekr1-thanks for the agreement with my theory. Yeah, I agree with you that Angela is probably more powerful than she lets on.

  • Eldest

    Hey what if it’s Galby crying on the beach in Eragon’s dream not Murtagh. He could have punished him similar to Sloan! Agree?

  • zasekr1

    were176crider – thats a really good viewpoint of the angela half elf theory. many ppl have suggested that she is half elf but then were rebuked because of oromis in eldest sayin that she was human…. but like u said she could have changed her appearance to seem more young/human. the only problem is that she said she had problems controlling and using magic and to change your appearance is hard magic but yet again i think she isnt letting on how powerfull she really is

  • Eldest

    Hey what if it’s Galby crying on the beach in Eragon’s dream not Murtagh. He could have punished him similar to Sloan! Agree?

  • zasekr1

    were176crider – thats a really good viewpoint of the angela half elf theory. many ppl have suggested that she is half elf but then were rebuked because of oromis in eldest sayin that she was human…. but like u said she could have changed her appearance to seem more young/human. the only problem is that she said she had problems controlling and using magic and to change your appearance is hard magic but yet again i think she isnt letting on how powerfull she really is

  • Were176cRider

    Wait, I have a better theory.

    CP said that there can be people who are half elf, half human right?

    So, could Angela be one of those people?

    I only say this because she is older than she looks and has been to Ellesmera.

    p.s. Arya changed her appearence in Brisingr using magic, so maybe that’s what Angela is doing the whole time.

  • Were176cRider

    Wait, I have a better theory.

    CP said that there can be people who are half elf, half human right?

    So, could Angela be one of those people?

    I only say this because she is older than she looks and has been to Ellesmera.

    p.s. Arya changed her appearence in Brisingr using magic, so maybe that’s what Angela is doing the whole time.

  • Were176cRider

    After all this hype about the green dragon, and no mention of it in the first four chapters of the fourth book, I have a theory.

    What if the green dragon doesn’t hatch until like the last chapter, when the battle is already over?

  • Were176cRider

    After all this hype about the green dragon, and no mention of it in the first four chapters of the fourth book, I have a theory.

    What if the green dragon doesn’t hatch until like the last chapter, when the battle is already over?

  • zasekr1

    500 comment wow

    on the subject of the green rider i always wanted angela to be the green rider. it wud be a great little twist

  • zasekr1

    500 comment wow

    on the subject of the green rider i always wanted angela to be the green rider. it wud be a great little twist

  • iloveeragon

    abr.du.fells and eragonrocks

    thank you for commenting on what i thought because it gives mea better prediction of what the 4th book will be like. 🙂

    P.S. if any of you wonder why i always put smilees on mine its because i love smilees!!! lol! 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    abr.du.fells and eragonrocks

    thank you for commenting on what i thought because it gives mea better prediction of what the 4th book will be like. 🙂

    P.S. if any of you wonder why i always put smilees on mine its because i love smilees!!! lol! 🙂

  • Abr.du.fells

    -iloveeragon

    If you are referring to your theory that Murtagh is going to become king, it would be an interesting and cool twist, but like people have said before, someone from Carvahall is going to inherit the throne. Roran is too likely a candidate in my opinion. However I do like considering the possibility.

  • Abr.du.fells

    -iloveeragonIf you are referring to your theory that Murtagh is going to become king, it would be an interesting and cool twist, but like people have said before, someone from Carvahall is going to inherit the throne. Roran is too likely a candidate in my opinion. However I do like considering the possibility.

  • eragonrocks

    hey iloveeragon I\’m responding to your theory thank you very much.

  • eragonrocks

    hey iloveeragon I’m responding to your theory thank you very much.

  • eragonrocks

    iloveeragon-I think that you are right and hrathgar used eragon so they aren\’t left out of all this dragon riding stuff bewteen evles and humans.They could also be doing this so that the dwarves could live longer.

  • eragonrocks

    iloveeragon-I think that you are right and hrathgar used eragon so they aren’t left out of all this dragon riding stuff bewteen evles and humans.They could also be doing this so that the dwarves could live longer.

  • iloveeragon

    plz could you peoples comment on my theory cuz i would like to know others thoughts about agreeing or disagreeing with me. plz 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    plz could you peoples comment on my theory cuz i would like to know others thoughts about agreeing or disagreeing with me. plz 🙂

  • eragonrocks

    yo hexrider I agree that what you said about the 1 female each thing is right even though my comment was late.

  • eragonrocks

    yo hexrider I agree that what you said about the 1 female each thing is right even though my comment was late.

  • iloveeragon

    im not saying its true but do you think that since eragon joined hrothgars clan that the dwarves can now be dragon riders?

    i say this because in eldest on page 638 it says \”im glad you accepted my offer to become Durgrimst Ingeitum. it is a honor to have you as mine kin\” is what hrothgar says. eragon says \”and you mine\”

  • iloveeragon

    im not saying its true but do you think that since eragon joined hrothgars clan that the dwarves can now be dragon riders?

    i say this because in eldest on page 638 it says “im glad you accepted my offer to become Durgrimst Ingeitum. it is a honor to have you as mine kin” is what hrothgar says. eragon says “and you mine”

  • frank

    its really unlikely there are other heart of hearts cause oromis told eragon that brom went looking for them after his saphira was killed and he couldnt find them and that all the heart of hearts were well accounted for. the vault of souls definitely just has galbatorix’s heart of hearts and eragon will release them

  • frank

    its really unlikely there are other heart of hearts cause oromis told eragon that brom went looking for them after his saphira was killed and he couldnt find them and that all the heart of hearts were well accounted for. the vault of souls definitely just has galbatorix’s heart of hearts and eragon will release them

  • Eldest

    zasekr1 – Yep

    What’s with this teenage girl stuff she only appears once!! It’s not like she’s gonna kill galby or something they’re not even part of the Varden!

  • Eldest

    zasekr1 – YepWhat’s with this teenage girl stuff she only appears once!! It’s not like she’s gonna kill galby or something they’re not even part of the Varden!

  • MeganBevis

    Oh… I didn\’t know that. Who do u think the next rider will be then?

  • MeganBevis

    Oh… I didn’t know that. Who do u think the next rider will be then?

  • elvenprincess

    do you think maybe the teenage girl will help steal the green egg (if it hasn’t been stolen or hatched already). she definitely has to play a big part in bk4 if angela read her fortune and solembaum talked to her! maybe she and her mom were captive in galby’s castle and escaped and might help eragon to get in and they’ll steal the egg or rescue some eldunari?

    any thoughts on shruikan’s fate??

  • elvenprincess

    do you think maybe the teenage girl will help steal the green egg (if it hasn’t been stolen or hatched already). she definitely has to play a big part in bk4 if angela read her fortune and solembaum talked to her! maybe she and her mom were captive in galby’s castle and escaped and might help eragon to get in and they’ll steal the egg or rescue some eldunari?

    any thoughts on shruikan’s fate??

  • zasekr1

    hadnt read the 2nd page of comments yet eldest soz

    least we know that it is an idea that several of us have thought of yano?

  • zasekr1

    hadnt read the 2nd page of comments yet eldest soz

    least we know that it is an idea that several of us have thought of yano?

  • Eldest

    zasekr1 – thats what I said.

    “Also In Eldest an elf Eragon is talking to says royal blood lives in Carvahall from King Palancer. So that means that when Galby dies the real king will be from Carvahall.”

  • Eldest

    zasekr1 – thats what I said.”Also In Eldest an elf Eragon is talking to says royal blood lives in Carvahall from King Palancer. So that means that when Galby dies the real king will be from Carvahall.”

  • zasekr1

    i think that roran will become the new king after deciding that it will be the only way to protect katrina and his child and he is most likely related to king palancar neways

  • zasekr1

    i think that roran will become the new king after deciding that it will be the only way to protect katrina and his child and he is most likely related to king palancar neways

  • Dragonrider360

    I like the idea of Murtaug being king, but, once again, we can’t have an immortal king. I donno about Roran….. Something tells me that there may wild dragons in the Spine or on Vronengard. As for the mountain in the Hadarac Desert, I’m thinking there could be Heart of Hearts or possibly dragon eggs. Just something to ponder over.

    PS: I have other questions and theories ya’ll might want to check out. It’s on the Q&A Solutions and Problems News. If anybody reads them I would like feedback! Thanks for reading! 🙂

  • Dragonrider360

    I like the idea of Murtaug being king, but, once again, we can’t have an immortal king. I donno about Roran….. Something tells me that there may wild dragons in the Spine or on Vronengard. As for the mountain in the Hadarac Desert, I’m thinking there could be Heart of Hearts or possibly dragon eggs. Just something to ponder over.PS: I have other questions and theories ya’ll might want to check out. It’s on the Q&A Solutions and Problems News. If anybody reads them I would like feedback! Thanks for reading! 🙂

  • vannet

    @MeganNicole-Good thoughts but Paolini already said that the next rider was in all 3 books and that girl was only in Brisingr.

  • vannet

    @MeganNicole-Good thoughts but Paolini already said that the next rider was in all 3 books and that girl was only in Brisingr.

  • iloveeragon

    it would be interesting to see murtagh king but id rather have it be roran but thats just my opinion

  • iloveeragon

    it would be interesting to see murtagh king but id rather have it be roran but thats just my opinion

  • MeganNicole

    heres my theory: the teenage girl is galbatorix’s daughter. therefore making her ‘of noble birth’. she becomes the next dragon rider and falls in love with eragon.

  • MeganNicole

    heres my theory: the teenage girl is galbatorix’s daughter. therefore making her ‘of noble birth’. she becomes the next dragon rider and falls in love with eragon.

  • voiceofreason

    Murtage dose kinda like Nusada. Remamber in Eragon when Murtage was in confindement, he told Eragon that Nusada had talked to him.

    There was a big hint hint!

    But as to Murtage being king… because he is a dragon rider he is immortal (duh) lol. That means Thorn has to die, and THEN he has to change sides, and THEN Nausada and him have to come to an “understanding”.

    Idk, it just seems like an awful big stretch for me to beleive that he will be king.

  • voiceofreason

    Murtage dose kinda like Nusada. Remamber in Eragon when Murtage was in confindement, he told Eragon that Nusada had talked to him.
    There was a big hint hint!
    But as to Murtage being king… because he is a dragon rider he is immortal (duh) lol. That means Thorn has to die, and THEN he has to change sides, and THEN Nausada and him have to come to an “understanding”.
    Idk, it just seems like an awful big stretch for me to beleive that he will be king.

  • Eldest

    Abr.du.fells – I agree it seems fit and I think VOS is on Vrongaurd.

  • Eldest

    Abr.du.fells – I agree it seems fit and I think VOS is on Vrongaurd.

  • yo.blagden

    I think Roran & Katrina will return to Carvahall.
    Nasuada will be queen & murtagh the king of Alagaesia.I know that Nasuada is a mortal but we can still hope.
    Also I dont think Nasuada will be the rider coz Orrin & Nasuada discussed in Brisingr how dangerous it is to have an immortal king.

  • yo.blagden

    I think Roran & Katrina will return to Carvahall.Nasuada will be queen & murtagh the king of Alagaesia.I know that Nasuada is a mortal but we can still hope.Also I dont think Nasuada will be the rider coz Orrin & Nasuada discussed in Brisingr how dangerous it is to have an immortal king.

  • yo.blagden

    I think CP told about the rider being in all 3 books in the interviews after releasing Brisingr or in the Q&As.I’m not so sure.

  • yo.blagden

    I think CP told about the rider being in all 3 books in the interviews after releasing Brisingr or in the Q&As.I’m not so sure.

  • Abr.du.fells

    -elvenprincess

    Murtagh seems like a plausible candidate for king. If for some reason Roran is not.

  • Abr.du.fells

    -elvenprincessMurtagh seems like a plausible candidate for king. If for some reason Roran is not.

  • Abr.du.fells

    Who thinks that the VOS is going to hold the HOHs? What else do you think could be there? Does anyone think it is possible to bring someone back from the dead there? Such as if Saphira dies?

  • Abr.du.fells

    Who thinks that the VOS is going to hold the HOHs? What else do you think could be there? Does anyone think it is possible to bring someone back from the dead there? Such as if Saphira dies?

  • elvenprincess

    voiceofreason- i also think that maybe murtagh might be the man on the beach crying out in eragon’s dream!

    does anyone think that maybe murtagh will become king (with nasuada as queen??) instead of roran? it seems to me that roran just wants to settle down with katrina in his farm and lead the quiet life. And in eragon , eragon commented that murtagh seemed to understand a great deal about the ‘politics’ of the land and suchlike.

  • elvenprincess

    voiceofreason- i also think that maybe murtagh might be the man on the beach crying out in eragon’s dream!

    does anyone think that maybe murtagh will become king (with nasuada as queen??) instead of roran? it seems to me that roran just wants to settle down with katrina in his farm and lead the quiet life. And in eragon , eragon commented that murtagh seemed to understand a great deal about the ‘politics’ of the land and suchlike.

  • Eldest

    I agree.

  • Eldest

    I agree.

  • HeXrider

    Yo.Blagden… can you recall WHEN or WHERE CP said that the new rider appeared in all three books? is it some interview? cuz i would like to read it 😀

    hmmm your theory sounds nice, about the RoK, it would be a good hiding spot too, with the misty interior. of where the trees are standing. And wood in RL can become stone by fossilizing, so that would mean the RoK/VoS is very VERY old… which is another coincidence. but that would mean that the dwarfs haven’t excavated the RoK yet/ haven’t found the entrance yet.

    For the third rider, the story would be most interesting if the rider where female, because there is 1 female dragon (saphira) and to equal that there should be 1 female rider. I keep my arrows pointed at Arya, it could mean a very interesting twist within the story. Nasuada can’t be a rider, she’s got the varden to worry about, Arya has noting specific after succeeding in transporting the egg to eragon. just serving her people, how better can she do that then being a rider?

  • HeXrider

    Yo.Blagden… can you recall WHEN or WHERE CP said that the new rider appeared in all three books? is it some interview? cuz i would like to read it :Dhmmm your theory sounds nice, about the RoK, it would be a good hiding spot too, with the misty interior. of where the trees are standing. And wood in RL can become stone by fossilizing, so that would mean the RoK/VoS is very VERY old… which is another coincidence. but that would mean that the dwarfs haven’t excavated the RoK yet/ haven’t found the entrance yet.For the third rider, the story would be most interesting if the rider where female, because there is 1 female dragon (saphira) and to equal that there should be 1 female rider. I keep my arrows pointed at Arya, it could mean a very interesting twist within the story. Nasuada can’t be a rider, she’s got the varden to worry about, Arya has noting specific after succeeding in transporting the egg to eragon. just serving her people, how better can she do that then being a rider?

  • Eldest

    Selena though remember was highly trained in magic and deceitful, plus why would she fallow Eragon out of Term “to see how he turns out” her atitude toward Eragon is also different than towards other people if you notice. She could have lost Galby’s trail on her like squashing an aunt.

    Roran will probably become king.

    Elva will turn on the Varden maby kill Angela (or Selena).

    Murtagugh is mostlikely the unfortinent the person.

    The Menola tree will force Eragon to leave Alegasia.

  • Eldest

    Selena though remember was highly trained in magic and deceitful, plus why would she fallow Eragon out of Term “to see how he turns out” her atitude toward Eragon is also different than towards other people if you notice. She could have lost Galby’s trail on her like squashing an aunt.Roran will probably become king.Elva will turn on the Varden maby kill Angela (or Selena).Murtagugh is mostlikely the unfortinent the person.The Menola tree will force Eragon to leave Alegasia.

  • voiceofreason

    elvenprincess, I think you might have something there!

    Also in that same dream wasn’t there a person staying behind crying out? It MIGHT be Murtage… it just seems like CP made Murtage to be the unfortunate person of the story.

  • voiceofreason

    elvenprincess, I think you might have something there!
    Also in that same dream wasn’t there a person staying behind crying out? It MIGHT be Murtage… it just seems like CP made Murtage to be the unfortunate person of the story.

  • yo.blagden

    CP said the greenie rider has appeared in the all 3 books.Charachters featured in all 3 books are-Arya,Jeod(unlikely),Elva,Orik(unlikely)
    Nasuada,Roran,Katrina,Angela(unlikely).

    Also dragonriders are chosen young.So maybe Arya couldnt be,though I hope she is.
    In Eragons guide to Alagaesia he writes a letter to the new rider.So I dont know whether he even knows who it is.

    The woman & a teenager whom Angela prophecies couldnt be behind the egg.The girl thanked Eragon & Saphira.

    You know how in King cat Grimmr Halfpaw refuses to let Angela inspect their minds.So she could have done this before.And I dont think Angela’s bad at all.After all CP has named her after his sister.

    The rock of Kuthian could be in the FOREST of STONE.CP would not have mentioned it just for show

  • yo.blagden

    CP said the greenie rider has appeared in the all 3 books.Charachters featured in all 3 books are-Arya,Jeod(unlikely),Elva,Orik(unlikely)Nasuada,Roran,Katrina,Angela(unlikely).Also dragonriders are chosen young.So maybe Arya couldnt be,though I hope she is.In Eragons guide to Alagaesia he writes a letter to the new rider.So I dont know whether he even knows who it is.The woman & a teenager whom Angela prophecies couldnt be behind the egg.The girl thanked Eragon & Saphira.You know how in King cat Grimmr Halfpaw refuses to let Angela inspect their minds.So she could have done this before.And I dont think Angela’s bad at all.After all CP has named her after his sister.The rock of Kuthian could be in the FOREST of STONE.CP would not have mentioned it just for show

  • Deidara

    @eragonrocks: yes maybe elva roran nasuada islandsadi or Angela

  • Deidara

    @eragonrocks: yes maybe elva roran nasuada islandsadi or Angela

  • abc

    i cant wait want 2 read book 4 fast hope paolini finishes it fast

  • abc

    i cant wait want 2 read book 4 fast hope paolini finishes it fast

  • Tulkas

    xhuggybearx- In an interview here, CP said that Brom’s ring was not an eldunari.
    yo.blagden- Being related to Galby has nothing to do with it. He is long-lived because he is a dragon rider.

    Didn’t Brom say something about how Selena liked animals or something? I’m not sure, but it could explain Solembum. I doubt this, though.

    HeXrider- First of all, CP said that he did not even remember the green shards, second of all I doubt that werecats could raise a dragon in the middle of Du Weldenvarden without the elves knowing about it, through the Menoa tree if nothing else, and third a werecat dragon rider would have to be included in the rider-spell.

  • Tulkas

    xhuggybearx- In an interview here, CP said that Brom’s ring was not an eldunari.yo.blagden- Being related to Galby has nothing to do with it. He is long-lived because he is a dragon rider.Didn’t Brom say something about how Selena liked animals or something? I’m not sure, but it could explain Solembum. I doubt this, though.HeXrider- First of all, CP said that he did not even remember the green shards, second of all I doubt that werecats could raise a dragon in the middle of Du Weldenvarden without the elves knowing about it, through the Menoa tree if nothing else, and third a werecat dragon rider would have to be included in the rider-spell.

  • yo.blagden

    hi
    there is a possibility that angela might be a relative of galby coz when arya said that only galby is considered old, angela said me too

  • yo.blagden

    hithere is a possibility that angela might be a relative of galby coz when arya said that only galby is considered old, angela said me too

  • iloveeragon

    i hope eragon will read the book cuz its like his only answer to the VOS and ROK

  • iloveeragon

    i hope eragon will read the book cuz its like his only answer to the VOS and ROK

  • eragonrocks

    Can anybody think of some other character in the books who could take Arya place and be the rider of the green dragon

  • eragonrocks

    Can anybody think of some other character in the books who could take Arya place and be the rider of the green dragon

  • trevor1237657

    eragons mother lived outside of Kuasta with morzan at his castle. She also died there. Oromis told Eragon that Brom’s parents lived in Kuasta. He didnt know it at the time but those would be his grandparents. Joed gave eragon a book written by a monk from Kuasta. The monk’s religion was to preserve information about the whole world. possibly information about the ROK and the VOS. Eragon has so many connections there, he will go there and someone will help him discover the ROK. Then when he opens it he will bring either the original Eragon back to life, or Vrael

  • trevor1237657

    eragons mother lived outside of Kuasta with morzan at his castle. She also died there. Oromis told Eragon that Brom’s parents lived in Kuasta. He didnt know it at the time but those would be his grandparents. Joed gave eragon a book written by a monk from Kuasta. The monk’s religion was to preserve information about the whole world. possibly information about the ROK and the VOS. Eragon has so many connections there, he will go there and someone will help him discover the ROK. Then when he opens it he will bring either the original Eragon back to life, or Vrael

  • eragonrocks

    hey does anybody kind of guess what Arya will call her dragon if she becomes the dragon rider.

  • eragonrocks

    hey does anybody kind of guess what Arya will call her dragon if she becomes the dragon rider.

  • eragonrocks

    that is true that angela said that.

  • eragonrocks

    that is true that angela said that.

  • kpr

    I think that Arya is the next rider b/c of when Angela mentioned that Eragon would have an Epic Romance in his future. And what could be more epic than 2 dragon riders one elf and the other human/elf getting together.

  • kpr

    I think that Arya is the next rider b/c of when Angela mentioned that Eragon would have an Epic Romance in his future. And what could be more epic than 2 dragon riders one elf and the other human/elf getting together.

  • iloveeragon

    i also think that arya should be the next rider too. it just fits but like i said before there are many possibilities.

    if there is to be a new king that takes galbys place i think it should be roran. i say this because hes a good leader and cp said that somebody has the blood of a use to be king/leader and im sure it is roran. i mean he brought all of carvahall to surda and that is huge. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    i also think that arya should be the next rider too. it just fits but like i said before there are many possibilities.

    if there is to be a new king that takes galbys place i think it should be roran. i say this because hes a good leader and cp said that somebody has the blood of a use to be king/leader and im sure it is roran. i mean he brought all of carvahall to surda and that is huge. 🙂

  • eragonrocks

    dragonrider360-I agree with you arya should be the next dragon rider not roran because that might mess things up with Katrina and roran.Though I didn\’t mean to be rude to anyone.

  • eragonrocks

    dragonrider360-I agree with you arya should be the next dragon rider not roran because that might mess things up with Katrina and roran.Though I didn’t mean to be rude to anyone.

  • eragonrocks

    iloveeragon-I think that the werecats hate angela because solumnbum might have been becoming leader but they might be convinced that she like made solumnbum join her which kept him from being made king. Though I did not mean to be a little rude.

  • eragonrocks

    iloveeragon-I think that the werecats hate angela because solumnbum might have been becoming leader but they might be convinced that she like made solumnbum join her which kept him from being made king. Though I did not mean to be a little rude.

  • Dragonrider360

    Thanks for commenting back dudes! I appreciate it! I liked the idea of Angela being Selena,but it just doesn’t fit. Something else came to mind though, what if Angela is half elf, half human? Just sayn’. No, I don’t think Roran should be the next rider. If he did, then he wouldn’t be able to love Katrina as long as he could. So I think Arya is the fit canidate, because she uses green magic, and the dragon is green.

  • Dragonrider360

    Thanks for commenting back dudes! I appreciate it! I liked the idea of Angela being Selena,but it just doesn’t fit. Something else came to mind though, what if Angela is half elf, half human? Just sayn’. No, I don’t think Roran should be the next rider. If he did, then he wouldn’t be able to love Katrina as long as he could. So I think Arya is the fit canidate, because she uses green magic, and the dragon is green.

  • hans

    roran wont be the last dragon rider because in the chapter “kiss me sweet” katrina is talking to roran about how he is the greatest warrior and roran responds with what about eragon and galbatorix and the elves and katrina brings up how they all fight with magic and roran is nothing more than a man. christopher paolini wouldnt add this chapter in unless he was trying to make a point. roran being the greatest warrior also ties in with king palancars blood being in carvahall to suggest that roran will be king of alagaesia once the empire is defeated and he is the one standing on the beach as eragon, arya, saphira, and the green dragon leave

  • hans

    roran wont be the last dragon rider because in the chapter “kiss me sweet” katrina is talking to roran about how he is the greatest warrior and roran responds with what about eragon and galbatorix and the elves and katrina brings up how they all fight with magic and roran is nothing more than a man. christopher paolini wouldnt add this chapter in unless he was trying to make a point. roran being the greatest warrior also ties in with king palancars blood being in carvahall to suggest that roran will be king of alagaesia once the empire is defeated and he is the one standing on the beach as eragon, arya, saphira, and the green dragon leave

  • eragonrocks

    iloveeragon – I think they are trying to get the last egg.

  • eragonrocks

    iloveeragon – I think they are trying to get the last egg.

  • iloveeragon

    why did angela have eragon bless these two woman he doesnt even know??? could they be trying to get the last egg??? and what part do the werecats have in this? why do they hate angela except for solemnbum?

    sorry for all the questions they just came to me and im very curious.

  • iloveeragon

    why did angela have eragon bless these two woman he doesnt even know??? could they be trying to get the last egg??? and what part do the werecats have in this? why do they hate angela except for solemnbum?

    sorry for all the questions they just came to me and im very curious.

  • iloveeragon

    i wander if roran will die in battle cuz if he does i will be very sad . plus he has a kid on the way he shouldnt die so i hope he doesnt.

  • iloveeragon

    i wander if roran will die in battle cuz if he does i will be very sad . plus he has a kid on the way he shouldnt die so i hope he doesnt.

  • Kscandy15

    hey! i was also thinking of this…what if those two mysterious ladies were somehow related to Selena and Eragon? Because Angela only offers to cast someone’s future with the dragon knuckles if Solembum chooses to speak to them. Solembum spoke with Selena, and he spoke with Eragon, but also with those two other women. hmmm

  • Kscandy15

    hey! i was also thinking of this…what if those two mysterious ladies were somehow related to Selena and Eragon? Because Angela only offers to cast someone’s future with the dragon knuckles if Solembum chooses to speak to them. Solembum spoke with Selena, and he spoke with Eragon, but also with those two other women. hmmm

  • i<3murtagh

    yeah, selena died after giving birth to eragon, how could angelena be her?

  • i<3murtagh

    yeah, selena died after giving birth to eragon, how could angelena be her?

  • Alice

    Eldest – I don’t think Angela is Selena. If I remember correctly, Oromis gives Eragon a fareth of Selena that Brom made. Unless Angela drastically changed her appearance, I think Eragon would be able to recognize her from the picture. Even though it was a profile picture, I’m sure he would see the resemblance if it was there.

  • Alice

    Eldest – I don’t think Angela is Selena. If I remember correctly, Oromis gives Eragon a fareth of Selena that Brom made. Unless Angela drastically changed her appearance, I think Eragon would be able to recognize her from the picture. Even though it was a profile picture, I’m sure he would see the resemblance if it was there.

  • iloveeragon

    i dont think angela is selena because she gave a fourtune to somebody named selena so i doubt tha angela is selena. i dont mean to be rude though.

    i think that elva and arya are one of the most favorites to be the next rider. i hope its arya though. lol! that would be so awesome but im not sure because theres a whole lot of others who could be it. like roran, katrina, arya, elva, nasauda, and maybe somebody new.

  • iloveeragon

    i dont think angela is selena because she gave a fourtune to somebody named selena so i doubt tha angela is selena. i dont mean to be rude though.

    i think that elva and arya are one of the most favorites to be the next rider. i hope its arya though. lol! that would be so awesome but im not sure because theres a whole lot of others who could be it. like roran, katrina, arya, elva, nasauda, and maybe somebody new.

  • Kscandy15

    Hey guys!
    I’m just throwing this out there, but I think that ‘true names’ will be a huge deal in the 4th book. I think that Tenga will also have a big roll, and I think that his question was, “what is the true name of the ancient language?” Anybody agree? I wonder if parentage is going to have anything to do with the 4th book. Do you guys think it’s going to matter who Elva’s parents are? There wasn’t even a whisper of it in the books. I also wonder who Selena’s, Brom’s, and Galbatorix’s parents are. Maybe Oromis had some kids? Just things I was thinking of after I read all 18 pages of the discussion. I also think that Angela is somehow connected to the Grey Folk. It just seems like the most logical answer.

  • Kscandy15

    Hey guys!I’m just throwing this out there, but I think that ‘true names’ will be a huge deal in the 4th book. I think that Tenga will also have a big roll, and I think that his question was, “what is the true name of the ancient language?” Anybody agree? I wonder if parentage is going to have anything to do with the 4th book. Do you guys think it’s going to matter who Elva’s parents are? There wasn’t even a whisper of it in the books. I also wonder who Selena’s, Brom’s, and Galbatorix’s parents are. Maybe Oromis had some kids? Just things I was thinking of after I read all 18 pages of the discussion. I also think that Angela is somehow connected to the Grey Folk. It just seems like the most logical answer.

  • elvenprincess

    someone (oromis?) said that the ‘time of the riders is at an end’ and since in eragon’s vision there are only 2 dragons in the sky does that mean the other 2 (shruikan and thorn maybe?) will die in the 4th bk and saphira and greeni will be the 2 leaving AL?

    just thought i’d throw that idea out there… but i really hope they don’t die though.

    on another note i think maybe elva will be the new rider since saphira’s mark makes her ‘destined for greatness’. arya is too obvious.

  • elvenprincess

    someone (oromis?) said that the ‘time of the riders is at an end’ and since in eragon’s vision there are only 2 dragons in the sky does that mean the other 2 (shruikan and thorn maybe?) will die in the 4th bk and saphira and greeni will be the 2 leaving AL?
    just thought i’d throw that idea out there… but i really hope they don’t die though.

    on another note i think maybe elva will be the new rider since saphira’s mark makes her ‘destined for greatness’. arya is too obvious.

  • xhuggybearx

    i was thinking today, what if the stone in broms ring is actually his dragons HOH. they’ve all said that they can sense a huge amount of energy in it and they just assume that brom had been storing it in their, but what if its just his dragons energy.

    i know you all probably think well why cany they hear its thoughts, well maybe brom made his dragon take an oath sometime when they knew that it might come down to them being the last dragon and rider and part of that oath being that the dragon couldnt reveal its true self until some type of conditions were met so thats why u can sense it.

    now why would brom have done this, im thinking that maybe brom wasnt entirely sure that oromis was still alive and wanted to make sure that the new rider would have a teacher and so maybe the condition would be that the dragon would reveal itself when eragon was the last remaining rider loyal to the varden. and so now that oromis is dead the dragons HOH will come “to life” in the first few chapters of the new book

  • xhuggybearx

    i was thinking today, what if the stone in broms ring is actually his dragons HOH. they’ve all said that they can sense a huge amount of energy in it and they just assume that brom had been storing it in their, but what if its just his dragons energy.i know you all probably think well why cany they hear its thoughts, well maybe brom made his dragon take an oath sometime when they knew that it might come down to them being the last dragon and rider and part of that oath being that the dragon couldnt reveal its true self until some type of conditions were met so thats why u can sense it.now why would brom have done this, im thinking that maybe brom wasnt entirely sure that oromis was still alive and wanted to make sure that the new rider would have a teacher and so maybe the condition would be that the dragon would reveal itself when eragon was the last remaining rider loyal to the varden. and so now that oromis is dead the dragons HOH will come “to life” in the first few chapters of the new book

  • Eldest

    Hi everybody I have 2 important things to point out here.

    First awhile back before Brisinger came out I had a theory about Angela actualy being Selena (I’ll give reasons later) and I’m realy taking to that now

    Also In Eldest an elf Eragon is talking to says royal blood lives in Carvahall from King Palancer. So that means that when Galby dies the real king will be from Carvahall.

  • Eldest

    Hi everybody I have 2 important things to point out here.First awhile back before Brisinger came out I had a theory about Angela actualy being Selena (I’ll give reasons later) and I’m realy taking to that nowAlso In Eldest an elf Eragon is talking to says royal blood lives in Carvahall from King Palancer. So that means that when Galby dies the real king will be from Carvahall.

  • iloveeragon

    i soooo agree that arya and eragon should and will hook up and arya will be the next dragon rider. i hope the dragon hatched for somebody already so it can help fight(only if its on the vardens side though)if not than Grrr!

  • iloveeragon

    i soooo agree that arya and eragon should and will hook up and arya will be the next dragon rider. i hope the dragon hatched for somebody already so it can help fight(only if its on the vardens side though)if not than Grrr!

  • NewBookPlease

    Arya and Eragon will hook up, RIGHT after she becomes the rider of this green dragon! who agrees?

  • NewBookPlease

    Arya and Eragon will hook up, RIGHT after she becomes the rider of this green dragon! who agrees?

  • john

    yo.blagden

    just because the cover will feature a green dragon doesnt mean anything. glaedr was on the front of brisingr.
    and i have read the earlier comments. i like the idea of the first rider still being alive, and the idea of the green dragon already having hatched. but i still believe that the other egg is green because in the battle in the first book, arya used a spell that consisted of green energy. GREEN. i would think that magic energy color depends on dragon and vice versa. i may be wrong and who knows, maybe the dragon has already hatched and maybe it hatched for arya and shes hiding it. i dont know if she would do that or why. and it is possible that the werecats hatched the egg in secrecy creating the first rider whos not a human or elf. although that would be kinda weird. i dont think roran or katrina could possibly be the next rider, because i think roran will be the next king of alagaesia. and the people would not want another magic user to be in power after galbatorix.
    another thing.
    could the rocks of kuthian be on the island of sharktooth? it seems like the kinda desolate place something almost sacred sounding as the vault of souls would be. and i like the idea or the vault of souls being full of eldunari like one earlier comment said. it could be the full of the eldunari of the original dragons the ones of old before galbatorix started taking them all.

    please tell me what you think about these theories and how possible it could be and if i mightve left something out. but dont criticize me to an unnecessary level.

  • john

    yo.blagdenjust because the cover will feature a green dragon doesnt mean anything. glaedr was on the front of brisingr. and i have read the earlier comments. i like the idea of the first rider still being alive, and the idea of the green dragon already having hatched. but i still believe that the other egg is green because in the battle in the first book, arya used a spell that consisted of green energy. GREEN. i would think that magic energy color depends on dragon and vice versa. i may be wrong and who knows, maybe the dragon has already hatched and maybe it hatched for arya and shes hiding it. i dont know if she would do that or why. and it is possible that the werecats hatched the egg in secrecy creating the first rider whos not a human or elf. although that would be kinda weird. i dont think roran or katrina could possibly be the next rider, because i think roran will be the next king of alagaesia. and the people would not want another magic user to be in power after galbatorix.another thing.could the rocks of kuthian be on the island of sharktooth? it seems like the kinda desolate place something almost sacred sounding as the vault of souls would be. and i like the idea or the vault of souls being full of eldunari like one earlier comment said. it could be the full of the eldunari of the original dragons the ones of old before galbatorix started taking them all. please tell me what you think about these theories and how possible it could be and if i mightve left something out. but dont criticize me to an unnecessary level.

  • dragoneater

    In the new chapter, in reference to Nasuada, “she too had been marked during the fighting”. leaves me to ponder as to whom else was marked during the fighting. Probably lots of people as the Varden were likely taking some serious casualties before the Big Cat showed, which would explain his arrogance and aloof attitude as well. Hopefully Roran wasn’t wounded too badly, he’s a bad mofo.

  • dragoneater

    In the new chapter, in reference to Nasuada, “she too had been marked during the fighting”. leaves me to ponder as to whom else was marked during the fighting. Probably lots of people as the Varden were likely taking some serious casualties before the Big Cat showed, which would explain his arrogance and aloof attitude as well. Hopefully Roran wasn’t wounded too badly, he’s a bad mofo.

  • dragoneater

    I bet Eragon and Arya end up hooking up. Who else agrees?

  • dragoneater

    I bet Eragon and Arya end up hooking up. Who else agrees?

  • yo.blagden

    The dragon is definitely green.CP said that the 4th book will feature a green dragon on the cover.

  • yo.blagden

    The dragon is definitely green.CP said that the 4th book will feature a green dragon on the cover.

  • yo.blagden

    Hi
    I just read KING CAT.on http://www.amazon.com
    Just go on books-brisingr-look inside-& in search type halfpaw.You neednt buy an edition now.

  • yo.blagden

    HiI just read KING CAT.on http://www.amazon.comJust go on books-brisingr-look inside-& in search type halfpaw.You neednt buy an edition now.

  • HeXrider

    To enlarge the theory of the green egg/dragon:

    What if the green dragon egg was allready stolen from galbatorix, but that he and whoever stole it have kept their silence. either by death or by magic?

    How about murthagh being sent by galby to find the egg/dragon. (it would explain his travels shortly hinted when saphira was alone while Eragon went to the dwarves clanmeet)

    How about the green egg shards where ectually of “the” green dragon. But that this green dragon is raised and trained in the utmost secrecy by someone. (maybe involve the werecats in this theory: the werecats know that the dragon has allready hatched, but choose not to share this information)

    What then if the green dragon comes forth and fights along with eragon with a rider we have not yet met?

    Just brainstorming, fill in or bust details if you want 😀

  • HeXrider

    To enlarge the theory of the green egg/dragon:What if the green dragon egg was allready stolen from galbatorix, but that he and whoever stole it have kept their silence. either by death or by magic?How about murthagh being sent by galby to find the egg/dragon. (it would explain his travels shortly hinted when saphira was alone while Eragon went to the dwarves clanmeet) How about the green egg shards where ectually of “the” green dragon. But that this green dragon is raised and trained in the utmost secrecy by someone. (maybe involve the werecats in this theory: the werecats know that the dragon has allready hatched, but choose not to share this information)What then if the green dragon comes forth and fights along with eragon with a rider we have not yet met?Just brainstorming, fill in or bust details if you want 😀

  • Alice

    Technically, Roran is the cousin of both Eragon and Murtagh, who happen to be half-brothers.

  • Alice

    Technically, Roran is the cousin of both Eragon and Murtagh, who happen to be half-brothers.

  • yo.blagden

    hi
    in the Q&A CP said that Murtagh had been always shown to kill/capture Eragon & Saphira (in ELD & BRI) but that he will play a bigger role in the fourth book.
    Also CP said that people will like it.So we have something to hope for.
    on green erider-the rider could be Roran coz Eragon,Murtagh & Roran are brothers.

  • yo.blagden

    hi in the Q&A CP said that Murtagh had been always shown to kill/capture Eragon & Saphira (in ELD & BRI) but that he will play a bigger role in the fourth book. Also CP said that people will like it.So we have something to hope for. on green erider-the rider could be Roran coz Eragon,Murtagh & Roran are brothers.

  • zasekr1

    omg maggimc thats a brilliant thought… if there is already a green dragon in the world it would explain possibly the green egg shards found in du fells nargroth (think its spelt right) it would mean that it could fight for what ever side it chooses….. oooooohhh i really like that idea

  • zasekr1

    omg maggimc thats a brilliant thought… if there is already a green dragon in the world it would explain possibly the green egg shards found in du fells nargroth (think its spelt right) it would mean that it could fight for what ever side it chooses….. oooooohhh i really like that idea

  • MaggiMc

    Question: I don’t remember canon ever mentioning the colour of the egg Galby still has… Is this true? We are all assuming that it MUST be green because we know there will be a green dragon. I agree with Baboo though, if the green dragon is a hatchingling it will have no real ability to change the story but just be part of the happily ever after. Because we were completely in the dark about Gladr before he appeared I like to think the Green dragon is not the dragon in the egg… Please one of you Inheritance encyclopedias let me know if the egg is ever actually refereed to by color!

  • MaggiMc

    Question: I don’t remember canon ever mentioning the colour of the egg Galby still has… Is this true? We are all assuming that it MUST be green because we know there will be a green dragon. I agree with Baboo though, if the green dragon is a hatchingling it will have no real ability to change the story but just be part of the happily ever after. Because we were completely in the dark about Gladr before he appeared I like to think the Green dragon is not the dragon in the egg… Please one of you Inheritance encyclopedias let me know if the egg is ever actually refereed to by color!

  • dragoneater

    I think the next dragon rider will be Roran. He will likely have a big role in the attempt to steal the green egg from galby, and Arya seems too obvious of a choice. Also seems to be some mysteries about Roran’s lineage that have yet to be uncovered.

  • dragoneater

    I think the next dragon rider will be Roran. He will likely have a big role in the attempt to steal the green egg from galby, and Arya seems too obvious of a choice. Also seems to be some mysteries about Roran’s lineage that have yet to be uncovered.

  • Alice

    I understand that Eragon made the oath to kill his brother. However, he wants to kill the brother who would be willing to do such an evil thing, like murdering a king. I think that if Murtagh changed enough and his true name changed, he could almost be categorized as a whole new person. In the way that his mind and soul would be so different. I agree though, that if this happened, Eragon would have a considerable amount of trouble with the dwarves. Maybe though, he could convince them that it was Galby’s fault more so then Murtagh’s since Murtagh was trapped under Galby’s orders.

  • Alice

    I understand that Eragon made the oath to kill his brother. However, he wants to kill the brother who would be willing to do such an evil thing, like murdering a king. I think that if Murtagh changed enough and his true name changed, he could almost be categorized as a whole new person. In the way that his mind and soul would be so different. I agree though, that if this happened, Eragon would have a considerable amount of trouble with the dwarves. Maybe though, he could convince them that it was Galby’s fault more so then Murtagh’s since Murtagh was trapped under Galby’s orders.

  • zasekr1

    it could gray folk that are on the boat with eragon in the vision/dream he had..

    does it say anywhere in the 3 books that the elves were generally taller than than humans? thats what made me think it could be the gf instead.

  • zasekr1

    it could gray folk that are on the boat with eragon in the vision/dream he had..
    does it say anywhere in the 3 books that the elves were generally taller than than humans? thats what made me think it could be the gf instead.

  • Baboo

    Were176cRider:

    It’s nothing to be ashamed about/afraid of in suggesting this, this is one of the more popular theories I have heard and certainly has a lot of supporting evidence.

    However, I should point out that it does not specify that the woman (or anyone else) is elven. Remember that at this point Eragon has never actually seen an elf. Based upon the description of the group (i.e. many had silver hair and carried tall lances) it is highly likely that they are elves.

    All we know about the woman (and the person she’s with) is that they are taller than the others (or at least appear that way in his dream).

    Remember that there are very few people (if any) on this site that simply tear peoples ideas apart in a malicious fasion. Mostly we’re just tossing ideas back and forth and trying to come up with really solid theories. If there are holes in a theory then they must be identified so that they can be explained/elaborated in order to make the theory stronger. And if there are serious holes then sometimes theories do have to back-track before they can progress.

  • Baboo

    Were176cRider:It’s nothing to be ashamed about/afraid of in suggesting this, this is one of the more popular theories I have heard and certainly has a lot of supporting evidence. However, I should point out that it does not specify that the woman (or anyone else) is elven. Remember that at this point Eragon has never actually seen an elf. Based upon the description of the group (i.e. many had silver hair and carried tall lances) it is highly likely that they are elves. All we know about the woman (and the person she’s with) is that they are taller than the others (or at least appear that way in his dream).Remember that there are very few people (if any) on this site that simply tear peoples ideas apart in a malicious fasion. Mostly we’re just tossing ideas back and forth and trying to come up with really solid theories. If there are holes in a theory then they must be identified so that they can be explained/elaborated in order to make the theory stronger. And if there are serious holes then sometimes theories do have to back-track before they can progress.

  • zasekr1

    all these theories makes me want the book to come out quicker so much more.

    i like the idea that the first eragon could still be alive. but if his dragon were still alive it would be ginormous!! so its probably in the spine or summat.

  • zasekr1

    all these theories makes me want the book to come out quicker so much more.

    i like the idea that the first eragon could still be alive. but if his dragon were still alive it would be ginormous!! so its probably in the spine or summat.

  • iloveeragon

    ya im with you dragonrider360 how did the first riders dragon die. cuz cp never mentioned him ever dying. so could it stilll be alive???

  • iloveeragon

    ya im with you dragonrider360 how did the first riders dragon die. cuz cp never mentioned him ever dying. so could it stilll be alive???

  • Were176cRider

    I am a bit nervous about asking this, but will Eragon leave Alagasia forever?

    He has a dream in the first book that shows him on a boat with an elven woman, with two dragons flying above.

    Would that woman be Arya, due to the fact that she is an elf? She is the most likely candidate to get the green dragon, so would that mean that that is her?

    Don’t judge this question too harshly, PLEASE!

  • Were176cRider

    I am a bit nervous about asking this, but will Eragon leave Alagasia forever?

    He has a dream in the first book that shows him on a boat with an elven woman, with two dragons flying above.

    Would that woman be Arya, due to the fact that she is an elf? She is the most likely candidate to get the green dragon, so would that mean that that is her?

    Don’t judge this question too harshly, PLEASE!

  • Dragonrider360

    Hold on, how did Angela get dragon knuckle bones?

    This question probably already been asked but how did the first Rider’s dragon die?

    Sorry again for posting so many questions….

  • Dragonrider360

    Hold on, how did Angela get dragon knuckle bones?

    This question probably already been asked but how did the first Rider’s dragon die?

    Sorry again for posting so many questions….

  • Were176cRider

    BTW, would it be possible that there are still wild Dragons, so would they be able to help the Varden and Saphira/Eragon? They might join foces and then attack Galbatorix with a dragon barrage.

  • Were176cRider

    BTW, would it be possible that there are still wild Dragons, so would they be able to help the Varden and Saphira/Eragon? They might join foces and then attack Galbatorix with a dragon barrage.

  • Were176cRider

    Could it be possible that the Vault of Souls that Solembum Mentions in Erargon contains lots of Eldunari. He says go there is your power is depleted, so could this be possible?

  • Were176cRider

    Could it be possible that the Vault of Souls that Solembum Mentions in Erargon contains lots of Eldunari. He says go there is your power is depleted, so could this be possible?

  • Dragonrider360

    What is Alaea, you know, the place where the elves came from?

    In the first book, there were attacks on ships in Teirm.Who or what are the attackers? Was it the Ra’zac?

    Just out of curiosity, what was that colorful bird in Angela’s shop?

    Sorry I posted so many questions…..

  • Dragonrider360

    What is Alaea, you know, the place where the elves came from?

    In the first book, there were attacks on ships in Teirm.Who or what are the attackers? Was it the Ra’zac?

    Just out of curiosity, what was that colorful bird in Angela’s shop?

    Sorry I posted so many questions…..

  • Dragonrider360

    I have another question:

    After I hurried to the local Barns and Noble, I found the book and read the the chapter and formulated a single question:

    If the werecats don’t like Angela, then why does Solembum hang around her?

    I STILL HAVE MORE QUESTIONS!!!!

  • Dragonrider360

    I have another question:
    After I hurried to the local Barns and Noble, I found the book and read the the chapter and formulated a single question:

    If the werecats don’t like Angela, then why does Solembum hang around her?

    I STILL HAVE MORE QUESTIONS!!!!

  • yo.blagden

    Eragon said he will do his best to avenge Hrothgars death.He might not kill Murtagh.I do hope Murtagh survives.Though I dont think its the dwarves nature 2 forgive someone.But with Orik as king &also as Eragons friend may forgive him.
    Also I dont understand why CP showed Murtagh as a sort of hero in Eragon only to make him his enemy in Eldest & Brisingr.I mean after being safe for the first time in his life with the Varden he was captured again.I really feel bad for him.He was 1 of my favorite characters.

  • yo.blagden

    Eragon said he will do his best to avenge Hrothgars death.He might not kill Murtagh.I do hope Murtagh survives.Though I dont think its the dwarves nature 2 forgive someone.But with Orik as king &also as Eragons friend may forgive him.Also I dont understand why CP showed Murtagh as a sort of hero in Eragon only to make him his enemy in Eldest & Brisingr.I mean after being safe for the first time in his life with the Varden he was captured again.I really feel bad for him.He was 1 of my favorite characters.

  • Tulkas

    I think that people are forgetting Eragon’s oath to kill Murtagh after he kills Horthgar. The only way around this would be if he killed Murtagh’s identity by changing his true name, but at least the Dwarves would still want to kill Murtagh.

  • Tulkas

    I think that people are forgetting Eragon’s oath to kill Murtagh after he kills Horthgar. The only way around this would be if he killed Murtagh’s identity by changing his true name, but at least the Dwarves would still want to kill Murtagh.

  • iloveeragon

    i really want to know who greenies rider is going to be and if it will beold and big enough to fight. if so i hope its on the vardens side. 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    i really want to know who greenies rider is going to be and if it will beold and big enough to fight. if so i hope its on the vardens side. 🙂

  • Baboo

    I still believe that Arya is the strong favorite to be the green dragon’s rider, but Nassuada is a definite possibility, as are a few others. In the same breath, it is possible that Saphira will mate with Thorn, but unlikely. However, both Eragon and Saphira’s feelings toward Murtagh/Thorn may change if they are able to change sides, especially if they do something really important in the meantime like save Eragon/Saphira/Roran’s life, pass on critical information to the Varden or (better yet) steal a certain green egg.

    On that note, I think it is time for fans to begin seriously considering the possibility that Greenie (the green dragon) will not play a major role in the upcoming battles. I’m not saying that this WILL be the case, but it looks more and more likely with each passing chapter.

    We have now seen the 4th chapter of Book 4 (or at least part of it) and there is no mention of the Varden acquiring it. It is possible that this occured in the first 3 chapters, but I still don’t think that there is any chance that it has hatched. At least 1 chapter would have to deal with stealing it (or at least having it presented to the Varden at the end of a chapter) and another chapter for it to hatch and bond to someone. So it’s theoretically posible, but highly unlikely, especially if a battle has also occured and the werecats have presented themselves in the first 3 chapters.

    Now, even if the dragon was to have hatched for someone by the beginning of the book, I still doubt it would reach 6 months of age before the Varden and company reach Uru’baen. Being realistic I doubt we could see Greenie before chapter 6 or 7 and it won’t be more than 3 or 4 months old in the final battle. The Varden will also not use growth acceleration like Galby did.

    If you think of Saphira trying to fight a random band of Kull just before reaching Farthen Dur, she was not all that formidable. She wasn’t even able to breath fire yet. I acknowledge that Saphira had no real training up to this point, but still, this is going to be one of the biggest battles in the history of Alagaesia and the foes will be Galby/Shruiken and possibly Murtagh/Thorn. Greenie isn’t exactly going to be turning any tides as a toddler, will he?

  • Baboo

    I still believe that Arya is the strong favorite to be the green dragon’s rider, but Nassuada is a definite possibility, as are a few others. In the same breath, it is possible that Saphira will mate with Thorn, but unlikely. However, both Eragon and Saphira’s feelings toward Murtagh/Thorn may change if they are able to change sides, especially if they do something really important in the meantime like save Eragon/Saphira/Roran’s life, pass on critical information to the Varden or (better yet) steal a certain green egg.On that note, I think it is time for fans to begin seriously considering the possibility that Greenie (the green dragon) will not play a major role in the upcoming battles. I’m not saying that this WILL be the case, but it looks more and more likely with each passing chapter. We have now seen the 4th chapter of Book 4 (or at least part of it) and there is no mention of the Varden acquiring it. It is possible that this occured in the first 3 chapters, but I still don’t think that there is any chance that it has hatched. At least 1 chapter would have to deal with stealing it (or at least having it presented to the Varden at the end of a chapter) and another chapter for it to hatch and bond to someone. So it’s theoretically posible, but highly unlikely, especially if a battle has also occured and the werecats have presented themselves in the first 3 chapters.Now, even if the dragon was to have hatched for someone by the beginning of the book, I still doubt it would reach 6 months of age before the Varden and company reach Uru’baen. Being realistic I doubt we could see Greenie before chapter 6 or 7 and it won’t be more than 3 or 4 months old in the final battle. The Varden will also not use growth acceleration like Galby did. If you think of Saphira trying to fight a random band of Kull just before reaching Farthen Dur, she was not all that formidable. She wasn’t even able to breath fire yet. I acknowledge that Saphira had no real training up to this point, but still, this is going to be one of the biggest battles in the history of Alagaesia and the foes will be Galby/Shruiken and possibly Murtagh/Thorn. Greenie isn’t exactly going to be turning any tides as a toddler, will he?

  • hans

    eragon has made an oath to kill murtagh so thorn and saphira bonding might be difficult…

  • hans

    eragon has made an oath to kill murtagh so thorn and saphira bonding might be difficult…

  • iloveeragon

    if saphira and thorn were to mate would eragon and murtagh become closer? i say this because they are brothers kinda(with the same mom) so would they become more like brothers. and if so do you think that murtagh will be able to change his real name and break free of galbys power or would eragon do as galby says because murtagh is under his power so it kinda would make eragon under the power to. so eragon surrenders to galby?? im just throwing it out there though 🙂

  • iloveeragon

    if saphira and thorn were to mate would eragon and murtagh become closer? i say this because they are brothers kinda(with the same mom) so would they become more like brothers. and if so do you think that murtagh will be able to change his real name and break free of galbys power or would eragon do as galby says because murtagh is under his power so it kinda would make eragon under the power to. so eragon surrenders to galby?? im just throwing it out there though 🙂

  • john

    i say arya will be the next dragon rider. for one thing she used to carry it btwn the varden and du weldenvarden and for another i notised while i was rereading book 1 that in a battle she used a spell that shot out a GREEN bolt of energy. its just a theory but it seems to me like the color of your dragon reflects the color or sword/magic etc. eragon has a blue dragon and when he uses the brisingr spell, the fire is blue. murtagh (and morzan) had a red sword and red dragon.

  • john

    i say arya will be the next dragon rider. for one thing she used to carry it btwn the varden and du weldenvarden and for another i notised while i was rereading book 1 that in a battle she used a spell that shot out a GREEN bolt of energy. its just a theory but it seems to me like the color of your dragon reflects the color or sword/magic etc. eragon has a blue dragon and when he uses the brisingr spell, the fire is blue. murtagh (and morzan) had a red sword and red dragon.

  • Alagaesiawanderer

    @Abr.du.fells
    I was somehow thinking on those lines: “when all hope is lost…” I think that either he or Saphira will be captured by Galby. Most likely Eragon will be captured and Saphira will surrender to Galby in the exchange of Eragon’s freedom… That would be really a situation when all the hope is lost.
    Regarding bringing somebody from the dead back to life, I recall having read that CP had hinted something about resurrecting a character… Not sure whether it was in a Q&A session, or some comment by Chris or some other from Shur’tugal staff. It might be that CP is not physically bringing somebody back to life but, who knows…

  • Alagaesiawanderer

    @Abr.du.fellsI was somehow thinking on those lines: “when all hope is lost…” I think that either he or Saphira will be captured by Galby. Most likely Eragon will be captured and Saphira will surrender to Galby in the exchange of Eragon’s freedom… That would be really a situation when all the hope is lost.Regarding bringing somebody from the dead back to life, I recall having read that CP had hinted something about resurrecting a character… Not sure whether it was in a Q&A session, or some comment by Chris or some other from Shur’tugal staff. It might be that CP is not physically bringing somebody back to life but, who knows…

  • indy

    i believe Arya willbe the next dragon rider because she has some much konowledge about magic and knows a good amout of dragon lore. plus she is much more experienced.

  • indy

    i believe Arya willbe the next dragon rider because she has some much konowledge about magic and knows a good amout of dragon lore. plus she is much more experienced.

  • Alice

    Murtaghs/beloved/enemy– I think it might be her. I did ntoice the green dress thing. She also is very strong and wise. Plus she knows how to fight and is brave. I think it’s likely she might be.

  • Alice

    Murtaghs/beloved/enemy– I think it might be her. I did ntoice the green dress thing. She also is very strong and wise. Plus she knows how to fight and is brave. I think it’s likely she might be.

  • Murtaghs/beloved/enemy
  • Murtaghs/beloved/enemy
  • MiaMaxRide

    Okay, about that one dream Eragon had about the boat and the two Dragons. I always saw it as Eragon and Saphira leaving, and she’s circling with Thorn or someone, and the man that lets out that anguished yell is either Murtagh or the other Dragons rider. (which would state that it’s a guy, but i can think that the two Dragons could mate without the riders also… mating. It would just be REALLY awkward for a while)

    email me if you want to make a point [email protected]

  • MiaMaxRide

    Okay, about that one dream Eragon had about the boat and the two Dragons. I always saw it as Eragon and Saphira leaving, and she’s circling with Thorn or someone, and the man that lets out that anguished yell is either Murtagh or the other Dragons rider. (which would state that it’s a guy, but i can think that the two Dragons could mate without the riders also… mating. It would just be REALLY awkward for a while)
    email me if you want to make a point [email protected]

  • steven

    Baboo – I realy don’t think that cp will make the time of the dragons come to an end because if he did then what would have been the pont in doing eragons guide to alagaesia, a whole guide for the next rider if there isn’t going to be one

  • steven

    Baboo – I realy don’t think that cp will make the time of the dragons come to an end because if he did then what would have been the pont in doing eragons guide to alagaesia, a whole guide for the next rider if there isn’t going to be one

  • Abr.du.fells

    My apologies on changing the subject of discussion, but there is something I have been wondering about for a while now.

    If I remember right, the instructions Eragon received said “when all hope is lost, go to the vault of souls and speak your name”. Now given all we have learned from the past three books, I just don’t see Eragon losing hope and dropping out of the fight. Unless that is, Saphira or maybe Arya dies. Otherwise what could cause Eragon to stop? Does anyone else see this a possibility? Or has this been discussed before?

    Also does anyone think perhaps the vault of souls contains the souls of those who have died, and it is possible that Eragon will go there in all likelihood to bring back Saphira or Arya if they die?

  • Abr.du.fells

    My apologies on changing the subject of discussion, but there is something I have been wondering about for a while now. If I remember right, the instructions Eragon received said “when all hope is lost, go to the vault of souls and speak your name”. Now given all we have learned from the past three books, I just don’t see Eragon losing hope and dropping out of the fight. Unless that is, Saphira or maybe Arya dies. Otherwise what could cause Eragon to stop? Does anyone else see this a possibility? Or has this been discussed before? Also does anyone think perhaps the vault of souls contains the souls of those who have died, and it is possible that Eragon will go there in all likelihood to bring back Saphira or Arya if they die?

  • MaggiMc

    HeXrider- I don’t think Eragon would need to “pair” with Murtagh. It would be too complicated if you could only be in love with a dragon/rider who had a rider/dragon that your “partner of heart and mind” was in love with too. The strong emotion thing would just mean it would be hard for the other if they felt hate, contempt, distrust etc.. for someone who was loved by their partner. I admit that Eragon’s emotions toward Murtagh are not fluffy bunnyish but he does pity and understand his brother. It wouldn’t be impossible for Saphira to mate with Thorn (I say mate with and not fall in love with because we don’t know how dragons work… are they a monogamous species?) though it would take a lot of writting to get to that point.

  • MaggiMc

    HeXrider- I don’t think Eragon would need to “pair” with Murtagh. It would be too complicated if you could only be in love with a dragon/rider who had a rider/dragon that your “partner of heart and mind” was in love with too. The strong emotion thing would just mean it would be hard for the other if they felt hate, contempt, distrust etc.. for someone who was loved by their partner. I admit that Eragon’s emotions toward Murtagh are not fluffy bunnyish but he does pity and understand his brother. It wouldn’t be impossible for Saphira to mate with Thorn (I say mate with and not fall in love with because we don’t know how dragons work… are they a monogamous species?) though it would take a lot of writting to get to that point.

  • ben

    drakor it cant be roran, that would make him immortal and after all that he went through to be with katrina it doesnt seem right.

  • ben

    drakor it cant be roran, that would make him immortal and after all that he went through to be with katrina it doesnt seem right.

  • HeXrider

    No, Saphira will not pair with thorn. Why? the reason i mentioned before. Through their mental link (yes they can supress it, but i don’t think so with very strong emotions) they share feelings for eachother’s mates. I dont see how eragon could “pair” with muthagh. So i repeat my former theorie:

    I think Saphira will pair with the new dragon when he is mature enough. And that arya will be his rider, so eragon and arya can “get together” too. they won’t have mixed up emotions or strange relations likethat. It seems the most logical to me.

    (sorry if i got to far by explaining tried to keep it desent)

  • HeXrider

    No, Saphira will not pair with thorn. Why? the reason i mentioned before. Through their mental link (yes they can supress it, but i don’t think so with very strong emotions) they share feelings for eachother’s mates. I dont see how eragon could “pair” with muthagh. So i repeat my former theorie:I think Saphira will pair with the new dragon when he is mature enough. And that arya will be his rider, so eragon and arya can “get together” too. they won’t have mixed up emotions or strange relations likethat. It seems the most logical to me.(sorry if i got to far by explaining tried to keep it desent)

  • hey.there

    is it possible that Roran and Katrina’s child might play a role?? or do you think that’s out of the picture?

  • hey.there

    is it possible that Roran and Katrina’s child might play a role?? or do you think that’s out of the picture?

  • vannet

    Baboo- on page 545 of Eldest, eragon has what he calls a “premonition” about the battle on the burning plains. He also has this premonition earlier in the book. But it does come true when he is facing murtagh and murtgah points his finger at eragon. In this instance, eragon does show signs of being able to see the future.

  • vannet

    Baboo- on page 545 of Eldest, eragon has what he calls a “premonition” about the battle on the burning plains. He also has this premonition earlier in the book. But it does come true when he is facing murtagh and murtgah points his finger at eragon. In this instance, eragon does show signs of being able to see the future.

  • drakor

    my theory is that eragon’s brother, Roran, will be the next dragon rider, i have read some theories of who is the next rider, but i believe it’s Roran, it just feels right, i don’t know

  • drakor

    my theory is that eragon’s brother, Roran, will be the next dragon rider, i have read some theories of who is the next rider, but i believe it’s Roran, it just feels right, i don’t know

  • Baboo

    (I tried posting this a few hours ago, but I don’t think it worked, so hopefully this isn’t a double post.)

    The only way that I can see Saphira not finding a mate/reproducing is if CP decided that the time of the dragons should end. I don’t want to see this, but we have to acknowledge it as a possibility.

    Eragon’s dream (from ch. “Deathwatch”) could be prophecizing this, with the last 2 dragons leaving the land forever (along with their riders and others). However, as many have suggested, the 2 dragons could easily be Saphira and her mate. This is the most plausible scenario. Finally, we must also acknowledge the possibility that this was simply a dream and nothing more. At no point in the series has Eragon displayed psychic abilities (whether awake or asleep). All of his prophecies that have come true were told by others (namely Solembum and Angela). Blagden also had a quasi-prophecy, and Eragon had visions of Arya in the cell (but that was more akin to scrying than future-telling).

    I really hope that the time of the dragons will not come to an end. It seems unfair that the dragons should leave (or go extinct) seeing as they (along with the dwarves) are native to the land and most other races are not. That certainly doesn’t mean it won’t happen, it has happened in other series and in real life situations in the past (where a native species gets displaced/wiped out).

    Still, it seems unjust.

  • Baboo

    (I tried posting this a few hours ago, but I don’t think it worked, so hopefully this isn’t a double post.)The only way that I can see Saphira not finding a mate/reproducing is if CP decided that the time of the dragons should end. I don’t want to see this, but we have to acknowledge it as a possibility.Eragon’s dream (from ch. “Deathwatch”) could be prophecizing this, with the last 2 dragons leaving the land forever (along with their riders and others). However, as many have suggested, the 2 dragons could easily be Saphira and her mate. This is the most plausible scenario. Finally, we must also acknowledge the possibility that this was simply a dream and nothing more. At no point in the series has Eragon displayed psychic abilities (whether awake or asleep). All of his prophecies that have come true were told by others (namely Solembum and Angela). Blagden also had a quasi-prophecy, and Eragon had visions of Arya in the cell (but that was more akin to scrying than future-telling).I really hope that the time of the dragons will not come to an end. It seems unfair that the dragons should leave (or go extinct) seeing as they (along with the dwarves) are native to the land and most other races are not. That certainly doesn’t mean it won’t happen, it has happened in other series and in real life situations in the past (where a native species gets displaced/wiped out).Still, it seems unjust.

  • zasekr1

    yo.blagden – just because eragon had a vision about a boat two ppl and two dragons and a guy on the shore doesnt mean that she will deffo pair up with something.. eragon could be anyone in that vision even the guy on the shore. since it hasnt happened we cant assume that one of the dragons is saphira and eragon is on the boat. anything could happen i know its not likely that she wont mate with someone but i wouldnt use the vision that he had as a justification of the view that she does mate.

  • zasekr1

    yo.blagden – just because eragon had a vision about a boat two ppl and two dragons and a guy on the shore doesnt mean that she will deffo pair up with something.. eragon could be anyone in that vision even the guy on the shore. since it hasnt happened we cant assume that one of the dragons is saphira and eragon is on the boat. anything could happen i know its not likely that she wont mate with someone but i wouldnt use the vision that he had as a justification of the view that she does mate.

  • Alice

    hehehe- Is that a joke? Because I seriously doubt that would ( if it even could) happen.

    I think Saphira will end up mating with Thorn, and maybe when the two of them start liking each other,Murtagh will be able to change. Perhaps first Thorn will start changing because of Saphira’s influence and then through him, Murtagh could learn how to change his name and help defeat Galby.

  • Alice

    hehehe- Is that a joke? Because I seriously doubt that would ( if it even could) happen. I think Saphira will end up mating with Thorn, and maybe when the two of them start liking each other,Murtagh will be able to change. Perhaps first Thorn will start changing because of Saphira’s influence and then through him, Murtagh could learn how to change his name and help defeat Galby.

  • yo.blagden

    hi Zasekr1 I think Saphira will pair with someone for sure.In ERAGON in the chapter Deathwatch Eragon sees a dream about a ship & 2 dragons in the sky.

  • yo.blagden

    hi Zasekr1 I think Saphira will pair with someone for sure.In ERAGON in the chapter Deathwatch Eragon sees a dream about a ship & 2 dragons in the sky.

  • yo.blagden

    Rhunon told Eragon that he imbued the sword with a portion of his personality.So Brisingr could be a part of his true name & maybe thats why Oromis said “I wonder”. How’s that for an idea?

  • yo.blagden

    Rhunon told Eragon that he imbued the sword with a portion of his personality.So Brisingr could be a part of his true name & maybe thats why Oromis said “I wonder”. How’s that for an idea?

  • zasekr1

    for some reason i dont think she is going to pair with any dragon… there will have to be some big reason as to why she doesnt though.

  • zasekr1

    for some reason i dont think she is going to pair with any dragon… there will have to be some big reason as to why she doesnt though.

  • Maawww

    i do beleive that Saphira will pair with Thorn, it is certain that she didnt pair with Glaedr unless he changed his mind and we dont know it yet 🙂

  • Maawww

    i do beleive that Saphira will pair with Thorn, it is certain that she didnt pair with Glaedr unless he changed his mind and we dont know it yet 🙂

  • eggs

    Is there any chance Saphira would pair with Thorn??

  • eggs

    Is there any chance Saphira would pair with Thorn??

  • invaderzim

    what if kuthians rock is the first eragons dragons heart of heart? when the dragons name was origionally brought up brom didnt know his name.

  • invaderzim

    what if kuthians rock is the first eragons dragons heart of heart? when the dragons name was origionally brought up brom didnt know his name.

  • Tulkas

    Mordor- Welcome back!

    (I couldn’t care less if I put on two posts in a row)

  • Tulkas

    Mordor- Welcome back!(I couldn’t care less if I put on two posts in a row)

  • Tulkas

    ShurtugalLiam- I still haven’t heard from her.

  • Tulkas

    ShurtugalLiam- I still haven’t heard from her.

  • Joanna<3

    Mordor
    Hey! haven’t seen you on here in a while 🙂 welcome back 🙂 we have not been debating any one particular thing… just many numbers of things and lots of different interesting theories 🙂

  • Joanna<3

    Mordor Hey! haven’t seen you on here in a while 🙂 welcome back 🙂 we have not been debating any one particular thing… just many numbers of things and lots of different interesting theories 🙂

  • Mordor

    386/7 comments! xP
    What in Alagaesia have you people been debating this time?
    xD

  • Mordor

    386/7 comments! xPWhat in Alagaesia have you people been debating this time? xD

  • Alice

    Bamboo- I wouldn’t exactly agree that he was “useless”. I think he has some weaker amounts of energy within himself that he can access. I do like your RoK theory; it’s very interesting.

  • Alice

    Bamboo- I wouldn’t exactly agree that he was “useless”. I think he has some weaker amounts of energy within himself that he can access. I do like your RoK theory; it’s very interesting.

  • Baboo

    Tulkas:

    Firstly, regarding Oromis’ ability to “store” magic I was meaning that he could not store it within himself (and I’m pretty sure that he couldn’t really produce it either. For example Eragon doesn’t need gemstones, or Saphira, or anything else to create and store regular amounts of magic, he can do it all on his own. The gemstones allow him to store excess quantities of magic Ilike reserves) and Saphira can transfer magic to him (or maybe through him would be more accurate). Oromis was more or less useless in magic without the mammoth store in his gemstone.

    Secondly, I think frodogamgee was meaning that Domia abr Wyrda could mention where the Rock of Kuthian (RoK) is, not specifically the Vault of Souls (VoS). Nobody except Eragon would think that the RoK was of any real significance. For example it could simply be telling a story/tale that has nothing at all to do with the VoS, say some guy on a quest for something. Along the way he may make camp at the RoK, or something stupid like that. Anybody else who read this would simply read right past it and think nothing of it. However, because of Solembum’s prophecy, Eragon knows that the VoS is located there.

  • Baboo

    Tulkas: Firstly, regarding Oromis’ ability to “store” magic I was meaning that he could not store it within himself (and I’m pretty sure that he couldn’t really produce it either. For example Eragon doesn’t need gemstones, or Saphira, or anything else to create and store regular amounts of magic, he can do it all on his own. The gemstones allow him to store excess quantities of magic Ilike reserves) and Saphira can transfer magic to him (or maybe through him would be more accurate). Oromis was more or less useless in magic without the mammoth store in his gemstone.Secondly, I think frodogamgee was meaning that Domia abr Wyrda could mention where the Rock of Kuthian (RoK) is, not specifically the Vault of Souls (VoS). Nobody except Eragon would think that the RoK was of any real significance. For example it could simply be telling a story/tale that has nothing at all to do with the VoS, say some guy on a quest for something. Along the way he may make camp at the RoK, or something stupid like that. Anybody else who read this would simply read right past it and think nothing of it. However, because of Solembum’s prophecy, Eragon knows that the VoS is located there.

  • ShurtugalLiam

    @Alice – Mair (mine and Tulkas’s friend Mair) no longer has facebook, but i am in contact with her and will be posting her views for her 🙂 as soon as i’ve emailed her all the different theories she said she will think of something and send it me 😛 lol!

    @Tulkas – i believe i made an error, my apologies lol. I assumed Alalgaesia was just the Broddring Kingdom.

    Welcome all new shurty posters 😀 as Joanna said we are all very friendly 🙂 And i like these theories, keep them coming 🙂 Especially the unexpected event, though i would cast a shadow on Ayra betraying the Varden and Eragon.
    heXrider – i thought about that too, and it does fit indeed, because the last dragon egg is male, which means they must free Greeni …. if they don’t i wonder what a dilemma Eragon would be in; would he allow Saphira to mate with Thorn?? I personally very much doubt Shurikan will escape Galby alive ….

  • ShurtugalLiam

    @Alice – Mair (mine and Tulkas’s friend Mair) no longer has facebook, but i am in contact with her and will be posting her views for her 🙂 as soon as i’ve emailed her all the different theories she said she will think of something and send it me 😛 [email protected] – i believe i made an error, my apologies lol. I assumed Alalgaesia was just the Broddring Kingdom.Welcome all new shurty posters 😀 as Joanna said we are all very friendly 🙂 And i like these theories, keep them coming 🙂 Especially the unexpected event, though i would cast a shadow on Ayra betraying the Varden and Eragon. heXrider – i thought about that too, and it does fit indeed, because the last dragon egg is male, which means they must free Greeni …. if they don’t i wonder what a dilemma Eragon would be in; would he allow Saphira to mate with Thorn?? I personally very much doubt Shurikan will escape Galby alive ….

  • HeXrider

    -Tulkas

    Correct magic exsisted before the dragons, but not like in the ancient language, so maybe the ancient language will come to fall.

    BTW i think that eragon and arya will fall in love, remember what saphira said: if eragon falls in love, it will have a great effect on her as well, so if arya becomes the new rider saphira could fall in love with the new dragon while eragon falls in love with arya, it fits like a puzzle.

    i still strongly believe that magic is somehow linked to the HoH’s or the AL but maybe it’s just a sort of magic amplifier

  • HeXrider

    -Tulkas
    Correct magic exsisted before the dragons, but not like in the ancient language, so maybe the ancient language will come to fall.

    BTW i think that eragon and arya will fall in love, remember what saphira said: if eragon falls in love, it will have a great effect on her as well, so if arya becomes the new rider saphira could fall in love with the new dragon while eragon falls in love with arya, it fits like a puzzle.

    i still strongly believe that magic is somehow linked to the HoH’s or the AL but maybe it’s just a sort of magic amplifier

  • Deidara

    Maybe Eragon the 1st and his dragon will be found guarding the vault of souls from the inside. We haven’t gotten ANY indication they are dead.

  • Deidara

    Maybe Eragon the 1st and his dragon will be found guarding the vault of souls from the inside. We haven’t gotten ANY indication they are dead.

  • Alice

    Maawww- I agree that something of great significance must occur, but I don’t think Arya betraying the Varden and Eragon is it. In the books we learn that Galby killed an elf that was a friend of hers and that she really liked that friend. I don’t think she would willingly work for him after he has killed people she was fond of. Not to mention what happened to her with Durza.
    Tulkas- Is there another? I was just wondering because if she has a facebook, I think I would want to talk to her. Specifically, I would like to discuss her veiws of CP. I haven’t really seen her on here much.

  • Alice

    Maawww- I agree that something of great significance must occur, but I don’t think Arya betraying the Varden and Eragon is it. In the books we learn that Galby killed an elf that was a friend of hers and that she really liked that friend. I don’t think she would willingly work for him after he has killed people she was fond of. Not to mention what happened to her with Durza. Tulkas- Is there another? I was just wondering because if she has a facebook, I think I would want to talk to her. Specifically, I would like to discuss her veiws of CP. I haven’t really seen her on here much.

  • Maawww

    i mean in the first book that Eragon rescued her

  • Maawww

    i mean in the first book that Eragon rescued her

  • Maawww

    something shocking must happen, something unexpected, what if Arya is working for Galby, and everything was set up that Eragon dreams about her, what if Galby was puting all those dreams into Eragon

  • Maawww

    something shocking must happen, something unexpected, what if Arya is working for Galby, and everything was set up that Eragon dreams about her, what if Galby was puting all those dreams into Eragon

  • Tulkas

    Alice- Is there another Mair/Mearad?
    Baboo- How did Oromis lose his ability to store magic? He stored magic in naegling, it just fell out of his hands.
    IBelieve- Contrary to what was said in Eragon, I’m not entirely sure that the true name of the AL is that powerful. Think of it. If you were to say “rabbit” in the AL, would all rabbits follow your bidding? No, they wouldn’t. If you say “love”, in the AL, do lovers follow your bidding? How, then, would saying “magic” make all magic users follow your commands?
    SHADEDRIVAL- They don’t use their own energy to control the stream of magic, the use their own energy to use magic. Perhaps Kuthian is the name of the old leader of the Dragons. The elves all know the name, they just can’t remember what it is. Likewise, the Dragon can only be conveyed by a series of short impressions… ok, ignore that theory, I just remembered that Brom said that their union with the Elves enables the Dragons to use language, so one born before that union would have no name.
    ShurtugalLiam- It was filmed as the Golden Compass because over here that’s the title of it, like Philosopher’s stone/sorcer’s stone, due to a misunderstanding with the Americian publisher, and yes, I have read them. Alagaesia is everything that is shown on the map, including Surda. Surda isn’t part of the Broddring Kingdom (I refuse to call the BK the Empire)

    The HoHs are in the Vault of Souls, which is in the Rock of Kuthian. The Rock of Kuthian could wherever there is a hollow rock.
    frodogamgee- Welcome! And the Dominance of Fate has been read by many people numerous times. If there was something of as great value as the Vault of Souls mentioned in it, Eragon would have been told about it.
    HeXrider- Your idea that the fate of magic is linked to the fate of the souls is flawed in that magic existed before the souls.
    iloveeragon- Welcome!

  • Tulkas

    Alice- Is there another Mair/Mearad?Baboo- How did Oromis lose his ability to store magic? He stored magic in naegling, it just fell out of his hands.IBelieve- Contrary to what was said in Eragon, I’m not entirely sure that the true name of the AL is that powerful. Think of it. If you were to say “rabbit” in the AL, would all rabbits follow your bidding? No, they wouldn’t. If you say “love”, in the AL, do lovers follow your bidding? How, then, would saying “magic” make all magic users follow your commands?SHADEDRIVAL- They don’t use their own energy to control the stream of magic, the use their own energy to use magic. Perhaps Kuthian is the name of the old leader of the Dragons. The elves all know the name, they just can’t remember what it is. Likewise, the Dragon can only be conveyed by a series of short impressions… ok, ignore that theory, I just remembered that Brom said that their union with the Elves enables the Dragons to use language, so one born before that union would have no name.ShurtugalLiam- It was filmed as the Golden Compass because over here that’s the title of it, like Philosopher’s stone/sorcer’s stone, due to a misunderstanding with the Americian publisher, and yes, I have read them. Alagaesia is everything that is shown on the map, including Surda. Surda isn’t part of the Broddring Kingdom (I refuse to call the BK the Empire)The HoHs are in the Vault of Souls, which is in the Rock of Kuthian. The Rock of Kuthian could wherever there is a hollow rock.frodogamgee- Welcome! And the Dominance of Fate has been read by many people numerous times. If there was something of as great value as the Vault of Souls mentioned in it, Eragon would have been told about it.HeXrider- Your idea that the fate of magic is linked to the fate of the souls is flawed in that magic existed before the souls.iloveeragon- Welcome!

  • chippawa

    I think it’s interesting that many here think that Eragon will be forced, compeled to leave alagaesia and never return. In eragons guide to alagaesia the first letter written is to a new dragon rider who just had an egg hatch for them. In the letter eragon states that he wishes that he and saphira could be there in person but that they chose to leave in search of something. As for everyones theories of roran being the new king, I feel the he doesn’t aspire to lead but would be very happy to have the war ended so he and katrina can return and rebuild carvahal

  • chippawa

    I think it’s interesting that many here think that Eragon will be forced, compeled to leave alagaesia and never return. In eragons guide to alagaesia the first letter written is to a new dragon rider who just had an egg hatch for them. In the letter eragon states that he wishes that he and saphira could be there in person but that they chose to leave in search of something. As for everyones theories of roran being the new king, I feel the he doesn’t aspire to lead but would be very happy to have the war ended so he and katrina can return and rebuild carvahal

  • MaggiMc

    Arya might be the new rider because her MAGIC is green… but whoever rides the dragon will have green magic, that’s just how it works. Her eye colour is not an accurate dragon rider predictor as Eragon’s eyes are not blue (brown) and Murtagh is not a shade (I think his eyes are brown too but I’m not in the mood to check) and therefore does not have bright red eyes.

  • MaggiMc

    Arya might be the new rider because her MAGIC is green… but whoever rides the dragon will have green magic, that’s just how it works. Her eye colour is not an accurate dragon rider predictor as Eragon’s eyes are not blue (brown) and Murtagh is not a shade (I think his eyes are brown too but I’m not in the mood to check) and therefore does not have bright red eyes.

  • iloveeragon

    oh btw im new 2 all of this but i did read all the comments that have been posted. some theories r really good. so im sorry if there r any typos

  • iloveeragon

    oh btw im new 2 all of this but i did read all the comments that have been posted. some theories r really good. so im sorry if there r any typos

  • iloveeragon

    heXrider i really like ur theory.

    although i wish that roran will become king and arya and eraon will finally fall in love with each other.

  • iloveeragon

    heXrider i really like ur theory.
    although i wish that roran will become king and arya and eraon will finally fall in love with each other.

  • HeXrider

    I also theorised that the vault of souls should be somehow linked to galby’s power, thus to the HoH’s. i think what eragon will do is release the dragons souls from their HoH’s after so much torture from galby (by use of the vault). then galby will lose so much power, he will be no match for three dragons opposite to him. (murtagh, eragon and the third)(yes i think murt will change sides).

    Then in an epic battle murtagh will die, and eragon and (arya) (maybe she’s te third) Will leave alagaesia after a new king is crowned.

    the urgals will have their piece of land and the new king will rule al races equally, in some sort of pact.

    yeah ow, by releasing the souls magic in general will vanish so no-one can abuse it from now on.

    about dragons and so? i think we will have dragon babies :p i dont think CP will let them die out alltogether.

    Maybe it’s too obvious, but just thinking out loud here

  • HeXrider

    I also theorised that the vault of souls should be somehow linked to galby’s power, thus to the HoH’s. i think what eragon will do is release the dragons souls from their HoH’s after so much torture from galby (by use of the vault). then galby will lose so much power, he will be no match for three dragons opposite to him. (murtagh, eragon and the third)(yes i think murt will change sides). Then in an epic battle murtagh will die, and eragon and (arya) (maybe she’s te third) Will leave alagaesia after a new king is crowned.the urgals will have their piece of land and the new king will rule al races equally, in some sort of pact.yeah ow, by releasing the souls magic in general will vanish so no-one can abuse it from now on. about dragons and so? i think we will have dragon babies :p i dont think CP will let them die out alltogether.Maybe it’s too obvious, but just thinking out loud here

  • Joanna<3

    frodogamgee
    Hello, and welcome here 😀
    I see we have another LOTR fan (there are many of us here) XD and, don’t worry we won’t tear you to shreds… All of us on here are polite and tactful for the most part lol 🙂

  • Joanna<3

    frodogamgee Hello, and welcome here 😀 I see we have another LOTR fan (there are many of us here) XD and, don’t worry we won’t tear you to shreds… All of us on here are polite and tactful for the most part lol 🙂

  • frodogamgee

    hey…
    the book (dominance of fate) records an untainted history of alagaesia…jeod’s research is a clue! this book is gonna tell eragon about the rock of kuthian and vault of souls…just sayin’

    waddup i’m new please don’t tear me to shreds lol

  • frodogamgee

    hey…the book (dominance of fate) records an untainted history of alagaesia…jeod’s research is a clue! this book is gonna tell eragon about the rock of kuthian and vault of souls…just sayin’waddup i’m new please don’t tear me to shreds lol

  • brendanpratt

    I agree that eragon shouldn’t have as much power as galby. I also thing the last dragon will be arya’s because she has green eyes. Then it will be a 2v2 unless Murtagh changes his real name. I think the vault of souls will be loaded dragons HoH because the heart of hearts are kinda like souls correct me if im wrong

  • brendanpratt

    I agree that eragon shouldn’t have as much power as galby. I also thing the last dragon will be arya’s because she has green eyes. Then it will be a 2v2 unless Murtagh changes his real name. I think the vault of souls will be loaded dragons HoH because the heart of hearts are kinda like souls correct me if im wrong

  • SHADEDRIVAL

    I was thinking that the barrier was like a magical door type thing on Vorengaurd. Im thinking thats why the DRs set up shop there. Also i think he felt it in his stomach because its something to do with a like chi spot my friend and i are the ones who were theorizing and he had the explanition for that. Anyway Saphiras eldunari is a physical thing. The monoa tree couldnt jusst will it to be gone and the stone vanishes. Also saphira says she can sense it. Why wouldnt she say something if this feeling all of a sudden disappeared.

  • SHADEDRIVAL

    I was thinking that the barrier was like a magical door type thing on Vorengaurd. Im thinking thats why the DRs set up shop there. Also i think he felt it in his stomach because its something to do with a like chi spot my friend and i are the ones who were theorizing and he had the explanition for that. Anyway Saphiras eldunari is a physical thing. The monoa tree couldnt jusst will it to be gone and the stone vanishes. Also saphira says she can sense it. Why wouldnt she say something if this feeling all of a sudden disappeared.

  • 7thwordofpower

    I Think it will be extremely tough to kill galby. Even if he is seperated from the HOHs/
    1. could have sucked all there strength away and put into a diamond or jewel letting thm recharge and repeating he process.Its been a hundred years.not counting the 40 yrs it took him to break the dragons minds. Then then for the next 60 yrs he filled up 11-12 times more times. He is going to be very very very hard to beat.Its lik me going up aginst muhammad ali the greatest boxer of all time in his prime.
    2. eragon wastes all his energy on sometime meaningless things he better ind the vault of souls quik like or he is going to be dead and saphira pimped.

  • 7thwordofpower

    I Think it will be extremely tough to kill galby. Even if he is seperated from the HOHs/1. could have sucked all there strength away and put into a diamond or jewel letting thm recharge and repeating he process.Its been a hundred years.not counting the 40 yrs it took him to break the dragons minds. Then then for the next 60 yrs he filled up 11-12 times more times. He is going to be very very very hard to beat.Its lik me going up aginst muhammad ali the greatest boxer of all time in his prime.2. eragon wastes all his energy on sometime meaningless things he better ind the vault of souls quik like or he is going to be dead and saphira pimped.